Today is the third week of a four week readalong of Chimes at Midnight by Seanan McGuire. How I’m loving this series and it feels as though each book just keeps adding more depth to the world created by McGuire. Feel free to join us. A Goodreads page is set up here or simply jump in with the comments. Also, be aware that spoilers will be lurking below so be careful!
This week Lisa at Over the Effing Rainbow is providing the questions so lets get a budge on:
1. “We took titles as a warning. ‘Stay away. Here there be monsters.'”
This week we learn the Luidaeg’s original name, and also that she really does, perhaps, have her sneaky ways of answering some of Toby’s unasked questions – or starting to, anyway. What speculations are you drawing from what we learn in Toby’s blood-vision? Given this teaser, what questions might you ask the Luidaeg if you were in Toby’s shoes.
Personally, if I was in Toby’s shoes I’d be gobbling those frozen blood pills down like they were candy in search of questions – which would probably be very unwise. I’m getting from these flashbacks, and how ingenious of the Luidaeg by the way to come up with that, that Toby’s mum was very much trying to protect Toby – I don’t know if I’ve picked everything up but clearly Armandine is very powerful and clearly sometimes being so powerful is a risky business – why else would the other firstborn have the titles and ‘stay away. Here there be Monsters’ thing going on. But, we had a different hint in this section – I think I would be asking just exactly who my father was if I was Toby – we know that one king already tried to hide his family to save them – what if Toby’s father wasn’t human. Toby could be very powerful and maybe a potential threat to others – maybe in danger. I don’t know, I’m jumping around all over the place but I’m beginning to wonder if Toby really is a changeling.
2. “I know a lot about being royal.”
Surprise! So the truth about Quentin’s background is out, and I’ve got to know: did you suspect this at all or did it in fact surprise you? Any predictions for the young squire-prince going forward from here?
I was completely surprised. I’ve been making a lot of surprises about Toby but I really didn’t follow the breadcrumbs with Quentin and I was gobsmacked. At least I didn’t have a pie in the face! I really don’t know – will he be required to complete his time as a squire? I can’t see how that would work really. It feels like Toby has already started to change towards him and although she has always been a little bit protective I think she will feel differently towards him. I don’t think it will affect their friendship – just maybe the way she feels about the whole situation or how comfortable she is ordering him around. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think Toby changes the way the acts around people depending on their status, I just think that knowing him to be a prince now will just change things. You can’t ‘unknow’ it can you? Perhaps Quentin could help Arden to become accustomed to her new role? I definitely think that he would be a champion for Toby in the future which can’t be a bad thing – he’s seen how she works and how fair she is so…
3. “You protect your family by making the world a better place for them to live. Not by running away.”
Toby’s got some hard truths for Arden, and well she should know about them… Do you think Arden will stand by her choice here? And what do you think of October Daye looking set up to have the ear of the next Queen in the Mists?
Yes, for once I can see that maybe Toby won’t be hated by the Queen in the Mists – of course Arden will be a relatively innocent Queen – in terms of what she doesn’t know, she’s led a very innocent life in terms of the fae after all – I think she will need somebody like Toby, who tells her things the way they really are and doesn’t bow and scrape or curry favour or seek power. In terms of Toby – having the ear of the Queen probably won’t make a difference – she’s not really seeking power or titles is she?
4. There’s plenty more to chew on in these chapters, but what parts stand out the most for you, and why?
So much in these chapters. Where to start. This book is so good. I pretty much know that things are going to get so much worse before they get better or maybe that’s my pessimism sneaking in. I want to know more about Quentin for a start. Tybalt and Toby – very revealing that Toby finally has found her place – no more floundering around for her – she’s chosen where she wants to be and that might come with sadness over what she’s leaving behind but she is ready to move forward. May – I think she might be getting ready to leave Toby and set up with Jazz but I could be wrong. She’s always ready to step in and I think she’ll always be there for Toby but the scene where she was leaving with Toby to go to Muir and she was looking back at the house worrying about Jazz, well, I couldn’t help thinking that the two of them are becoming very serious and ready to move on together. I loved reading about the Cu Sidhe – dog fae! Especially winding down the window on Danny’s cab – why do dogs love to stick their heads out of car windows – which basically means a blast of cold air in the face – but yet they hate it if you blow in their face! What is that. Why? And the Luidaeg – I can’t help thinking that everything could be improved by her appearance. So tetchy and grumpy and pushing people around – but underneath it all – yeah, she’s still a grumpy puss, but she has heart.
Today is the third week for our readalong of A Closed and Common Orbit by Becky Chambers.
Here’s the schedule:
Week 1: Friday 2nd December – Start of Part 1 up to Page 94 (“…yellow, silver, white…”), hosted by Over the Effing Rainbow
Week 2: Friday 9th December – Page 95 (Jane, Age 10 “Jane was still tired…”) to End of Part 1, hosted by imyril at There’s Always Room For One More
Week 3: Friday 16th December – all of Part 2, hosted by Lynn at Lynn’s Book Blog
Week 4: Friday 23rd December – Part 3 to End, hosted by Mogsy at The BiblioSanctum
To the Q&A with the customary spoiler warning! Be warned folks, spoilers will be lurking. And, feel free to dive in with your comments.
1. Imriel spends the night at Melisande’s before Solon is to do his spell. Melisande tells Imriel that she would like it if, after all this, he would find it in his heart to come visit her again. Do you think he will? What would that reunion be like?
Yes, I think he will visit her again. I don’t really know why but I have a feeling that his feelings towards her may be softened somewhat, especially now he’s met her again and heard her talk – not to mention that very frank conversation they had when they looked at each others weaknesses or fault lines.
2. Solon tells Imriel to “put Imriel away” and “make him small…like a tiny, tiny seed.” How much of Imriel remains inside “Leander” once the spell is complete?
I must confess this part of the story was so strange following in the mind of Leander! Some of his thoughts don’t exactly portray him in the best light! But, yes, I do think there is obviously quite a bit of Imriel’s personality shining through. I think the desire to meet Sidonie and his thinking that he might be falling in lover with her – I think that’s obviously persuaded by Imriel – maybe not directly but I just can’t help feeling that somehow Imriel’s love is determined to come out and this will in some way affect Leander. After all, even the tiniest seed can grow in the right conditions – of course that could all be nonsense!
3. Sidonie and Leander/Imriel meet and court again. What do you think of this and the echoes of their past courtship? How much of Imriel does Sidonie actually remember, if anything?
It’s so odd, like I said above – both of them are having their natural feelings, and in the case of Sidonie her memories, surpressed, and yet both of them seem to be drawn to each other inexplicably. For me there is clearly something about that relationship that wants to shine out in spite of all the magic currently heaped onto them to prevent it.
Oct. 16th Week 2: Chpts. 11-22 (Hosted by Tethyan Books)
Oct. 23rd Week 3: Chpts. 23-35 (Hosted by Emma Wolf)
Oct. 30th Week 4: Chpts. 36-49 (Hosted by Emma Wolf)
Nov. 6th Week 5: Chpts. 50-62 (Hosted by Lynn’s Book Blog)
Nov. 13th Week 6: Chpts. 63-75 (Hosted by Tethyan Books)
Nov. 20th Week 7: Chpts. 76-END (Hosted by Over the Effing Rainbow)
Today is week three of our readalong of Ashes of Honour (October Daye #6) by Seanan McGuire The schedule is over on Goodreads and this week I am hosting the questions. With the customary warning about potential spoilers lets get straight to the Q&A.
So Duchess Riordan is indeed involved in Chelsea’s disappearing acts – a plot which coincides with Samson’s efforts to remove Tybalt from power and “remove” Toby with him … Do you think Samson and Riordan are in cahoots somehow?
Oh my – I never even considered that but now the question has been asked it makes sense! Riordan was speaking to a man on the phone when Toby was earwigging the conversation so that could have been Samson. I’ve become so used to the Queen of the Mists being oddly involved with things or acting strange that I tend to always look in her direction when things go wrong and this has probably blinkered me a little and stopped me considering other people’s involvement.
Speaking of Toby and Tybalt … Not so much a question, but let’s discuss THAT confession from Tybalt!
Well – that little confession clears up so much. For example, why Tybalt originally disliked Toby due to her changeling nature. And, more than being revealing it just helps to build up more of a picture of Tybalt – not to mention just how long he’s actually been around. Plus it feels like the air has been cleared – there’s really nothing standing between Toby and Tybalt now! These two do make a great couple. I liked the remarks in the book – that Connor was in love with ‘Toby the girl’ but Tybalt is in love with ‘Toby the woman’ – I’m not quoting there but there was definitely something along those lines and I thought it was spot on. Toby and Connor were together in a strange hankering after ‘what was’. It never felt right for either of them really – more like they were clutching at straws. I certainly didn’t want Connor to die mind you – but there it is!
Meanwhile, Officer Thornton’s last appearance was not so random. Do you think he might know more than Toby realises about what’s going on, or does he just suspect something more?
The feeling I’m getting from Officer Thornton is that he doesn’t believe Toby. He knows that something is wrong but just not what or why? That’s the way he comes across to me at least. Like turning up at Toby’s house for example – he’s obviously looking into her because otherwise how would he know where she lived? That being said – I don’t like that he’s looking into her!! I don’t really know what his role is going to be in all this – I’m not getting a bad vibe but I can’t help feeling a little bit suspicious. I’m hoping though that maybe Officer Thornton might be a future ally for Toby – he could certainly be very helpful in future cases – in the same way, he could, of course, be very unhelpful.
Lastly, I need to mention that last encounter between Toby and Luna, in which things seem far less cosy at Shadowed Hills than they once were. What do you make of Luna’s reactions, and Toby’s responses to them? Is Toby in the right, or do you think Luna’s not being entirely unreasonable?
At first I was thinking this was strange but now I’m not so sure. It’s always felt as though something strained the relationship between Luna and Toby. At the back of her mind maybe Luna blames Toby for not actually succeeding in rescuing her and more to the point Rayseline? I also sometimes get the impression that Luna maybe dislikes the close relationship that Toby and Sylvester enjoy. Plus, at the end of the day, Luna did send Toby into a situation that would more than likely end up with her death. That must cross Toby’s mind as well – it just feels like the two of them really need to clear the air and speak their minds. As it is it feels as though Toby has hardened a little towards Luna and it feels very much as though Luna has withdrawn into herself. I hope the two of them figure it out – they do have a lot of history between them and not all of it is good but I think they could work it out if the desire to do so was there.