#SPFBO X Semi Finalist Announcement
21 October 2024
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: #SPFBO X, Book Reviews, Books, Semi Finalist Announcement

For those who don’t know about SPFBO (the Self Published Fantasy Blog Off) – this is a competition created and run by Mark Lawrence. The competition is now in its tenth year and you can find more about all the other entrants and judges over on Mark Lawrence’s blog.
I have now completed my reading for Stage 1 of the competition. I had five books that I read and reviewed and I chose two books to pass to my co-judges (The Critiquing Chemist.). Likewise the Critiquing Chemist chose three books to pass to me to check out. These five books are our chosen Semi Finalists and are posted below
Without further ado here are our five finalists.
*****
****
***
**
*
I will soon be reviewing the three books selected by the Critiquing Chemist but for now here are the titles linked to their Goodreads page.
Commiserations to the authors whose books have fallen. We had a lot of great books and some difficult decisions, with one final tough decision still yet to come.
By A Silver Thread by Rachel Aaron
Through Blood and Dragons by RM Schultz
The Enchanter’s Counsel by Thalib Razi
Smile and Be A Villain by Yves Donlon
Touched by Magic by Celine Jeanjean
#SPFBO 9 Semi Finalist Review : Under the Lesser Moon by Shelly Campbell
26 October 2023
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: #SPFBO, Review, Semi Finalist Announcement, Shelly Campbell, Under the Lesser Moon

What is SPFBO 9? This is a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted. Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants. Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.
Our batch of 30 books was split equally between myself and the Critiquing Chemist’s team. I have now completed my batch and announced my semi finalists and the CC have also now chosen their three semi finalists.
My three semi finalists can be found here.
So, My review today is for Under the Lesser Moon by Shelly Campbell, a Semi Finalist chosen by my partners.

Well, I can certainly understand why this book was chosen as a SF. The storytelling voice is simply superb. I was totally absorbed with Akrist’s tale and read with ever increasing curiosity and dread. However, I will make totally clear from the outset that this is not a book for everyone (IMO). Make no mistake, this is brutal, shockingly brutal in fact and the author doesn’t pull the punches. This is heart wrenching, frustrating, annoying and absolutely jaw dropping in equal measure – and that ending. Bring on No.2. But, although I’m saying this might not be for everyone, I thought it was impressive.
So, Under the Lesser Moon follows a nomadic tribe as they search the wastelands for the best hunting grounds. We meet Akrist as a young boy and immediately discover that he leads a rather strange existence, barren of love, affection and even human contact (for the most part). Akrist is the first born son and as such is cursed. Known as daeson (which I couldn’t help reading as ‘demon’ and perhaps there’s an element of that in the tribe’s superstitious beliefs) he is raised separately from his family, his mother hates him, his father looks relentlessly guilt stricken and basically, Akrist doesn’t fully understand the implications of his curse. The tribes have strong beliefs and customs and unfortunately, ritual sacrifice is included amongst these. Yes, Akrist, as the first born son, will be sacrificed to appease the Gods. The sacrifices occur every twelve years and so on finally realising what awaits him Akrist’s only option is to run. Which is easier said than done.
What really worked for me was the character Akrist. His voice is compelling and his life is intriguing. The life of this nomadic tribe comes across very easily on the page and is made really interesting by the inclusion of the tribe’s strange talking birds, vaiyas. These are great creatures and because Akrist spends much of his time caring for them they share a special bond, particularly the pack male, Vax. This really does lend a few much needed lighter moments to the story – although, again, there is a rather shockingly violent scene involving Vax which makes for difficult reading. Now, I will hold my hands up. I’m painting probably a grim picture here about the violence and cruelty, but I will say that although this made for difficult reading in parts it didn’t feel gratuitous or out of place given the way of life portrayed.
The religious beliefs of the tribe play into everything they do. This is a world with dragons and wurms, one of these mythical beasts revered the other reviled. Dragons not only guide the tribes but also choose their leaders, marking them with a unique scar. The dragons are unfortunately in decline and sightings are rare. Wurms are killed whenever they’re seen. They have voracious appetites and are believed to be evil. The world building is really good. The tribes people live difficult lives, the search for food is constant but occasionally other tribes people join their number and this adds a new element, particularly when Akrist finds himself a temporary reprieve and a possible love interest.
I won’t elaborate further on the plot. This goes in a direction I really didn’t foresee. The author makes some hard choices but ultimately the twist in the end is really breathtaking. I loved it. I felt sad at the same time so it is definitely bittersweet but, I will, without any doubt, pick up the next instalment.
My thanks to the author for a review copy. The above is my own opinion.
Now head on over to the Critiquing Chemist to read their thoughts.
Two more reviews to go and then a difficult decision ahead.
#SPFBO 9 Semi Finalist Announcement

If you follow #SPFBO or have been taking note of my recent reviews you’ll know that today I am making my Semi Finalist announcement (more about the competition below for info).
Our batch of 30 books was split equally between myself and the Critiquing Chemist’s team. I have now completed my batch. Out of my fifteen books I fully read seven of the books and have reviewed them during the course of the past week (links below). Today I am choosing three books to be semi finalists. Please note that these are my semi finalists – my partners will be announcing their semi finalists shortly. We will then read each others SFs and after a good deal of back and forth discussion arrive at our finalist (it sounds so easy doesn’t it!)
Anyway, after much head wrangling and wringing of hands I have my three books.
Firstly, here are my seven hopefuls (I have posted links to the reviews below):
My apologies to the authors whose books are being cut today. I had some fantastic books in my batch this year and so whilst that’s a really good thing and makes the reading much more enjoyable it comes with the problem of narrowing the field down. All I can say is a huge thanks to all the authors who entered their books, my commiserations if your book didn’t make this round of cuts, I hope you’re making the most of SPFBO in other ways by reaching out and connecting with other authors and reviewers – and to anybody reading this then please check out some of the other books here – there are some gems.
Without further ado my semi finalists are:
…
…
…
…
***
Congratulations to PJ Nwosu, Carol Carman and Hiyodor. Good luck in the final stage of Phase 1.
***
More info below:
What is SPFBO 9? This is a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted. Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants. Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.
My introduction post can be found here and also the Critiquing Chemist recently posted their first elimination post. I posted my first ‘cuts’ last week. My second elimination post can be found here.
My reviews the past week:
Here’s my first review for Of Thieves and Shadows (The Heart of Quinaria #1) by BSH Garcia.
Here’s my second review for Dark Innocence by PJ Alexander
Here’s my third review for The Bone Spear by Alexander Layne.
My fourth review is for The First and Last Demon by Hiyodori.
My fifth review is for The Heron Kings Rampant by Eric Lewis
My sixth review is for Twicetime by Carol Carman
My final review is for Dream of Death City by PJ Nwosu
#SPFBO 8 Semi Finalist Announcement

What is SPFBO? Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.
This year I am teaming up again with the ladies from The Critiquing Chemist.
Today I’m posting the two books that I’ve chosen as semi finalists. Check out my recap post here for all the reviews and updates posted so far.
I carried five books forward and have recently read and reviewed them. I have to say that I had a good time with all of them which makes this process even harder. But, I’m not going to draw this out longer than necessary.
Here are my five potentials:
and my two chosen semi finalists are :
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
Now stop on over to the Critiquing Chemist to check out which books they’ve chosen.
We will now press on with each other’s selected SFs before choosing our finalist.









