Meet Me in Another Life by Catriona Silvey
Mr Five Word TL:DR Review : Took me completely by surprise

Meet Me in Another Life is a book that will defy your expectations, it will feel familiar, you’ll think you’ve got it nailed down, you’ll know exactly what’s going on here (well, sort of) right up until that moment of revelation when the author shows you that you knew nothing at all. In between times, before that moment of disclosure, we have a story, that feels like a tale of reincarnation two people born again and again into each other’s timeline, playing different roles each time, lovers, teacher and student, parent and child, and then some more. They’re not always born in the same place, there is constantly a disparity in where they find themselves, and yet, inexplicably they are drawn together through a shared desire to know more. Let’s start at the beginning.
As the story kicks off we meet Thora and Santi in what appears to be their first meeting. It doesn’t go particularly well and to an extent this is something that will be repeated over and over again in a kind of Groundhog Day style. Don’t be put off though, sometimes they live full lives – not always together but always kind of in orbit around each other.
Now, I’m not going to say anything more about the story because, and I know I use this a lot, but it really could lead to spoilers and seriously you need to read this with as little knowledge beforehand as possible as that will only play more into the intrigue.
So, what can I discuss here today. Well, a few things.
Overall feelings. I liked this very much, I particularly like it given the ending – which isn’t to say I didn’t like the earlier chapters – just that the ending gives you a whole new bunch of things to think about plus a desire to backtrack and see what you missed along the way because you can rest assured that there is a trail of breadcrumbs just waiting to be pecked up by those hungry enough to pay attention. I confess, I didn’t have the slightest notion so there we go – what can I say, I missed the breadcrumbs.
Characters. Well, if you love characters that are well developed you’ll love these two. Let’s just be honest, the author has a lot of opportunity to teach us different aspects to their nature, to show them in a good light or a not so good light. To reinvent them on a constant basis but with enough consistencies to make them familiar to us in every iteration. It’s fantastic really because it plays into the whole ethos of just how well can you really know someone? How long does it take to really know that person? A lifetime – well, Thora and Santi have a whole bunch of lifetimes and they’re still learning about each other at the end of the book.
The setting. Another really cool part of this – both characters are repeatedly drawn to the same place. It’s like a force or irrepressible magnetism that they simply can’t deny. Set in Cologne we find ourselves visiting over and over to such an extent that it becomes familiar, I feel like I could see the streets, the bars, the clock tower in my own mind.
Let’s not get away from those certain little things that are familiar. Sometimes ‘familiar’ is comforting and there are definitely elements here that will feel like ‘things’ you know. Obviously the constant reincarnations have a Life After Life feel. The way that the two characters arrive at different points and places kind of reminded me a little of The Time Traveller’s Wife, the repetitive nature of certain aspects could be likened to Groundhog Day, the little inconsistencies experienced in each episode – well, I’m sure you can see where I’m going with this. There are undeniably familiar elements to this story but not only does it stand on it’s own two feet – primarily because of this winning combination between science and theology that is constantly discussed and argued by Thora and Santi, one determined to believe in fate and miracles, the other sticking to science and proven things together – but, it evolves in a direction that I never saw coming.
On top of this, the story is packed with emotion which persists right up to the ending where… well, you’ll just have to read it and find out for yourself.
In terms of criticisms. Okay, well, firstly, I cannot deny that this feels like a series of short stories with recurring characters. Now, I’m not a lover of short stories so this could have become very old very fast for me, however, I think the author managed to get the timing perfect in that just as I was starting to feel a little ‘same old/same old’ she started to throw in changes and this is when the real mystery began. The same thing could also be said of the repetitive nature of certain elements – this definitely had the capacity to become tiresome and yet I didn’t find it to be so because the author makes subtle changes all the time which lent it a fascinating aspect.
So criticisms. that aren’t really criticisms at all, put to one side. Yes, this was a very good, entertaining, mysterious, fascinating and slightly heartbreaking read.
I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.
The above is my own opinion.
My rating 4.5 of 5 stars
A Dark and Secret Place by Jen Williams
My Five Word TL:DR Review : A Little Slow to Start

A Dark and Secret Place is the first foray into thriller/mystery by an author whose body of fantasy work I love and as such this was also an impressive book although I didn’t love it quite as much as the author’s other books.
As the book begins we make the gruesome discovery of a dead woman, the body mutilated and staged in the horrific style used previously by the notorious serial killer Michael Reeve, known as The Red Wolf, except Reeve was caught and has been in prison since.
At the same time we meet Heather Evans. Heather is returning to her family home. A home she left as a teenager and hasn’t visited since. Heather and her mother shared a strained relationship and Heather’s return has been brought about by the sad news that her mother has commited suicide. Heather struggles to understand why her mother would take her own life, the suicide note itself is puzzling, but when she discovers a stack of letters between her mother and the serial killer the plot thickens.
Heather takes the letters to the police and becomes caught up in the hunt for a copycat killer – involving visits to the Red Wolf himself to try and discover if he is involved.
The story is told in two timelines. We have Heather’s current timeline and we jump back to a young version of Michael.
This one does get off to a fairly slow start but I didn’t have a problem with the pace to be honest. It slowly becomes obvious that Heather is the centre of something very odd. She finds strange things in the house, there’s a creepy vibe to the place and sightings of a stranger lurking in the rear garden. To be honest I don’t think I could have stayed there so Heather was certainly a lot braver than I would have been. Clearly somebody was leaving these ‘mysterious’ things for her and there was a tension about this element to the tale that was decidedly spooky.
The flashbacks to Michael were also a bit unnerving and dark in nature but I’m not going to discuss those here.
We also have the visits to prison where Heather visits with Michael in a desperate bid by the police to uncover anything about the new murderer. The visits don’t turn out to be terribly helpful with Michael often behaving rather obtuse, spouting stories that resemble gruesome fairytales. Michael has a very strange intensity to him that was a little unnerving and I couldn’t help having this odd ‘Silence of the Lambs’ vibe.
The story escalates when Heather decides to take matters into her own hands and the final revelations become a little frantic.
I liked this one, there are some good ideas here and the story is well delivered. However, I didn’t love this one and I’m not sure that I can put my finger on why that is. I think on the face of it I struggled to connect with Heather. She could be a little bit prickly and in spite of her obvious intelligence she made some very dubious and risky decisions. I was mystified by one of her decisions in particular but,again, I won’t elaborate.
I think my slight hesitation in falling for this was a slight disparity between the first half of the book and the second They didn’t seem to gel as well as I would have liked. The ending had an almost chaotic feel with all sorts of elements being woven into the storyline. And the really odd thing is that now, reflecting on the story itself to write this review I struggle to recall some of the final revelations which is a really strange experience for me.
Overall, though, I did like this, it was a very easy read, gripping in fact, and I would love to see what the author comes up with next.
I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.
My rating 3.5 of 5 stars.
Booking Ahead/Weekly Wrap Up
11 July 2021
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Booking Ahead, Caffeinated Reviewer, Weekly wrap up

I’m trying to get back into the habit of doing a round-up of the week just completed and also take a look at my plans for the forthcoming week. I rather got out of the habit of doing this last year but I would like to reinstate this type of post as I feel it keeps me on track. So, I’m linking up to The Sunday Post over at Kimberly’s Caffeinated Reviewer. Without further ado:
Last week:
Haha – this week I had the sudden lightbulb moment that no matter how much I try to forge ahead I will always be chasing my tail (just to be clear – I don’t have a tail!). So, I just need to chill I think and come to terms with the fact that I will always have four or five books waiting to be reviewed – and in fact, that’s a good thing in some respects because I’ll always have content so, yay. This week I’ve read two books – the first SPFBO book from batch 2 and I went off plan a little (but still chose a review book) – Meet Me In Another Life by Catriona Silvey. I’m still slowly making my way through Empire’s Ruin by Brian Staveley which really is a book to savour – it makes me happy reading this book because it’s so good.
I’m aiming to read The 22 Murders of Madison May by Max Barry and The Retreat by Elisabeth de Mariaffi. I need to get back on track with my buddy reads too as I’ve been a little lacking in both of those recently.
Reviews Posted since last Sunday:
- The Rising Tide by Sam Lloyd
- The Final Girl Support Group by Grady Hendrix
- Equal Rites by Terry Pratchett
Forthcoming Reviews:
- Murder of Crows by Anne Bishop
- A Dark and Secret Place by Jen Williams
- The Past is Red by Catherynne M Valente
- Berserker by Dimitrios Gkirgkiris
- Meet Me in Another Life by Catriona Silvey
#SPFBO Saturday : Interview with Tim Hardie, author of Hall of Bones

As part of the SPFBO Competition each weekend I am hoping to post guest blog posts inviting authors taking part in the competition to visit my blog to either write an article, discuss covers, take part in an interview or post an excerpt or teaser for their work. If you’d like to pay me a visit then don’t forget to leave me a comment 😀
This weekend I’m really pleased to welcome Tim Hardie to my blog. Tim is the author of Hall of Bones, the first book in The Brotherhood of the Eagle series. Hall of Bones is one of the submissions allocated to Lynnsbooks/The Critiquing Chemist.
First things first – a warm welcome to Tim and my thanks for agreeing to take part in an interview. I will also be sharing two excerpts from Hall of Bones at a future date so keep your eyes peeled:
***
Can you give us a short introduction to Hall of Bones?

Thanks for the invitation to take part.
Hall of Bones is the first of four planned books in an epic fantasy series called The Brotherhood of the Eagle. It’s a Viking-inspired tale but the fantasy setting has its own unique history and mythology. The story’s central character is Rothgar Kolfinnarson, the second son of the chief of his clan, and the challenges he faces when his people come under threat from their neighbouring rivals.
Hall of Bones is a debut but you mention on your blog that you have written other books. Do you think you’ll return and dust any of those off at any point? What lessons did you learn from those earlier books?
My first novel, called The Final Seer, took me nearly five years to write and I don’t think I’ll return to it because it’s not very good! It’s still an important part of my writing journey because The Final Seer was the book where I learned a lot of hard lessons. In short, I completely underestimated the level of endurance and attention to detail required to write a good novel.
That first draft was panster from start to finish and involved unnecessary sub-plots and side characters (which ultimately had to be cut), appallingly clunky dialogue, anguished periods of writer’s block and an unfathomable main story. It was meant to be Firefly set in medieval times and I have a lot of affection for that novel but, in the end, my heart wasn’t in continuing the story.
It also was a bit dated in terms of the story and characters, which was basically the feedback I received when I submitted it to a literary agent. He (rightly) rejected the story but in his rejection email he kindly put me on to some of the current crop of fantasy writers (including Joe Abercrombie, Mark Lawrence and John Gwynne). I read those authors and realised there was a different way to approach a fantasy novel. Hall of Bones was the novel I wrote next, applying those lessons and taking a tighter approach to plotting as well as spending more time developing distinctive and believable characters.
The other legacy from The Final Seer was the fantasy world of Amuran, which I used as the setting for Hall of Bones. So a lot of that novel’s background and in particular the early history and mythology provided the foundations for Hall of Bones.
How do you strike a balance between including all your world building or leaving some of it out to keep the pace more punchy?
I leave out a lot more than I include. For example, there are various fantasy races in Amuran that don’t feature at all in Hall of Bones (they were prominent in The Final Seer, which was set in a different location). Detailed world building is important, because it provides depth to the setting you’ve created as an author. This fires my imagination as I write. For example, the early history of Amuran provided the driving force behind the underlying narrative for Hall of Bones. Generally, my rule of thumb is if it’s not important or relevant to the plot (either novel or series) then it shouldn’t be included. Sometimes I incorporate extra elements just to add a bit of colour to a scene and to make it clear these events are taking place in a much larger world. That’s an indulgence, though, and I have to restrain myself from using that too often.
From first draft to finished article – how did the book change during the course of writing and publishing? Did you have to cut certain storylines for example or were there any surprises that you hadn’t imagined?
I think Hall of Bones was where I found my voice as an author, rather than imitating other writers. Unlike my previous novel, it didn’t need any major cuts or rewrites. However, it was full of annoyingly repetitive phrases and sentence structures and in need of an overall tightening of the text. Those bad habits had to be ironed out during the editing phase, which I worked on with my agent prior to independent publication.
Although I carefully plotted the novel I had a lot of new ideas as I was writing it. I think that’s the best part of creative writing, where the characters take the story off in an unexpected direction. For example, the magical elements of the story weren’t in the original plotline at all – they were additions that came to me later that are now integral to the plot. One minor character, the Reavesburg warrior called Djuri, just wandered into the book without any warning and he’s become one of my favourites as the series has progressed. Plotting is an important part of my process but it’s important not to lose that creative spark. It’s brilliant when those things come together and your own novel surprises you completely.
Writing is lonely and self publishing even more so as you have to undertake tasks that wouldn’t fall to you if your book was traditionally published. How do you keep yourself motivated? How do you achieve a work/life balance?
My main motivation comes from seeing how much readers enjoy my writing. It’s small beginnings but I’m slowly finding my audience and that’s what keeps me going. Of course, not everyone will love my writing and that’s absolutely fine because creative writing is subjective and different readers will enjoy different things. The key thing is to write your own books in your own style for the people who enjoy what you do.
I’ve really valued the support I’ve gained from other writers. This competition has already helped me make some links with other contestants and I’ve found social media a fantastic way to make connections. Authors go through many of the same challenges and I’ve found the writing community to be a tremendously supportive place. I’ve learned a lot from other people and that’s really helped me in approaching my own writing.
Like most authors, I have a job that pays the bills, so I don’t write as often as I would like. I’ve had to build a writing routine that helps me write when my energy levels are at their highest, which means early starts at the weekend and doing creative writing at the beginning of the working week, leaving other author related stuff (blogs, promo materials, social media) towards the end. I also have a family (a very patient, understanding and supportive one) who need my time and attention. Whilst writing is important to me it’s not the only thing in my life so, as your question suggests, it’s all about finding that balance.
Can you share with us any information about the next instalment? In particular, do you intend to go further afield and expand on the territories beyond Laskar?
The second book, Sundered Souls, is due out later this summer. I don’t want to say too much and spoil things for people who haven’t read Hall of Bones but the stakes are higher in the next instalment and our characters find themselves ill-prepared as they face a new enemy. I think the other key theme in the sequel is the question of loyalty, as the characters face a difficult choice over which side to support in the conflict that begins during Hall of Bones. This aspect gave me some of my best material when writing Sundered Souls.
The Brotherhood of the Eagle is set primarily in the region of Laskar, although the series does take the reader to the different territories of the clans as the story progresses. Again, this is about using the world building necessary to tell the story. Those wider locations (you can find the maps on my website) are fertile ground for future stories but they don’t feature prominently in The Brotherhood of the Eagle.
In terms of the next instalment – which book would you say has been the most difficult to write and why?
Hall of Bones was hard to write because I was still learning my craft. Although there weren’t big structural rewrites, it went through a lot of editing phases to arrive at the version I published. It took me nearly four years to complete the first draft. Sundered Souls was easier as I’d already established the situation and the characters, so it was a case of diving back in and continuing the story and it only took me 18 months to write. Personally, I think it’s a better book than Hall of Bones (Should I be saying that? Too late!) as I was able to apply everything I’d learned when writing the sequel.
However, when I wrote the third book in the series, Lost Gods, despite all my preparation I didn’t exercise enough control on the ideas that came to me as I was writing. The first draft of that book came in at 200,000 words and I think I’m going to have to cut 50,000 words to focus on the main story rather than the sub-plots. That’s getting close to a discarded novel in its own right! It’s probably my biggest editing challenge so far, so I’d say Lost Gods has proved the most difficult book of the series so far.
Readers frequently highlight particular quotes that resonate with them – do you have any favourite quotes from Hall of Bones that you can share?
I find this really interesting because I don’t remember anything I’ve written! Although I know the plot, the characters and the emotional journey I take them on if you asked me in the street to quote a single line of text, I don’t think I could do it. The novel is more about the feelings and emotions it evokes in me. I’ll sound like a crazy person to non-writers at this point, but to me the characters are real and I feel their triumphs and their failures as if they were my own. It’s this stuff that tends to resonate with me, rather than the specifics.
All that said, I’ve noticed my readers have picked up their favourite quotes and highlighted them in their reviews, which I love to see. The character of Etta, the aged shadowy spymaster of the Reavesburg Clan who orchestrates so much behind the scenes, seems to be someone my readers are drawn to and she’s the one they quote. These seem to be their favourites:
“If you understand your people’s hearts, possess wisdom and learn from the knowledge of your forefathers your life will be a long one.”
“A clan chief who rules only with the sword sleeps wakefully and their life is short”
As a young boy, Rothgar’s response to Etta’s attempt to tutor him and impart her wisdom offers an alternative perspective:
“I still prefer the sword to the slate, Etta. Darri never sings great ballads about the men who knew all their letters.”
Finally, in terms of your own reading, which three authors have you read the most? What are you currently reading? What three books would you have no hesitation in recommending?
I’ve devoured books by many different authors, so it’s hard to narrow that down to three. In terms of sheer volume, it would be Ian Rankin’s Inspector Rebus series. The central character is so well written and the setting of Edinburgh, one of my favourite cities, feels like a person in its own right. Iain M Banks’ Culture novels (and his ‘mainstream’ output too, which is also phenomenal) are just fantastic and I loved how he combined laugh out loud humour, big concepts and thrilling space opera high jinks in his books. There’s really nothing else like them. More recently, I’ve loved Joe Abercrombie’s books, especially The First Law trilogy, and they were definitely a big influence on my own writing.
My current read is Dark Oak by Jacob Sannox, who coincidentally was an SPFBO Semi Finalist from your blog group back in 2018. What I love about this book is how he’s reversed the typical fantasy tropes by beginning his story with the defeat of the archetypal Dark Lord, focussing on all the chaos, confusion and grey moral choices following that event. It makes for an intriguing and compelling read.
In terms of recommendations beyond the books I’ve already mentioned, I’d say you should look at Gareth L Powell’s Embers of War sci-fi series, which is one of the few books I’ve found that fills the huge gap left by Iain M Banks’ untimely passing. I also can’t recommend Dark Eden by Chris Beckett highly enough. It’s a hypnotic, thought-provoking sci-fi story that stayed with me for days after I finished reading it. If I’m limited to three (this is cruel), I’ll give my final recommendation to We Men of Ash and Shadow by H L Tinsley. I was excited when I started reading this book because the author’s voice was so strong and the gaslamp fantasy world she created, with its various nefarious characters, was incredibly well-realised. Holly’s a fellow competitor in this year’s SPFBO contest and I really hope she does well. Her book is a great example of the sheer talent of many independently published authors at the moment.
Tim – thank you again for visiting with me today. I loved your answers, they’re insightful and humorous and I hope readers will enjoy reading them as much as I did.
***
Tim Hardie grew up in the seaside town of Southport during the 1970s and 1980s. This was before anyone had even heard of the internet and Dungeons & Dragons was cutting edge. Living in a house where every available wall was given over to bookshelves, he discovered fantasy writers like JRR Tolkien, Michael Moorcock, Ursula Le Guin, Alan Garner, Stephen Donaldson and Susan Cooper. Those stories led him into the science fiction worlds created by Frank Herbert, Philip K Dick, Arthur C Clarke and HP Lovecraft.
After training to become a lawyer Tim lived in London for three years before moving to Yorkshire in 1999, where he has worked ever since in a variety of legal, commercial, financial and management roles. His writing began as a hobby in his early twenties and has gradually grown into something else that now threatens to derail his promising career.
Tim writes epic fantasy that will appeal to fans of Joe Abercrombie, John Gwynne and Robin Hobb.
I will be posting a couple of excerpts from Hall of Bones very soon so watch this space!
Friday Face Off : A Wicked Grin
9 July 2021
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Books by Proxy, Friday Face off, Gregory Maguire, Wiced

Here we are again with the Friday Face Off meme created by Books by Proxy . This is a great opportunity to feature some of your favourite book covers. The rules are fairly simple each week, following a predetermined theme (list below) choose a book (this doesn’t have to be a book that you’ve read), compare a couple of the different covers available for that particular book and choose your favourite. Future’s themes are listed below – if you have a cover in mind that you’re really wanting to share then feel free to leave a comment about a future suggested theme. I’ve also listed events that take place during the year, that I’m aware of, so you can link up your covers – if you’re aware of any events that you think I should include then give me a shout.
This week’s theme:
A Wicked Grin
For once, I knew exactly which book I had in mind for this week’s theme. It’s perfect in terms of title and cover. It’s a book I haven’t read even though I picked up a copy many years ago. Wicked by Gregory Maguire. And, here are the covers:
And, well I had to go with the cover I find the most familiar this week:

Do you have a favourite?
I’ve updated the list now to include themes for next year. If you know of an event that’s coming up let me know and I’ll try and include covers that work for the event itself so that you can link up to the Friday Face Off and, as always, if you wish to submit an idea then leave me a comment – or if you’d like to host a week then simply let me know. Also, I would just mention that it’s very possible that some of these might be repeats from previous FFOs although I have tried to invent more ‘open ended’ prompt that can be interpreted differently and also prompts that relate to emotions. Finally, don’t struggle with any of these, this is meant to be a fun way of highlighting books. If you can’t come up with a book you think fits for a particular week use a freebie – perhaps a recent read for example:
Next week – Books with ‘book’ in the title
2021
July
16th – Books with ‘book’ in the title
23rd – A Black Hole – could be in the universe or going deep into the ground
30th – Chaos – maybe too much going on in this one
August
6th – “They cluck their thick tongues, and shake their heads and suggest, os so very delicately!” – The Motel
13th – A favourite holiday read
20th – Dressed to kill (could be literally someone dressed to kill, or someone dressed up for a big night out
27th – Sunbathing or on the beach
September (RIP event)
3rd – 1920s feel, noir detective
10th – I’m Henry the Eighth I am – let’s look at Kings or other Emperors/rulers
17th – Books with ‘Murder’ in the title
24th – A favourite thriller
October
1st – A Halloween read
8th – Chills – anything at all that almost makes you too scared to pick up the book (your own pet hate)
15th – Your favourite book of magic
22nd – Books with ‘Queen’ in the title
29th – Must be gothic
November – Sci Fi Month
5th – Your earliest sci-fi read or the first sci-fi you reviewed
12th – A book with ‘star’ in the title
19th – Futuristic vista
26th – A Black Hole – in the universe or going deep into the ground
December
3rd – Windswept, the classic figure, stood majestically, with wind blowing out in a fetching way
10th – A fairytale retold
17th – Winter Solstice approaching – anything cold and seasonal
24th – All things fire – red hair, red covers, fire breathing dragons, simply fire?
31st – What’s your catnip – if it’s on a cover you have to pick it up



