The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch readalong, week 1
For the next few weeks I will be joining a number of other people taking part in a readalong of the Lies of Locke Lamora, followed by another readalong of Red Seas Under Red Skies. I’m so excited to be doing this because Scott Lynch’s third novel is due to be released this summer and so this acts as a perfect reminder of all that has already taken place.
I love these books! They’re dark, gritty and brutal. They’re populated by great and complex characters. Definitely unflinching and not for the YA market!
If you haven’t already read these books and don’t want to read spoilers please don’t continue with the rest of this post (and, really, if you haven’t read these books what exactly are you waiting for – really, just read them). If you want to join this readalong follow this link:
littleredreviewer.wordpress.com
1. If this is your first time reading The Lies of Locke Lamora, what do you think of it so far? If this is a re-read for you, how does the book stand up to rereading?
I’ve already read the Lies of Locke Lamora but it was some time ago now and so rereading all the detail again is amazing. I think I’m noticing so much more this time because I think the first time I read a book I read it very fast and am totally on a mission to find out what’s happening next so I don’t tend to savour the writing as much as I should. With this reread I’m taking my time and absorbing properly all the information about the place, the food, the descriptions of the orphans and being introduced again to the Thiefmaker (who I can’t help picturing as Fagin from Oliver Twist) and Chains.
2. At last count, I found three time lines: Locke as as a 20-something adult, Locke meeting Father Chains for the first time, and Locke as a younger child in Shades Hill. How are you doing with the Flashback within a flashback style of introducing characters and the world?
I’m really enjoying the flashbacks and the slow reveals of what actually took place with Locke that led to the Thiefmaker finally reaching the end of his tether and deciding to dispose of him. I think the way the time lines jump back and forth make it more interesting. One moment we’re looking at Locke and his crew and what their next job is, then just as they reach a critical point we bounce back to Locke telling his story to Chains. One part of me is thinking what – no, I want to see what happens next, but then pretty rapidly I’m absorbed in ‘younger’ Locke’s tail and then I’m equally as eager to carry on reading that story. I think writing like this and jumping inbetween helps to focus your attention, plus, it’s like you’re reading more than one story so it’s double or even triple the excitement.
3. Speaking of the world, what do you think of Camorr and Lynch’s world building?
At the risk of appearing to just automatically like everything that Scott Lynch does I’m going to admit that I love the world building. What I particularly enjoy is the detail – maybe it’s not to everyone’s liking – but, I find it really easy to build up the world in my own mind’s eye. I have my own idea of what the place actually looks like (which might not be the same as everyone else’s but that’s the beauty of reading). I like the fact that traditions, lifestyles, even food have all been thought about. It makes the whole reading experience rewarding. I even have my own picture of what I think Locke looks like, the twins, Chains – I’ve got it all pictured. Plus, I like the fact that SL has thought about it all. He doesn’t just say ‘okay, here’s the world and this is what it’s like and expect you to be wowed – he builds it up gradually, he introduces you to the unsavoury elements and explores the underground, he gives you a bit about the history, just enough to keep you going, I can practically taste the food and the wine. I can imaging the squalor of certain elements and the richness of others. There are loads of layers that gradually build to give you a perfect picture. It’s like a work of art 😀
4. Father Chains and the death offering. . . quite the code of honor for thieves, isn’t it? What kind of person do you think Chains is going to mold Locke into?
Well, it seems a contradiction in terms, but I guess that Chains is going to mold Locke into a thief with honor! He’s not just going to be a ‘grab and run’ or sneak in the night. He’s going to use his cunning and intellect. Chains is going to develop him and teach him the ways of the world so that he can blend into any setting with ease. He’s going to help develop him to think on his feet and be quick witted. He’s going to help him to become an actor of sorts.
5. It’s been a while since I read this, and I’d forgotten how much of the beginning of the book is pure set up, for the characters, the plot, and the world. Generally speaking, do you prefer set up and world building done this way, or do you prefer to be thrown into the deep end with what’s happening?
I enjoy reading either way, providing the writing is good and in this case it is. Sometimes when reading a novel I just feel like I’m suddenly reading a huge info dump, which doesn’t blend in well with the story and feels quite literally as though the author is thinking ‘okay, let’s get this over and done with’. I don’t enjoy that and it can be distracting and take you away from the plot which is just annoying. The start of this book helps you to see how Locke is as a boy and gives you an appreciation of how is character has come along to reach where he is as an adult. You can see that even at a very young age he was going to be a lot more than just a regular pickpocket – he likes to succeed and has a lot of ambition.
6. If you’ve already started attempting to pick the pockets of your family members (or even thought about it!) raise your hand.
No, I wouldn’t be any good at this as I’m a total wimp. I think that there is a pickpocket in the making in my house however – I usually have to buy a new set of headphones every month (why? I dunno!) plus little things have a mysterious habit of going missing – or I’m losing the plot and can’t remember where I put them. Perhaps we have Borrowers under the floorboards – which would explain why I have 50 pairs of odd socks.
Great questions. Loving it.
Thanks 😀
On a totally superficial note : I love this cover (I can’t help myself from just going there!)
Red Seas Under Red Skies by Scott Lynch
7 September 2011
Filed under Book Reviews, Challenges for 2011
Tags: Red Seas Under Red Skies, Scott Lynch
Just finished reading Red Seas Under Red Skies by Scott Lynch. The first book in this series (The Lies of Locke Lamora) was an excellent addition to the fantasy world of reading that was an absolute pleasure to read. That being said I wasn’t as keen as I thought I would be to pick up this installment and it has in fact sat on my shelf for a long time. I think the idea of Locke and Jean becoming pirates put me off somewhat. But, I was very pleasantly surprised. Although it’s probably fair to say that Book No.1 is the better of the two this is no shabby addition. I think Scott Lynch is almost a victim of his own success in that respect. The LoLL was such an outstanding novel, rich in detail and populated with such great characters and dialogue that it was always going to be a tall order to surpass it and add to that the fact that your follow up novel is no longer as unique as when it first appeared, plus not all of the characters made it to book two and added to that you have a bit of a feel for the characters and how they will behave – given all that this second book is no small achievement.
I won’t go into too much detail about the plot. Basically Locke and Jean have moved on to new shores. They have left Camorr and are now in Tel Verrar where they are busy laying the foundations for their latest heist. This involves them spending a lot of time at the Sinspire – basically a huge gambling joint run by a ruthless man called Requin. Nobody steals from Requin – unless they want to pay the ultimate price and so of course our two gentlemen have set their sights and made it their next target. Added to this, we have an alternative story revolving around internal politicis and double dealing which seas Jean and Locke themselves being duped and resulting in them putting out to sea as pirates.
I really enjoyed this book and it seemed to take no effort at all to complete in spite of it being quite a large novel. I love the world building of Scott Lynch, I suppose some people may find it overly detailed but I love it. I thought Camorr was brilliant in the LoLL and it reminded me of an ‘alternative’ Venice and then again in this story we have Tal Verarr where once again the author’s imagination has simply run riot. The Sinspire is an enormous gambling tower (a sort of mini Las Vegas all located in one building) with each successive level of the building becoming more impressive, decadent and difficult to gain access to. Then, just as we start to come to terms with Tal Verrar everything is tipped on it’s head and the two are desperately struggling to learn the ways of the water. I liked this, it threw both of them out of their comfort zone, particularly Locke who really struggled to find his sea legs and learn all the correct nautical terms. Although in fairness I waned a little when reading about their training the story soon picked up when they put to sea and frankly some of the dialogue which then follows is really amusing (particularly the scene where they first run into the Orchid).
From there onwards we have a number of plots, and plots within plots, that twist and turn quite wonderfully. We are introduced to the pirate fraternity and intrigued by the Ghostwind Isles reached by the intriguing Parlour Passage and it’s creepy inhabitants. The story fairly races along packed to the brim with action, betrayal and even love. We have a really good look at Jean and he gets to really shine in this novel – I find him an excellent character who I enjoy reading about. Added to that we have the richly climatic ending topped off with even more twists in the tale.
Sorry, this is all very vague but it would be so easy to simply ruin this book by giving anything away.
So, on the whole, whilst this might not have been quite as good as the first book I put that down to the novely card having been played already. I actually enjoyed the ‘at sea’ element and thought the pirates, whilst a bit cliched, were a great addition.
In terms of criticisms I thought the ending was maybe a little rushed and I thought the loss of one character in particular was a little predictable. That aside, if you’re looking for great entertainment in a new and imaginative fantasy world this could be your book. Be warned however this is not a light read, it also contains a few scenes of violence and the use of a few expletives here and there – although I didn’t find it to be gratuitous or overly done.
I really liked this story and can’t wait to see where Scott Lynch is taking us to next. His imagination seems to know no bounds!
Rating -A






