Caraval (Caraval #1) by Stephanie Garber
Once upon a time there were two sisters who lived upon the tiny Isle of Trisda. Every year the older sister wrote a letter to the man simply known as ‘Master Legend’, begging him to visit their Isle, and every year her letters remained unanswered. That is until the seventh year when the elder sister having woken in the morning, barely days away from her marriage to a mysterious Count, finally received the long awaited invitations to attend the spectacle known as ‘Caraval’. Entry to Caraval is by invitation only and the most important thing to remember is that ‘it is only a game!’
Yes, Caraval is told in an almost fairytale style. We have two beautiful sisters who are treated harshly by their tyrannical father. Their mother disappeared many years ago and their father, a powerful man on the Isle rules over them with an iron rod. Scarlett and Donatella (or Tella as she is more often known) finally have escape within their grasp, even if that comes in the form of Scarlett marrying a man she knows nothing of it seems to be the only acceptable way that they will ever escape the Island. Until their golden tickets arrive, announcing the next Caraval spectacle where the winner will be granted one wish. It really does sound too good to be true doesn’t it?
I actually really enjoyed Caraval. Don’t get me wrong, I had a couple of reservations, but overall it totally had me at it’s mercy. I confess that it feels like a very indulgent read in some respects. There is a certain amount of instalove, which is something I normally find quite irritating and yet it didn’t seem to bother me at all here, and, for two sisters who care so very much about each other I must admit that I didn’t really get a strong feeling of that. In fairness to the author, Tella spends a good deal of the book missing in action, but even so I think that we maybe didn’t see enough of the two of them together! And yet, in spite of those reservations I was hooked, so there it is. The only real reservation I did experience concerned an issue with the ending which was a bit shocking and took me by surprise and that even now I’m not totally sure how I feel about. But, I think that’s the beauty of this book in many ways – it keeps you thinking because it isn’t at all what it first seems to be. (Anyway, I bet you’re glad I cleared that up!)
So, why did I really like this. Well, firstly, the writing. This story is brimming with beautiful descriptions that bring the whole spectacle to life on the page. The imagination and creativity in terms of the place created and the magical possibilities within are just amazing. Caraval itself is a deliciously wicked conundrum. Nothing is ever as it seems, roads never lead to where you think, dark is day and light is night, bridges never begin and end at the same place twice, clock shops are shortcuts to wherever and dresses and gowns can be paid for using memories or other strange means. Secrets and lies and yet more secrets and lies. Put bluntly I found this a magical read and I was captivated. On top of that the pacing was excellent and assisted by the tick tock looming and ever-approaching-faster-deadline in which to solve the mystery I found myself almost as desperate as Scarlett for the next clues to be uncovered.
In terms of the characters. We have the tyrannical father – he was a bit of a cliche and I never fully understood what motivated him to be so cruel but in terms of being the big bad wolf of the piece he definitely fits the bill. Scarlett, I liked her. She isn’t a kick ass female and I’d say she spends a lot of time paying attention to her magical attire but I liked that she wasn’t perfect to be honest. She didn’t really understand the nature of the game being played at Caraval and found it difficult to be duplicitous enough to actually make any real headway. Basically, she makes plenty of mistakes that leave you shaking your head and she’s not above needing some help -although to be honest how much help she received in real terms is negotiable. Tella, it’s really difficult to say too much about her without giving away plot points and having finished the book with all it’s twists and turns I think my earlier feelings about her may have been a little unfair and need revising because on first impressions she certainly wasn’t my favourite. All I can say, without giving more away, is that you really do have to read to the end for certain elements to be fully revealed and to have your final lightbulb moment. I must say that I was pleased to be wrong on a number of occasions in terms of where the author took the story – I just didn’t see a number of the twists at all and the ending really took me by surprise.
Then we have the love interest element. Everything here is not quite as it seems and you never know whether you can trust what you’re reading. I’m not going to elaborate, even though there is a little bit of instalove I thought it was written in a very subtle way and it certainly didn’t steal the show in fact if I’m going to be a total brazen hussy about it I wouldn’t have minded more of this element as it was well done.
I was very pleasantly surprised by Caraval. Why surprised? Well, I sometimes find YA a little hit and miss – especially when I read a book where I have countless questions and not enough answers. I didn’t experience this with Caraval. I was so entranced by the spectacle that I felt at times as though I was experiencing it with Scarlett. There’s a history both to the show and Master Legend and his beginnings that is woven into the story. In fairness there’s not a great deal of in depth examination about the magical aspects but personally I didn’t really mind. Sometimes you question these things and sometimes they just feel acceptable without explanation.
So, on the whole a very enjoyable, well crafted, fairytale style story about two sisters who will surprise not only themselves but also you the reader.
Chimes at Midnight (October Daye #7) by Seanan McGuire, readalong week 3
21 January 2017
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Chimes at Midnight, October Daye #7, Readalong week 3, Sci Fi, Seanan McGuire
Today is the third week of a four week readalong of Chimes at Midnight by Seanan McGuire. How I’m loving this series and it feels as though each book just keeps adding more depth to the world created by McGuire. Feel free to join us. A Goodreads page is set up here or simply jump in with the comments. Also, be aware that spoilers will be lurking below so be careful!
This week Lisa at Over the Effing Rainbow is providing the questions so lets get a budge on:
1. “We took titles as a warning. ‘Stay away. Here there be monsters.'”
This week we learn the Luidaeg’s original name, and also that she really does, perhaps, have her sneaky ways of answering some of Toby’s unasked questions – or starting to, anyway. What speculations are you drawing from what we learn in Toby’s blood-vision? Given this teaser, what questions might you ask the Luidaeg if you were in Toby’s shoes.
Personally, if I was in Toby’s shoes I’d be gobbling those frozen blood pills down like they were candy in search of questions – which would probably be very unwise. I’m getting from these flashbacks, and how ingenious of the Luidaeg by the way to come up with that, that Toby’s mum was very much trying to protect Toby – I don’t know if I’ve picked everything up but clearly Armandine is very powerful and clearly sometimes being so powerful is a risky business – why else would the other firstborn have the titles and ‘stay away. Here there be Monsters’ thing going on. But, we had a different hint in this section – I think I would be asking just exactly who my father was if I was Toby – we know that one king already tried to hide his family to save them – what if Toby’s father wasn’t human. Toby could be very powerful and maybe a potential threat to others – maybe in danger. I don’t know, I’m jumping around all over the place but I’m beginning to wonder if Toby really is a changeling.
2. “I know a lot about being royal.”
Surprise! So the truth about Quentin’s background is out, and I’ve got to know: did you suspect this at all or did it in fact surprise you? Any predictions for the young squire-prince going forward from here?
I was completely surprised. I’ve been making a lot of surprises about Toby but I really didn’t follow the breadcrumbs with Quentin and I was gobsmacked. At least I didn’t have a pie in the face! I really don’t know – will he be required to complete his time as a squire? I can’t see how that would work really. It feels like Toby has already started to change towards him and although she has always been a little bit protective I think she will feel differently towards him. I don’t think it will affect their friendship – just maybe the way she feels about the whole situation or how comfortable she is ordering him around. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think Toby changes the way the acts around people depending on their status, I just think that knowing him to be a prince now will just change things. You can’t ‘unknow’ it can you? Perhaps Quentin could help Arden to become accustomed to her new role? I definitely think that he would be a champion for Toby in the future which can’t be a bad thing – he’s seen how she works and how fair she is so…
3. “You protect your family by making the world a better place for them to live. Not by running away.”
Toby’s got some hard truths for Arden, and well she should know about them… Do you think Arden will stand by her choice here? And what do you think of October Daye looking set up to have the ear of the next Queen in the Mists?
Yes, for once I can see that maybe Toby won’t be hated by the Queen in the Mists – of course Arden will be a relatively innocent Queen – in terms of what she doesn’t know, she’s led a very innocent life in terms of the fae after all – I think she will need somebody like Toby, who tells her things the way they really are and doesn’t bow and scrape or curry favour or seek power. In terms of Toby – having the ear of the Queen probably won’t make a difference – she’s not really seeking power or titles is she?
4. There’s plenty more to chew on in these chapters, but what parts stand out the most for you, and why?
So much in these chapters. Where to start. This book is so good. I pretty much know that things are going to get so much worse before they get better or maybe that’s my pessimism sneaking in. I want to know more about Quentin for a start. Tybalt and Toby – very revealing that Toby finally has found her place – no more floundering around for her – she’s chosen where she wants to be and that might come with sadness over what she’s leaving behind but she is ready to move forward. May – I think she might be getting ready to leave Toby and set up with Jazz but I could be wrong. She’s always ready to step in and I think she’ll always be there for Toby but the scene where she was leaving with Toby to go to Muir and she was looking back at the house worrying about Jazz, well, I couldn’t help thinking that the two of them are becoming very serious and ready to move on together. I loved reading about the Cu Sidhe – dog fae! Especially winding down the window on Danny’s cab – why do dogs love to stick their heads out of car windows – which basically means a blast of cold air in the face – but yet they hate it if you blow in their face! What is that. Why? And the Luidaeg – I can’t help thinking that everything could be improved by her appearance. So tetchy and grumpy and pushing people around – but underneath it all – yeah, she’s still a grumpy puss, but she has heart.
These are the voyages of the FFO…
20 January 2017
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Becky Chambers, Books by Proxy, Friday Face off, The Long Way to a Small Angry Planet

Here we are again with the Friday Face Off meme created by Books by Proxy . This is a great opportunity to feature some of your favourite book covers. The rules are fairly simple each week, following a predetermined theme (list below) choose a book, compare a couple of the different covers available for that particular book and choose your favourite. Future week’s themes are listed below. This week’s theme:
Spacecraft “Slipped the surly bonds of earth’ to ‘touch the face of God.”
The Long Way to a Small Angry Planet by Becky Chambers:
And my winner,:

I love this cover!
Which is your favourite?
Future themes:
27/01/2017 – Book “A room without books is like a body without a soul”
03/02/2017 – Hotel “Welcome to the Hotel California! Such a lovely place. Such a lovely face. Plenty of space at the Hotel California”
10/02/2017 – Diamonds “Diamonds are a girl’s best friend!”
17/02/2017 – Car “Drivin’ along in my automobile”
24/02/2017 Alien – “Aliens – if they exist-are little green men with big eyes and spindly arms…or giant insects or something like a lumpy little creature”
03/03/2017 – Playing cards “Life is not a matter of holding good cards, but of playing a poor hand well”
10/03/2017 – School “I never let my schooling interfere with my education”
17/03/2017 – Bird “Some birds are not meant to be caged, that’s all. Their feathers are too bright, their songs are too sweet and wild”
24/03/2017 – Street lamp “He stood under the street lamp, sleet settling in his hair, hands fisted at his side”
31/03/2017 – Casino “Whisky, gambling and Ferraris are better than housework “
07/04/2017 – Circus “You can get the monkey off your back, but the circus never leaves town!
14/04/2017 – Easter “The rabbit of Easter. He bring of the chocolate”
21/04/2017 – Bridge “I demolish my bridges behind me…then there is no choice but to push forward”
28/04/2017 – Beach/Seaside”Oh I do like to be beside the seaside!”
05/05/2017 – Lion “If you place your head in a lion’s mouth, then you cannot complain one day if he happens to bite it off”
12/05/2017 – Phone “Don’t use the phone. People are never ready to answer it”
19/05/2017 – Plane “When everything seem to be going against you, remember that the airplane takes off against the wind, not with it ….”
26/05/2017 – Mice “Of all the words of mice and men, the saddest are, ‘it might have been’…”
02/06/2017 – Moon “Shoot for the moon. Even if you miss, you’ll land among the stars”
09/06/2017 – Mummy “It shuffles through the dry, dusty darkness”
16/06/2017 – Guitar “You couldn’t not like someone who liked the guitar”
23/06/2017 – Cat “In ancient times cats were worshipped as gods; they have not forgotten this”
30/06/2017 – Hat “It is always cruel to laugh at people, of course, although sometimes if they are wearing an ugly hat it is hard to control yourself “
07/07/2017 – Gold “All that is gold does not glitter”
14/07/2017 – Boats “The Owl and the Pussy-cat went to sea, in a beautiful pea green boat…”
21/07/2017 – Planet “Any planet is ‘Earth’ to those who live on it”
Friday Firsts: Department Zero by Paul Crilley
20 January 2017
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Department Zero, Friday Firsts, Paul Crilley, tenacious reader

Friday Firsts is a new meme that runs every Friday over on Tenacious Reader. The idea is to feature the first few sentences/paragraph of your current book and try and outline your first impressions as a result. This is a quick and easy way to share a snippet of information about your current read and to perhaps tempt others. Stop on by and link up with Tenacious Reader. This week I’m reading Department Zero by Paul Crilley
‘The polite term for what I do for a living is “biohazard remediation.”
That’s what I say in anyone asks me at a dinner party. Not that I’m ever invited to dinner parties. (Megan got custody of all the friends in the divorce.) But it’s what I’d say if I was invited, and if someone was actually polite enough to approach through the chemical smell of industrial-strength cleaning products that clings to my body.
Another term for what I do is Crime and Trauma Scene Decontamination. Or CTSDecon, if you want to sound cool.
Which, basically, means that I clean up stiffs for a living.
All the stiffs. No prejudice in my line of work.
Murder? Check.
Suicide? Check
Murder-suicide? Check.
Industrial accidents? Check.
Decomposition after unattended death? Check.
Spontaneous human combustion? Check. (Not that I’ve ever had one of those, but I live in hope.)’
My First Impressions
Well, no messing around there then! What a great opening, I think I’m going to enjoy this one.
What you reading this Friday??
*The above excerpt was taken from an advanced reader copy and it is possible that the final version may have further changes.
Gilded Cage (Dark Gifts #1) by Vic James
The Gilded Cage is an unusual and interesting story. Set in an alternative UK the story revolves around one particular family as they embark on a period of enforced slavery. I must admit that I have mixed feelings with this book. It was certainly fast paced and actually made for quite addictive reading but I felt like the world building needed something more.
The story starts with our main family, the Hadleys, as their life is about to completely change. The Hadleys are about to start their ‘slavedays’. Every commoner in the UK, or, more to the point, every person not born with ‘skill’, must serve a compulsory ten year period of slavery. The world here is split into those without magical ability and those with. Let’s call them the ‘haves’ and ‘have nots’. The former being the aristocracy, landed gentry living lives of privilege on huge country estates whilst the latter are the commoners who undertake all the hard work within society. In this particular instance the Hadleys have undertaken to go to into this period of their lives as a whole family. Unfortunately, their plan to be located as a whole unit working on the Jardine’s country estate doesn’t go quite according to plan and although the mother, father, and two daughters are placed as planned the son, Luke, is torn from the family and placed in one of the factory towns up North.
We then predominantly follow Luke as he becomes familiar with his new and brutal surroundings and then switch to his sister Abi as she tries to plan for a way to get Luke back with the family whilst finding herself in the strange predicament of finding herself becoming attracted to one member of the family she now serves.
So, to the characters. My favourite storyline was Luke’s. Located in a town called Millmoor this is a grim place. The people work long and miserable hours and are barely fed enough to sustain them – obviously just one of many ways to keep them downtrodden and too tired to fight back. This doesn’t stop underlying rumblings and an underground movement with rebellion at it’s core and Luke fairly quickly becomes embroiled with this group. Meanwhile, Luke’s sister Abi is helping to run the Jardine’s office. She’s an intelligent young woman and fairly quickly finds her feet. Unfortunately she finds herself attracted to the middle son of the family, Jenner. Jenner is an anomaly in the world of Equals, born without skill he’s something of an embarrassment to the family. His older brother and heir is a particularly vindictive piece of work with a short fuse – Gavar. Rumours circulate the estate about how he murdered a former maid and the mother of his child. The younger brother, Silyen, is the one to watch. He’s incredibly powerful in terms of his own skill and seems to have his own agenda which hasn’t yet been made clear. The Equals have their own problems of infighting and back stabbing. There’s plenty of jostling for position and families seeking beneficial matches to increase their own status.
The plot, well there are two threads running through the story. Obviously the underground rebellion movement being spearheaded at Millmoor and then the political struggles taking place in the world of the Equals. Alongside this are a couple of twists, one concerning the younger Jardine and the other focusing on Luke’s own role. I won’t go into either as they will contain spoilers.
The world building. Set in a modern day world this is an alternative UK where history split from the one we currently live in many years ago. It’s a bit of a strange world to come to grips with and this is an area that I struggled with a little. The period just has a jumbled feel somehow. The factory towns feel like they’re straight out of the Industrial Revolution era. They have a Dickensian type feel. Poor housing, poor food, long hours, harsh wardens. The Jardine’s family home is like Downton Abbey, except that whilst one of the sons rides around the estate on horseback his brother chooses motorbikes as his favourite mode of transport. It feels like the book is conflicted a little with its own time period somehow – it’s not as far advanced in technological terms as our own, and yet it does benefit from some modern day advances.
The story does takes a good look at class division and exploitation and I thought that was a very thought provoking element that has kept me thinking for days after I put the book down. However, this brings me to the real issue I had which revolved around the slavery aspect and the whys and wherefores of how it all works. The idea puts me loosely in mind of conscription but much more severe – everyone serving a 10 year period of enforced slavery but there was very little detail in relation to this aspect and I guess you’re just expected to go with the flow and not focus on the finer detail. The thing is I just can’t help myself from wanting that little bit of extra detail. Such as, why were people allowed to volunteer at whatever age they liked. How is it feasible for a whole family to go together – what happens to their home, how do they resume life when their slavedays are over. How is the whole thing even monitored – what happens if you don’t volunteer, why wouldn’t you simply leave your volunteering days until your twilight years?? Look, I’m not suggesting that we have a full essay on the economics of dystopian society, nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition after all, but just a few lines here and there. As it is I didn’t really get the idea that people had any real qualms about going into their slavedays, and whilst some of this is explained away I do find it difficult to believe that everyone in the country is unaware of the horror that takes place during this period of their life.
On the whole this was an intriguing story that kept me entertained. I did have niggles, which primarily revolved around me wanting more information, but I can understand that this would have made the book a lot slower in pace and therefore not to everyone’s liking.
I received a copy courtesy of the publisher through Netgalley for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.



