#SPFBO X Review: The Enchanter’s Counsel by Thalib Razi

For those who don’t know about SPFBO (the Self Published Fantasy Blog Off) – this is a competition created and run by Mark Lawrence.  The competition is now in its tenth year and you can find out more about all the other entrants and judges over on Mark Lawrence’s blog.

I have now completed all my reading for the first phase of SPFBO X.  Today I am posting my second of three reviews following which the  Critiquing Chemist and I will be announcing our finalist.

Today’s review is for The Enchanter’s Counsel by Thalib Razi.

The Enchanter’s Counsel brings to readers an interesting world that explores religion, culture, climate change and other real world issues in an intriguing setting.

The world building here is interesting and felt quite unique.  This is a coin shaped world, people live on both sides of the coin as well as along the rim.  This is a world that experienced wars in the past and the peace still feels tentative, there is tension and as with most wars the culprit is greed and the race to mine the gems that encrust the edge of the planet.  Fridehim is the holy city and the setting for the majority of the story.  The city is populated by dwarves, goblins and elves although the three don’t always get along as well as they could and in fact tensions and outbursts of conflict are not uncommon.

As the story begins we meet Mizan al-Wasati.  Mizan is returning to his family home having graduated university as an enchanter of gems.  Along the way he is accompanied by a friend called Apple and the two have a few adventures before Mizan finally boards the dragon that will fly him home.  It’s something of a strange homecoming for Mizan, on one hand he’s graduated university and everyone is suitably proud, on the other he doesn’t yet have a new job and is starting to feel like his years of study were for nothing.  Initially, Mizan works at his family’s cafe until he comes up with a bright idea to drum up new business that eventually sees him encountering a childhood friend and uncovering a potential disaster just waiting to happen.

Mizan is the MC.  He is accompanied by a few old friends.  Apple, a university friend, Nick, a childhood friend and eventually Daena – who Mizan has a soft spot for.  The four become entangled in a secret project.  Of late the city has been plagued by earthquakes and it seems that the hard mining for magical gems is starting to take its toll and over use of magic is causing rifts.

What I particularly enjoyed about The Enchanter’s Counsel was the setting.  There are some really creative elements.  I loved the hustle and bustle of the city.  There’s a lot of attention to the cultural aspects that really bring the place to life.  The fantasy elements feel low key in some ways, people have become reliant on gems which has created the need for overmining.  I loved the diversity of the world, of course there are tensions and misunderstandings and I felt this was dealt with in a sensitive fashion.  This is a world of mixed cultures and as a result there are extremists from both sides of the coin that are not necessarily reflective of the greater population who are simply trying to get on and live together.  A lot of thought has been given to this element of the story and it shines through.

In terms of criticisms.  I think the story itself felt a little light but this is sometimes the case with a first book in series where character development and plot sometimes take a back seat to world building.

Overall, this was an intriguing read and a good set up for future instalments that hopefully take our MC further afield and explore this coin shaped world in greater depth.

I received a copy courtesy of the author for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

Booking Ahead/Weekly Wrap Up

Sunday Post

Books read this week:

This week has been another busy one.  I went off track a little with my reading, well, not off track exactly as the books were still from my October list,  just a little out of order, a bit of mood reading.  I completed Cold Snap by Lindy Ryan.  This one didn’t work out quite as well as I was anticipating, particularly after I loved her last book, Bless Your Heart, perhaps my expectations were out of kilter.  I hadn’t realised this was a novella and I rarely request shorter books or collections as they’re not really my go to.  I also read, loved and reviewed Magic by Sarah Pinborough, this was so good and I have another from the collection still waiting to be read that I can’t wait to pick up.  And, as I’m writing up this post I’ve just completed Hear Him Calling by Carly Reagon – if you want scaring half to death then I suggest giving this a read, seriously this gave me the heebies.  It’s the perfect time for a haunting story and Hear Him Calling delivers this without a shadow of a doubt.

Next Week’s Reads:

I’m going to get back on track and pick up The Coven by Harper L Woods and The Book of Witching by CJ Cooke.  In fact I’ve already started The Book of Witching, it’s early days but so far so good.

Reviews Posted:

  1. Cold Snap by Carly Ryan
  2. And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie
  3. Through Blood and Dragons by RM Schultz (SPFBO)
  4. Magic By Sarah Pinborough

Outstanding Reviews

#SPFBO X Review: Through Blood and Dragons by RM Schultz

For those who don’t know about SPFBO (the Self Published Fantasy Blog Off) – this is a competition created and run by Mark Lawrence.  The competition is now in its tenth year and you can find out more about all the other entrants and judges over on Mark Lawrence’s blog.

I have now completed all my reading for the first phase of SPFBO X.  Over the next few days I hope to publish reviews for the three books chosen by the Critiquing Chemist followed by a post in which we will announce our finalist.

Today’s review is for a high fantasy story called Through Blood and Dragons by RM Schultz.

If you love stories with dragons then this will surely appeal.  Dragons are integral to the story.  They are used by warring nations and in fact can tip the balance of whether you win or lose.  They share a bond with their rider and there is a dragon realm that will hopefully be explored more in future editions.

This is the land of Cimeren, torn by a history of war between the north and south there is an uneasy peace which rests on a knife edge.  Instability threatens to once again push the nation into war and so when a terrible event leads to the death of the King of Murgare and his Queen being taken hostage the infamous Dragon Queen of the north decides to take action.  And so the scene is set for these two nations to once again go to war.

However, here is so much more to this story than the simple overview above.  This is a story with intrigue and mystery, corruption and bravery.

The landscape of this world has largely helped to prevent the constant outbreaks of war that are always looming.  The two are separated by a dark forest and a huge lake.  Both of these are obstacles to war when your main threat comes from a host of dragons.  The forest gives little chance of respite for the larger dragons to rest as does the lake, and so nature helps to keep these warring nations apart.  They are, of course, constantly trying to keep ahead in terms of recruiting more dragons – a kind of arms war if you will.  There are many types of dragons, the larger of which wear armaments and carry warriors into the fray. The author has clearly thought this through in depth with different breeds and abilities.

As the story begins we meet Cyran Orendain, a squire at an outpost called Nevergrace.  Cyran is an easy to like character, he’s good natured and friendly, he cares about the dragons, he dreams of better things, he has a secret fancy for one of the young women from the outpost and he has a strong sense of duty.  We follow Cyran for much of the story taking us back and forth into the large city of Belvenguard where the plot thickens and back to the outpost where war has raised its bloody head.  There are of course other characters and Cyran’s sister, Jaslin, is definitely one to watch.

The world building is impressive and there are plenty of unexpected elements to the story to hold your attention.  I was surprised by how ruthless the author was in terms of not only the characters but also the dragons.

I mentioned intrigue.  Not all of the story elements are concluded by the end of the story.  Clearly, there is more to this war than at first meets the eye.  Of course there is the natural enmity between the north and south given their history, however, other forces are at play and maybe the start of this war is not as straightforward as it first appears.  Certain members of the King’s court come across as decidedly suspicious, someone is sending out secret messages to a number of the key players warning them to be careful and on top of this the dark forests seem to be coming alive with death and mystery, strange magic, enchanted music and unusual artefacts.

In terms of criticisms.  I didn’t have anything that spoiled the story for me.  There are a number of threads, some of which are ongoing at the conclusion of the tale and there is a lot to take on board but this feels natural for epic fantasy of this scope.  In that respect it has a typical start to a series feel. there are many characters to become familiar with, plus the layout and backstory which can slow the story down a little at points but not to the point that I wasn’t enjoying the read.

In conclusion, I enjoyed Through Blood and Dragons, it’s a great start to a promising series.

I received a copy courtesy of the author, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

Friday Face Off : The House at Watch Hill by Karen Marie Moning

FFO

Today I’m returning to the  Friday Face Off, originally created by Books by Proxy).  I’ve missed these for the past few months and so would like to get back to comparing covers (and hopefully I will be updating this page with a new banner.  This is an opportunity to look at a book of your choice and shine the spotlight on the covers.  Of course this only works for those books that have alternative covers (although sometimes I use this to look at a series of books to choose a favourite). . So, if you have a book that has alternative covers, highlight them and choose your favourite.  If you’re taking part it would be great if you leave a link so I can take a look at what you’ve chosen.

This week I’ve chosen another book that is on my shelf waiting to be read. The House at Watch Hill by Karen Marie Moning.  I’m looking forward to picking this one up soon.  Only two covers, take a look:

My favourite this week:

Have you read this book already?  What did you think and which is your favourite?

Join me next week in highlighting one of your reads with different covers.

Review: And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie

My Five Word TL:DR Review: Loved It, especially the reveal

And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie is a book that I’ve wanted to read for some time.  I bought, a few years ago, a copy of a paperback version and I think I also might have had a kindle version but when I saw this on Netgalley, well, firstly, I knew that it would give me the push I needed to pick it up and secondly, I was fascinated about this collector’s edition and the way the ending is revealed.

So, if you’re not familiar with And Then There Were None its a closed room mystery that takes place on an island where a number of guests have been invited for a mystery weekend.  One by one the guests begin to die and it soon becomes apparent that a murderer is amongst the party.

I had such a good time with this.

Having read Christie before I had an idea of what to expect with the style.  The writing is very easy to get along with.  The style is, I suppose, dated, I think the original was probably written in the 1940s and the characters, the dialogue and the set up is reflective of that but I loved it.

As mentioned, we have a number of characters that arrive at Soldier Island to be met by the housekeeper and butler.  Only ten people in total.  The island is completely cut off from the mainland and stormy weather makes it impossible for the inhabitants to leave once the murders begin.

In each room is an old nursery rhyme and on the dining room table are ten pottery soldier statues – which slowly but surely disappear in line with the murders.

None of the characters know each other (apart from the butler and housekeeper who are man and wife). 

Quite early in the story an ominous and intimidating record is played to the guests in which they are all accused of murder.  This of course causes immediate outrage and much stomping about followed by loud declarations of innocence.  Within fairly short order we have our first victim.  To begin with the guests think this may have been a suicide and although they all still feel uncomfortable and wish to leave the island they don’t at this point have any other fears – until the next body appears – two dead bodies in such a short period, even though they don’t immediately stand out as murder, it’s a bit of a coincidence.  And then the third body turns up and it becomes clear to all that their lives are in danger.

So, much searching of the island and the house ensues.  Some of the party have taken to solitary confinement and reflection, almost with a resigned feeling of the inevitable.  Of course, the island is small and practically barren with no hidey holes.  Likewise the house is a modern structure, clean lines and also very little room for evasion.

What I really liked about this.

The pacing is great.  There’s always something going on.

The mystery.  I’m pretty certain I’ve seen an adaptation of this but if I have I still didn’t guess the ending correctly.  To be fair my impatience got the better of me.  I started trying to work things out methodically and, not blowing my own trumpet, I thought I’d made quite a good job of coming up with the answer – but – well, firstly I was wrong, secondly there is a rather large clue which I’d completely overlooked and thirdly, there’s an element to the solution that I was totally closed off to.  Plus, as I mentioned, my impatience got the better of me and I was so excited to read the ending I just went for the first person that I thought sounded feasible.  Perhaps if I’d have taken long and reasoned things through – well, I don’t know.  

The characters, I don’t think any of them are particularly easy to like – which isn’t to say I strongly disliked any of them.  But, they’re all keeping secrets and some of them are definitely guilty and guilt ridden. I don’t think you’re supposed to love them to be honest which is just as well because the body count rises very quickly.

I have absolutely no hesitation in recommending this.  If you like a fast paced murder mystery, short, snappy and full of intrigue then you need to give it a shot.  The clues are all there, my only advice, don’t be like me and rush into your conclusion.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 4.5 of 5 very entertaining stars

 

 

 

« Previous PageNext Page »