#SPFBO 9: Finalist Review: The Fall is All There Is by CM Caplan

SPFBO71024_1

What is SPFBO 9?  This is  a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted.  Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants.  Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.  Also, check out this page to see all the lovely finalists and the scoreboard for Phase 2 of the competition.

***

Fall

This is one crazy book indeed and, I won’t beat about the bush, I had a really good time reading this.

Seat belts on please because I have no idea where this review is going to take me, to be honest, it took me about 25% of the book to actually start to understand the basics of the place and the main character – and even then, lets just say my grip was tenuous at best. But, regardless, I was hooked.

Firstly, can we discuss character driven stories – because this is certainly that.  Secondly, dysfunctional families – yep, here in spades. Thirdly, a very intimate style story told by a person who is autistic.  Fourthly a genre defying tale with scifantasy based in a post-post apocalyptic world filled with fascinating creations and a creepy fog that turns those that get caught in it into a ghost version of themselves – a zombie if you will.

The story is told by Petre Mercy.  Petre ran away (well, rode away on a cyborg horse if you want to be pedantic) about five years ago.  Driven to despair by his family, the politics and the backstabbing, not to mention that he didn’t have the means to withstand the constant barrage of fierce rivalry.  He has now been called back to the fold following the death of his father – the King.  Petre is one of four quadruplets now embroiled in a possible civil war over the succession to the throne.  And, in spite of the fact that Petre was really seen as the weakest link it seems that his siblings are now all keen to have his support.

That’s really the main gist of the story although it unfolds in a slightly less straightforward way than I’ve portrayed.

So, Petre.  Well, as it happens, I really liked this character.  He made me laugh.  He’s wicked.  He’s addicted to some kind of muscle memory inducing drugs that give his body more strength and the ability to act more quickly than he would otherwise be capable of.  I would say that Petre is really an unreliable narrator in some ways because he doesn’t seem to have any realisation of his own value to the family – but that’s my take and yours could be different.  Fortunately, I liked Petre, which in turn makes it a lot easier to like the book – because you spend the entire story in his head with all the ensuing chaos, paranoia and sometimes close to hysteria as you can get, thoughts.  He doesn’t always see the full picture – therefore we, the reader, don’t always see the full picture.  I think this is a risk on the part of the author but for me it worked really well.  It does give a much narrower focus, you see things only from Petre’s perspective, and as I mentioned, he doesn’t always understand everything, but it’s consistent – it just needs you to join up a few dots for yourself.  And, fortunately, Petre is still learning as the story progresses and sometimes he remembers stories and events quite differently than his brothers or sister – like I said, slightly unreliable narrator – although, that being said, I think people often have a different memory of an event than others that were present.

The world is one creepy messed up place.  It’s a strange mix of new and old.  Things are not necessarily explained, for example, what is the weird fog that turns people into zombies?  I don’t know and for me those sort of details felt irrelevant to the story.  The real beauty of Petre’s narration and the fact that he is often unaware of the bigger picture is that we don’t have serious info dumps.  He does provide us with some details, he sometimes clearly listened to his lessons, but, for the most part, and I would say this goes for the pacing as well, you’re pretty much meant to hit the ground running with this one.  I really like the element of not always being told everything that’s happening exactly as it happens, I like the speculation this leads to inside my own head that, okay, is often times wrong but is enjoyable nonetheless.

The writing is really good.  I will just mention though that this is grimdark, yes there is humour and snark but it can also be brutal, it can be a bit ick and there’s some colourful cursing.  For me the author hit the right tone.  I like books that make me smile and I love books that make me laugh, particularly if that breaks up what otherwise would be a very dour read.

Basically, at its core, this is a book about family and the way we interact, fight, scream, laugh, cry. Of course, the stakes with this particular family are what makes their story so interesting.  I found this unique and enjoyable  and I look forward to reading more by this author.

My thanks to the author for providing a copy for review.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 8.5 of 10 stars or 4 of 5 for Goodreads

#SPFBO 9: Finalist Review: The Wickwire Watch by Jacquelyn Hagen

SPFBO71024_1

What is SPFBO 9?  This is  a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted.  Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants.  Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.  Also, check out this page to see all the lovely finalists and the scoreboard for Phase 2 of the competition.

***

TWW

The Wickwire Watch was the second SPFBO Finalist that I picked up.  This is another coming of age story that blends gaslight fantasy and mystery with a little bit of magic, vengeful ghosts and found family.

As the story begins we meet Inkwell Featherfield,  Ink is on a self imposed mission searching for his parents (he isn’t sure at this point whether they are alive or not).  He travels from town to town, picking pockets along  the way and surviving as best he can – his light fingers actually catch the attention of a local reporter who is trying to find out more information about a murder that has just taken place.  Ink takes on the job of looking around the home of the victim but what starts out as a fairly simple affair soon sees him being chased by Spektors and rescued by a group of unlikely outlaws.

I will say that I really enjoyed the start of the story.  There was the mystery to solve, talk of ‘colonists’ – who are whispered about with much fear and of course we have a magical item that has been found.  The pacing at the start was good and quickly pulled me into the story.

That being said, once Ink was rescued I found the story, or the plot that I was expecting, came almost to a halt.  Instead we then have a good chunk of the book dedicated to showing us the life that Ink’s rescuers live.  I will give a mention to the ‘island’ that they live on – this was a great idea.  But, aside from that, I found these chapters pulled me out of the story.  I understand the idea is to let Ink and the readers get to know these new characters, to give them an opportunity to develop trust, but, it was a huge slice of life story that I didn’t particularly enjoy with a lot of attention on everyday life, picking apples, making breakfast, washing up, etc.  I don’t mind that detail, just to be clear, but I felt there was too much, and rather than demonstrate how well Ink’s would-be rescuers were surviving it seemed to show the opposite to a certain degree.  However, this is a very personal issue which other readers will probably love.  I simply felt it slowed the story down too much and eventually I felt myself losing interest.

What I liked about the Wickwire Watch was the period in which it’s set.  We have a Victorian style world where magic is fading and new technology is taking its place.  There are still magically imbued items and of course some people can still perform magic although I won’t try to describe the finer details as I’m not totally sure I understand how the magic worked but I really liked the setting.

I also really liked the way the author gives both sides of the story.  Ink is a character who doesn’t easily give people his trust which is completely understandable with him fending for himself and, much like Ink, the reader also doesn’t totally know who to trust. The outlaws are believed to have committed horrible crimes, people speak of them in hushed voices and Ink fears for his life when he discovers his rescuers are  none other than the infamous murdering Colonists.  But they tell a different story entirely.  So, who do you believe – and will Ink make the right choice ultimately. I really like this aspect of the book it adds to the intrigue.

I did have some issues that held me back with this book.  I already mentioned the pacing and the way the story slowed down for a good chunk of the book.  On top of this I failed to connect with Ink, which I can’t really explain  but I find it difficult to really sink into the story if I don’t get along well with the main character.

Small issues aside though, this is undoubtedly an enjoyable read.  I did feel it went off track a little but I had no problems returning to this book and I think it will easily find it’s target audience.

I received a copy from the author, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 3.5 of 5 or 7 of 10

#SPFBO 9: Finalist Review: Master of the Void by Wend Raven

SPFBO71024_1

What is SPFBO 9?  This is  a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted.  Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants.  Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.  Also, check out this page to see all the lovely finalists and the scoreboard for Phase 2 of the competition.

***

MofV

This is a coming of age story with an interesting magic system and multiple povs.  The writing is good, there is plenty of travel and mystery and I enjoyed the whole ‘void’ concept.  However, I did have some issues that stopped me from loving this book as much as I’d hoped.

Set in the Seven Lands magic is fundamental to everyday life.  Basically, everyone has some element of magic even if it’s fairly simple or mundane.  We quickly learn that when a person turns 13 they can choose to undertake a magical ability test, of course, most participants expect this to be fairly run of the mill – the worst that could happen is maybe a low level magical ability.  As the story begins we meet our two primary characters – Derrius and Orimond.  Disaster strikes for both these characters – which I won’t go into – and sends them both on totally different, independent voyages of discovery.

What I liked about this – I really enjoyed the way the author takes the two main characters along completely different paths.  I enjoyed in particular the way that one character physically went on a real adventure and eventually seemed to find a measure of happiness in his life in spite of his disappointment at the start of the story.  I personally thought the way the characters’ disappointments fed into their eventual choices was very well executed.

The world is quite well explored and I enjoyed all the travel involved – particularly when a group of characters band together to go in search of someone.

I would say this has an epic fantasy feel.  There’s definitely a ‘the world is under threat’ feel and a sense of things generally coming to a head in the most critical fashion.

In terms of my issues.  I think there were too many povs.  I usually enjoy multiple povs but I felt that the characters didn’t feel distinct enough, I was sometimes muddled in terms of who I was reading about and I found the jumps forward in age a little perplexing. Maybe that just speaks of a level of impatience on my part because the timeline/confusion about the characters’ ages does resolve itself.  On top of this I just didn’t find myself forming firm attachments to any of the characters.  Which isn’t to say I disliked their storylines just that a firm favourite never really became apparent.

On top of this, and this is a personal thing of course, but this felt like it could have been shortened to make it a bit more punchy.  As it is the pacing felt a little inconsistent, certain areas felt like they progressed very slowly and then the conclusion seemed to plough forward very quickly indeed.

Anyway, issues aside, this has an easy style of writing, a good amount of world building and a well thought out elemental style magic system that I really liked and although I experienced a few issues I think it will have no problem finding its audience.

I received a copy through the author, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 6.5 of 10

#SPFBO 9 Update

Posted On 16 March 2024

Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: ,

Comments Dropped 2 responses

SPFBO71024_1

What is SPFBO 9?  This is  a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted.  Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants.  Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.  Also, check out this page to see all the lovely finalists and the scoreboard for Phase 2 of the competition.

***

Okay, I realise that I’ve been very quiet in terms of posting about SPFBO.  Rest assured this is not a reflection on the Finalists or indeed my progress in reading them, rather that I have been more fixated on getting some reading under my belt before I started to post any reviews.

As you may know, for Phase 1 of the competition I was joined by the wonderful Critiquing Chemist, Sarah and her trusty boffin Jennie, who helped with the initial phase taking on board half of the book allocation and helping to choose our finalist (A Rival Most Vial).

For Phase 2 Sarah has taken a step back due to family commitments but Jennie was still keen to join me in reading through the finalists and scoring each one. However, Jennie also has less time for reading at the current time due to pressures that I won’t go into here and whilst she has been reading we’re both not sure  that she’ll manage to complete all the finalists before the end of the competition, and I certainly don’t want to add any additional pressure in that respect.

What does this mean going forward?

Well, as it currently stands I have now read 6 of the 9 finalists (i’ve started book 7 and I’m hoping to complete that and the remaining two books before the end of the month).  I thought I’d make that clear first in case there were any concerns that the finalists wouldn’t all be complete.

In terms of scoring, Jennie has read and scored some of the finalists, however, as we cannot guarantee that she’ll be able to read all of them before the deadline at this point I will score the books alone – this seems fair and consistent (to be honest, our tastes have aligned very well so far so I don’t think this will affect the overall scores in any sort of dramatic way).

With that in mind I’m going to start posting my reviews very soon, I’ll hopefully be posting one every four to five days.

That’s my update for now.  I’m so sorry that it’s taken me so long to post an update, but, as I mentioned, I’ve been concentrating more on reading than reviewing, and also I wanted to give my partner in books time to get through some of the finalists without adding any stress.

Watch this space, hopefully my first review will go live this forthcoming week.

#SPFBO 9 Finalist Announcement

Posted On 31 October 2023

Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: ,

Comments Dropped one response

 

SPFBO71024_1

What is SPFBO 9?  This is  a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted.  Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants.  Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.

Our batch of 30 books was split equally between myself and the Critiquing Chemist’s team.  We have both now completed our reading, we chose three semi finalists each and we have read each others choices.  So, today is tough decision time.  And, I can say, all these semi finalists were so good.  I really enjoyed them and have no hesitation recommending them all, which certainly made choosing just one even more difficult.

However, I’m not going to prolong the announcement – details of the semi finalists can be found below.  We went back and forth with debate and our chosen finalist for SPFBO 9 is:

**

**

**

**

**

**

**

**

ARival

*

A Rival Most Vial by RK Ashwick is a wonderful cosy fantasy that we thoroughly enjoyed.  Congratulations to the author.

My condolences to the other authors.  We had six superb SFs this year – all quite different.  Here are my reviews for the others.

The First and Last Demon by Hiyodori.  This is a unique story, really engaging and quite compelling and I loved the twist in the tale.  It’s quite insular with a very small cast of characters but is a standalone that leaves no threads hanging.  I literally read this in two sittings because I had to have answers.

Twicetime by Carol Carman.  This story was like my very own personal ‘pick me up’.  It was such good fun.  I simply don’t know why this book isn’t receiving oodles more attention.  I loved it and can’t wait to read my next book by Carol Carman.

Dream of Death City by PJ Nwosu.  Wow, what a fantastic imagination this author has.  This world is dramatically painted in reds and golds.  The way of life is harsh.  I love the ideas on display and the two central characters are easy to get on board with.  A must read.  I want more.

Under the Lesser Moon by Shelly Campbell.  This book is a difficult read and undoubtedly not for everyone but I thought it was brilliant to be honest.  It’s a cruel world, bad things happen (really bad things) but there is hope as well and the ending had me immediately rushing to see when or whether the next book was released.

The Many Shades of Midnight by CM Debell.   Another standalone.  A story with epic scope but told from a much smaller perspective and focused primarily on the characters.  Lovely writing and a fascinating world not to mention a lovely character in the apprentice surgeon.

Finally, don’t forget to stop over to the Critiquing Chemist to read their thoughts.

« Previous PageNext Page »