Review: Nightshade and Oak by Molly O’Neill

My Five Word TL:DR Review: History and Mythology Perfectly Blended

I absolutely adored Greenteeth and couldn’t wait to read more by this author and Nightshade and Oak certainly didn’t disappoint. O’Neill has a way of blending history and folklore that is quite magical, she also seems to like to bring together two totally different characters, who, on the face of it, really shouldn’t get on, and then throw them into a situation. In Greenteeth we had a lake monster and a witch and in Nightshade and Oak we have a Goddess and a warrior.

The start of the story is amazing. We witness the Goddess of Death, Mallt Y Nos, and her pack of dogs roaming as they sweep through the carnage of a battlefield. Mallt is responsible for sending souls to their final resting place, helping those that are stuck or unhappy. Unfortunately, during her work she is struck by an errant spell that strips her of her immortality. She becomes a frail human, no longer blessed with great strength and speed. The person responsible for this action is a female warrior called Bellis, daughter of Boudicca. The Iceni tribe were making a final stand against the Romans, it didn’t go well and Belis was trying a spell of healing. The two are now thrown together through need and to be fair, although they set out on a quite simple quest things become much more complicated along the way.

What I loved about this.

It’s a really easy story to engage with, similar to Greenteeth. It’s set in a period where myth and magic were still believed in and it blends into the story easily.

I love Mallt. She’s a great character to get along with. She’s been a Goddess for so long, she barely thinks about the things she now does, it’s all automatic, she takes for granted her long life and her abilities so when she loses them not only is it devastating for her but it does make for some situations that definitely bring light relief. She’s so naturally arrogant, but then she finds she can’t climb a hill without hurting everywhere, she feels hunger, she can’t run fast, and she’s smaller in stature than Belis. It’s all quite unbelievable to her and she has to go through a massive learning curve, understanding once again how to speak to others, how to ask for help and finally realising that she can be hurt, both physically and emotionally. She’s interesting and easy to read.

Belis isn’t quite as quirky so in some ways she takes a back seat. She also doesn’t share as much page time as Mallt so although we are treated to little chapters where we see her in the past, it’s not as easy to become attached. Don’t get me wrong, I liked this character, she’s steadfast and clearly been taught well but a lot of what she does takes place off page so you don’t really witness her capabilities. It’s like we’re more wrapped up in Mallt’s conundrum than Belis’s. Which I really didn’t mind.

The world building is to the point. It definitely is the sort of story that expects readers to pick up and run with things and I can’t deny that I found that easy enough to do. This isn’t a history lesson and I’m not sure how historically correct certain story lines depicted are but I enjoyed the way the story blends the Roman elements with the mythological. I also really liked the dialogue and the style in which the story is told. It isn’t heavily described but it conjures a picture and the dialogue isn’t olde worlde but at the same time it isn’t modern and I really appreciate that.

I think I’ve seen the author described as ‘cosy’ fantasy. I can see where this description fits in some ways as there is almost a fairytale element to her storytelling, probably more so with Greenteeth I think, but, I don’t know that I’d say this is cosy. This certainly doesn’t shy away from warfare and death. There is a very slow building romance but there’s also a bittersweet ending – which to me felt like the only real way that this story could end.

Overall, I had a really good time reading this and in fact practically completed it in only two sittings because I didn’t really like putting it aside. I think I can safely say that Molly O’Neill is an author that I will be watching with interest.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.

My rating 4 of 5 twinkly stars

Countdown to 2026: Day 24 – Christmas Eve – One of your most anticipated books for next year

Once again I am counting down to the New Year, as with the previous years I shall be highlighting at least one book per day to fit the prompt on that given day.  The main aim for this countdown is to highlight some of my reads during the past year and to shine the spotlight on them once again (although some of the prompts relate to forthcoming reads).

Today is Day 24 of the countdown to 2026 and a list of prompts can be found here if you wish to join me in counting down to 2026 and casting a spotlight on some of your favourite books.

Today’s Prompt: Christmas Eve – One of your most anticipated books for next year:

I’ve chosen Nightshade and Oak by Molly O’Neill.  Because I loved Greenteeth and can’t wait to see what the author comes up with next.  Plus, check out this cover:

7 Days Remaining

Tomorrow’s prompt: Christmas Day – a book you received as a gift

Countdown to 2026: Day 22 – Reindeers – a book with memorable critters 

Once again I am counting down to the New Year, as with the previous years I shall be highlighting at least one book per day to fit the prompt on that given day.  The main aim for this countdown is to highlight some of my reads during the past year and to shine the spotlight on them once again (although some of the prompts relate to forthcoming reads).

Today is Day 22 of the countdown to 2026 and a list of prompts can be found here if you wish to join me in counting down to 2026 and casting a spotlight on some of your favourite books.

Today’s Prompt: Reindeers – a book with memorable critters :

Greenteeth by Molly O’Neill.  I had an absolute blast with this book.  I couldn’t put it down and in fact Greenteeth herself is one incredibly memorable critter.

9 Days Remaining

Tomorrow’s prompt: Sleigh bells – a series that you want to ring out the praise for

Can’t Wait Wednesday: Nightshade and Oak by Molly O’Neill

CWW

“Waiting On Wednesday” is a weekly meme that was originally created by Breaking the Spine.  Unfortunately Breaking the Spine are no longer hosting so I’m now linking my posts up to Wishful Endings Can’t Wait Wednesday. Don’t forget to stop over, link up and check out what books everyone else is waiting for.  If you want to take part, basically, every Wednesday, we highlight a book that we’re really looking forward to.  This week my book is: Nightshade and Oak by Molly O’Neill.  I absolutely loved Greenteeth and can’t wait to tuck into this one.  Here’s the description and cover – feast your eyes:

An Iron Age goddess must grapple with becoming human in this delightful historical fantasy of myth and magic from the author of the instant hit Greenteeth.

When Malt, the goddess of death, is accidentally turned human by a wayward spell, she finds she’s ill-equipped to deal with the trials of a mortal life. After all, why would a goddess need to know how to gather food or light a fire?

Unable to fend for herself, she teams up with warrior Bellis on a perilous journey to the afterlife to try to restore her powers. Frustrated by her frail human body and beset with blisters, Malt might not make the best travelling companion.

But as animosity slowly turns to attraction, these two very different women must learn to work together if they are to have any hope of surviving their quest.

Expected publication: February 2026

Review: Greenteeth by Molly O’Neill

My Five Word TL:DR Review: I practically inhaled this book

Oh my, I think my little socks have been blown off.  I absolutely loved Greenteeth.  I saw a lovely review for this on a blog that I’ve come to trust very much (thank you Books Bones and Buffy) and decided I had to give it a shot.  I was actually trying to be careful this month but the fae elements of this really appealed to me and so I threw caution to the wind.  My giddy aunt – I’m so glad I did.  I mean, if I hadn’t picked this up I would have missed this perfect little nugget – I don’t suppose I’d ever know just how much I’d be missing it, but even so – I would have been gutted – even if I wasn’t aware of it.  Moving swiftly on.

This is a story full of myths and magic, high and low fae, a terrible evil that must be overcome and a witch, a goblin and a Jenny (swamp or lake hag – sorry Jenny) who go on a quest.  First of all, who doesn’t love a quest?  Second what a great cast and; third just read this if you need a quick injection of fae trickery.

So, I’ve not heard of a Jenny Greenteeth before – although having gone away to check out some more I must have done because apparently there’s one in Pratchett’s Wee Free Men.  Anyhow, Jennyies inhabit lakes and the like (they’re all called Jenny apparently), they have green skin, slimy hair and wicked teeth.  They were quite possibly dreamt up as a way to scare children so that they wouldn’t wander away from home and drown.  Anyway, I absolutely loved Jenny, whose bark was definitely worse than her bite.  She was grumpy and curmudgeonly, although she keeps an orderly lake and a spick and span cave, and she’s become used to living by herself (her daughter having left for different waters many moons since) although she begrudgingly confesses to missing some of the characters from the story when they become absent.

The plot.  Well, as the story begins Jenny is disturbed when something large is thrown into her lake and goes to investigate (perhaps it will be a nice snack) – instead, it’s a woman.  Seemingly thrown into the pool by the village folk.  They have something of a standoff (whilst the woman continues drowning and Jenny ponders the situation) and then Jenny whisks her off to her secret lair.  An underground cave where she stashes all the goodies that end up lost or abandoned in her environment.

I don’t really want to go into everything, best that you discover the tale for yourself.  Its a quick read and easy to become absorbed in.

The other characters.  Temperance is the witch, a good witch I hasten to add, no dark arts here, who is determined to return to her family.  She has the notion that she can cast a ‘forgetting’ spell and return home safely, however, a powerful predator has taken up residence in her sleepy little village and it’s going to take something much stronger than a hedge witch and two lower fae to dislodge it.  Brackus is the travelling salesman type goblin, he can acquire anything from Kelpie hair to strange candles.  He has a soft spot for Jenny and the two have a constant stream of banter in which they attempt to show how much they dislike each other but fail spectacularly.

What I loved about this.  Everything.  The pacing was spot on.  I mean, the story pretty much gets off to an immediate start and the writing is just lovely.  I really enjoyed the dialogue and the way everything unfolds in such an easy and natural way.  I really liked the characters and this is so character focused which is a real must for me.  Jenny is certainly not without her faults, she constantly reminds Temperance and readers that she’s a monster and not to forget it, but even so – I simply liked her.

On top of this, there’s the quest of course.  Our characters travel, through the use of fae gates and roads, to the high court seeking the aid of the Fae King.  There are lake giants, fae dogs and everything is eventually tied together with some lovely olde English lore.

To be honest, this felt like the perfect book at the perfect time.  A coming together of the planets in perfect alignment if you will.  It felt cosy but also drifted into tense territory on occasion and particularly during the concluding chapters and, well, put simply, it made me happy – which is not something to be scoffed at. I eagerly await information about what Molly O’Neill is planning next.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 5 of 5 shimmering stars