Friday Face Off : Better late than never!
5 March 2022
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Books by Proxy, Friday Face off, Ian Tregillis, The Mechanical

Here we are again with the Friday Face Off meme created by Books by Proxy . This is a great opportunity to feature some of your favourite book covers. The rules are fairly simple each week, following a predetermined theme (list below) choose a book (this doesn’t have to be a book that you’ve read), compare a couple of the different covers available for that particular book and choose your favourite. Future’s themes are listed below – if you have a cover in mind that you’re really wanting to share then feel free to leave a comment about a future suggested theme. I’ve also listed events that take place during the year, that I’m aware of, so you can link up your covers – if you’re aware of any events that you think I should include then give me a shout.
I’ve added themes in below. For information, I’m trying out some new ideas so along with coming up with particular items for book covers I thought we could also look for certain elements contained within the book or that play a large part in the story – this really broadens things out because I have plenty of more ideas with this – I’ve gone for a few of the Tough Travel Themes (so a book with that theme – just choose any book – the theme isn’t necessarily on the cover, then compare covers), also, I’ve thrown in some genres and some colours. Hopefully this will open things out a little and give us some more freedom to come up with new books.
This week’s theme:
Genre : Gadgets and airships – a book that is ’steampunk
So, I’ve had a strange few days. Basically, came home a couple of days ago and my dog, who gets very excited, kind of charged at me (and he’s such a clumsy goofball – he didn’t stop in time) and his big old bullet head rammed my arm. Wow, did that hurt. Just a bit. Anyway, I left it for a few hours, took pain killers, tried to carry on as normal with lots of facial wincing and eventually decided I needed to go to hospital. Long story short. Nothing is broken – and thank goodness for that. But it is very sore and so I’m doing everything quite literally single handed at the moment. There you go – that’s my story for this week. Hope you’re all well and sorry for the delay with the Face Off.
This week I’ve gone for a book I read a few years ago and loved. The Mechanical by Ian Tregellis (#1 of The Alchemy War Series.
Here are the covers:
Not a lot of coves to choose from and seeing them together the original one does stand out the most. I do like the mechanical heart though so here it is enlarged a little so you can see the detail:

Which one is your favourite?
If you’re taking part in this week’s theme feel free to leave your link in the comments below.
If you know of an event that’s coming up let me know and I’ll try and include covers that work for the event itself so that you can link up to the Friday Face Off and, as always, if you wish to submit an idea then leave me a comment – or if you’d like to host a week then simply let me know. Also, I would just mention that it’s very possible that some of these might be repeats from previous FFOs although I have tried to invent more ‘open ended’ prompt that can be interpreted differently and also prompts that relate to emotions. Finally, don’t struggle with any of these, this is meant to be a fun way of highlighting books. If you can’t come up with a book you think fits for a particular week use a freebie – perhaps a recent read for example:
Next Week’s Theme : The most recent book you’ve read that has covers to compare
2022
The Mechanical by Ian Tregillis
Just finished reading The Mechanical by Ian Tregillis and what a great story this is. I really enjoyed it, a strange combination of alternate history, steampunk and conflict – in more ways than one – that packs an emotional punch for most of the journey.
I’m not going to say this was a quick read because it isn’t. The style of writing and depth of detail coupled with the ideas and name places do mean you have to give this your whole attention. Or at least I found so. But that’s not a criticism. I loved the world displayed on the pages here and I was entranced almost immediately by the plight of the Clakkers.
At the heart of the story is the war between the all powerful Netherlands who, using the Clakkers that they invented approximately 200 years ago, have risen to supremacy and the French and their King in exile who, having barely survived the last conflict, spend their time trying to find a way to thwart any future attacks.
Thanks to an inventor called Huygens the Netherlands possess the know-how to make Clakkers. Mechanical, thinking and talking machines, much stronger and faster than humans, brought to life through a combination of chemicals and alchemy and controlled by ‘geas’ that make it impossible for them to act on impulse and in actual fact cause them increasing pain if they disobey a direct order. The Guild who create the Clakkers closely guard their inner workings but unfortunately, every now and again, one of the Clakkers seems to break free of the restraints imposed and turn ‘rogue’. And this is how the story starts – with a public execution of not only traitors to the Brasswork Throne but a Clakker who has broken free from his obligations. It’s a great opening. It keeps you hooked with suspense and immediately demonstrates that whilst these automatons are mechanically made objects – they do have the ability to think independently and are far from the simple machines without feelings that the Guild would have everyone believe.
At the start of the story, a precarious ceasefire has been agreed but it balances on a knife edge and rests on the French obeying the terms and conditions to the letter. Of course, both sides are infiltrated by spies and double agents. The Netherlands trying to protect their secrets and the French trying desperately to find out what makes the Clakkers tick before any more attacks come their way.
The story alternates around three main protagonists – Jax, a Clakker whose inner thoughts we become privvy to, Berenice, the spymaster general to King Louis and Father Visser who is in fact an undercover Catholic priest. Their lives will become inextricably linked especially when Visser sets Jax on a mission which has a dramatic impact on both their lives and could potentially create the spark to start a whole new war.
What I found really impressive with this book is the way the author makes you care about all three of these characters. I mean Jax is a mechanical and yet I just loved his character and really cared about him. Similarly Berenice – talk about your creative cursing – she gets put through the wringer for sure but still comes out kicking and fighting. Visser – well, the least said here the better. I could barely read what he went through.
This is certainly an incredibly clever, complex and layered book and I’m sure that everyone who reads it will take away their own interpretation which is something that I really admire. I will mention that the author doesn’t shy away from the more violent aspects of the story. He simply tells it the way it is warts and all – and there are a few stomach turning scenes where blood and guts take a messy centre stage. But, it’s not gratuitous simply realistic and a fairly honest look at the damage that a strong automaton could wreak on what are, comparatively speaking, fragile humans. Is that an argument for imposing geas on the Clakkers – some seem to think so and yet the majority of the violence caused during the story is as a result of human interference.
Very thought provoking. A gripping and enjoyable read with an ending that left me wanting to know when the next book comes out!
I received a copy of this from the publishers courtesy of Netgalley for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.




