#SPFBOX Review: The Oathsworn Legacy by KR Gangi

Today I’m posting my third Finalist review for #SPFBOX (here’s a link to the Finalist table).  I’ve already posted a review for The Humane Society for Creatures & Cryptids (Teraglossa #1) by Stephanie A. Gillis and The Forest at the Heart of Her Mage by Hiyodori.  Over the next two weeks I shall be posting regularly in order to fit all the Finalists in before the competition ends.  So, without further ado lets get to my review The Oathsworn Legacy by KR Gangi.

Firstly here’s the description (courtesy of Goodreads), the cover and a link.

Rawley and Baelin make a living the only way they know how—protecting the people of Centrum by slaying the dark things that stole their childhood: Monsters, and everything evil.

Though the work never ends, and there’s plenty of coin to go around, Rawley and Baelin discover a sinister secret hidden deep within the crevices of Centrum’s past. Centuries of lies and deceit unravel before them, and they soon shift from mere mercenaries to a force that will last generations.

At least, that’s their hope.

Dwarves in the west, Wroughtmen in the north, Elves in the east, and a tyrant king ruling with an oppressive fist, Rawley and Baelin balance on the precipice of total chaos.

Will everything they’ve accomplished be enough to save them from the shadows rising, or will a plot that’s generations old finally drag everything into the abyss?

Oathsworn Legacy is epic fantasy with classic Tolkien elements.  The story revolves around two brothers who, having been orphaned at a young age when their parents were attacked by monsters, become monster hunters themselves.

Although this falls into classic fantasy I thought the first 40/50% of the story stepped out of the norm.  We had a series of adventures where the brothers go about ‘their monster hunting’ quite often getting into all manner of desperate situations.  I have to say that I found this part of the story refreshingly entertaining.  This style may not work for everyone and I confess at first I wondered about this narrative choice but it became apparent fairly quickly that each of the stories was going to be important in terms of introducing both new characters and also plotlines.  Pay attention when you’re reading these stories because they all feed in to the plot at some point.

The story then switches.  The brothers move on with the plans they’ve been harbouring for some time in the process attracting the wrong sort of attention.  From this point onwards things start to go horribly wrong eventually escalating into all out battle.  I did feel like this area of the story was a bit hastily sketched, I felt like we jumped to a fairly well established school for monster hunters and somehow I felt like I’d missed something.

My thoughts on Oathsworn are divided.  I really liked the early stories and there’s a heck of a lot of promise with some of the ideas there that I suspect the author will explore further.  I don’t think I really connected well with the brothers though.  To be fair, I didn’t dislike them but I didn’t feel fully invested for some reason.  I preferred some of the side characters but I did like the fact that the brothers were not totally rigid in their ideas but open to persuasion and I liked the way they became surrounded by good friends.

I also really liked the writing and felt that although this is quite a chunky story it certainly didn’t feel that way when I was reading in fact I read this very easily in a matter of days.

In terms of criticisms.  I don’t really have any as such but epic battle scenes don’t always work for me and so the concluding chapters weren’t my favourite.  But that’s on me obviously.

Overall, I enjoyed Oathsworn and although this reads as a standalone I am curious to see if the author returns to this world.

I received a copy courtesy of the author, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 7 out of 10.

#SPFBO 9: Finalist Review: Hills of Heather and Bone by KE Andrews

SPFBO71024_1

What is SPFBO 9?  This is  a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted.  Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants.  Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.  Also, check out this page to see all the lovely finalists and the scoreboard for Phase 2 of the competition.

Today I’m posting my final SPFBO Finalist review, Hills of Heather and Bone by KE Andrews.

Hills of Heather and Bone cover - 15

This is a book with beautiful writing, a lovely setting and plenty of emotion.  The author provides some trigger warnings over on Goodreads so take a look at those before picking this one up.  Personally, I thought this was a beautifully written tale with so many lovely descriptions.  I did have a couple of issues but let’s start from the beginning.

As the story sets out we make the acquaintance of Percy and Morana.  They live in a small cottage on the outskirts of a rural village.  This is a world full of magic and myth and our two characters both possess magic – Percy has a gift with plants and also is a healer to the small community in which they live.  Morana’s magical ability is unfortunately one that makes their life balance on a knife edge.  She is a bone weaver, she can bring back the dead and usually there is a price for doing so.  Boneweavers are being systematically sought out and removed from society for the threat they pose.  Consequently, our main couple live a life of constant fear of discovery with the necessary running and hiding that this leads to.  We are given a brief insight into the cosy life they’ve managed to achieve when their worst fears are realized and they are discovered by a group authorised to seek them out known as Failinis.

From here on out the couple go on the run, trying to find sanctuary and seeking out family along the way.

I won’t elaborate further on the plot. Instead let’s take a look at what worked for me.

I loved the writing.  It’s so beautiful and frankly a pleasure to read.  The setting, which has a delicious Scottish Highlands feel is also spot on.  There are so many lovely descriptions (I know these don’t work for everyone but what can I say – they work for me) including the plants and flowers that were a joy to read.  The magic is really intriguing, there are various forms, people who can charm animals, or move earth, conjure fire, etc, etc.  And, I will say, I love reading about a couple that are actually already in a loving relationship.  It’s so refreshing.

So, looking at the magic here I was puzzled why the Boneweavers received such a bad deal.  I mean, okay, this is necromancy by another name and I understand that a good deal of ignorance and fear fed into the general public’s overall dislike, but, some of the other magical abilities seemed very threatening, fire for example.  It puzzled me and I wanted to know more.  I do understand that this is a look at prejudice but I think I just wanted a tad more about the world to stop my incessant questions.

In terms of characters.  I really appreciated, as mentioned above, the focus on an already married couple and for a relationship that is realistic with hopes and fears, love and upset, doubt, etc – and this is an emotional read, make no doubt about that.  The author writes this couple so lovingly.  Morana suffers from terrible physical pain and also carries a good deal of emotional pain too.  On top of this she worries about Percy and the uproar that his life has become as a result of her outlawed magic.  Their relationship felt real.  That being said, the show stealer for me was the curmudgeonly chicken that accompanied them relentlessly, loves Percy and is jealous of any and all affection he shows to Morana.

The plot does fall into something of a pattern.  We meet our couple in their cosy cottage, they are confronted by the Failinis, they make a run for it, hiding out in the woods and taking all sorts of precautions to prevent discovery, they find a new place, start to find a rhythm and are again confronted and find themselves on the run, etc.  To be fair I did find this aspect a little frustrating.  I think I would have enjoyed it more if they’d taken some of the action into their own hands,  Not settling down so easily, taking more precautions, being in control a little more and I think even though they were on the run this element lacked tension, because although the couple were frequently sent running into the night with simply the clothes on their backs Percy’s magic was such that they never really lacked for food or shelter.  It took away a little of the fear and hardship that the situation would naturally create.

Anyway, I had a couple of minor issues but nothing that spoiled the read or prevented me from picking this one up.  It is a beautifully told and emotional tale and I loved the author’s style. I will definitely keep an eye out for what KE Andrews comes up with next.

I received a copy courtesy of the author, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 7.5 of 10

#SPFBO 9: Finalist Review: Murder at Spindle Manor The Lamplight Murder Mysteries #1) by Morgan Stang

SPFBO71024_1

What is SPFBO 9?  This is  a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted.  Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants.  Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.  Also, check out this page to see all the lovely finalists and the scoreboard for Phase 2 of the competition.

Today I’m posting my review for Murder at Spindle Manor by Morgan Stang, the first book in the Lamplight Murder Mystery Series.

MASM

Where to begin with this review.  Well, I liked it very much.  It’s a bit crazily chaotic, well written, witty and packs in a lot of imagination.  It’s your basic, gothic-horror, gaslamp fantasy murder mystery.  What’s not to like really, I think the author has covered all the bases, particularly for the type of read I’m really enjoying at the moment.  Gothic – well you have my attention immediately, gaslamp – ditto, now add in the secret ingredient – fantasy murder mystery, with a locked room style case in the style of Agatha Christie – but with ghosts, monsters and other critters – consider me hooked.  Fantasy worlds with murder mysteries are absolutely my thing at the moment.  I can’t get enough of this type of story and so I was more than happy to pick this one up.

We immediately make the acquaintance of Isabeau Agarwal, a huntress on the trail of a deadly monster known as a Doppelvyrm, a beast that longs to be human, killing it’s victims and then perfectly replicating them whilst retaining their memories making it almost impossible to catch.  Isabeau has tracked this monster to Spindle Manor, a stopover that travellers use before making the final journey to Lamplight City (if the monster reaches the City there will be dire consequences and death on a ridiculous scale).  Within the Manor are ten guests and Izzie needs to uncover which one of them is the monster before the morning arrives.  Unfortunately, the death of one of these guests complicates the issue giving her two mysteries to solve and a good deal of hindrances along the way.

What I really liked about this.

There is such a lot of story packed into this relatively small package.  As I said above it does have the tendency to become a bit chaotic at times but overall it has this almost wonderfully ‘hammed up’ style that I really enjoyed.  Locked room mysteries can be so entertaining and Spindle Manor is no exception.  We have our guests, we have all the lies and secrets and so many possible suspects.  Adding to the dilemma is Izzy’s need to uncover who is the monster in disguise and this is hampered by a string of occurences that has everyone running from one side of the manor to the other, as well as going top to bottom, in the search for answers.

The writing is lovely and I found myself laughing out loud on occasion.  The pacing is quick although I will mention that there’s a lot to take on board as the story begins – mainly due to the fact that we are introduced to so many characters in such a short period.  I didn’t find this an issue to be honest, there has to be some set up after all and the rest of the world building blended easily into the story as matters progressed.

I liked the characters, particularly Izzie and her coachdriver/sidekick/partner Evie.  This was a winning partnership that looks set to continue through the series.

The imagination was also top notch.  I wouldn’t say the world building is given a great deal of attention, but, some of the ideas, such as the living doll (a person who has died and been brought back to life but has their mouth stitched shut to stop their soul from escaping), the creature in the attic (which I won’t elaborate on here but let you find out for yourself) and the angry spirit of a former guest.  I would say that I would have liked to know more about the ‘Nobles’ and I was very keen to find out about one particular incident in the book which hasn’t yet been explained but I’m sure will come up again in the series.

The only real criticism I had was that the actual mystery and the investigation felt a little thin on the ground – more time seemed to be spent charging about the Manor checking out new leads which usually led to something monstrous.  And, well, there is that chaotic feel which might not be everyone’s cup of tea, although I found it amusing and intriguing.

Overall, I had a good time with Spindle Manor and I would definitely like to continue this series.

I received a copy from the author, for which my thanks.

My rating is 8.5 of 10

#SPFBO 9: Finalist Review: Cold West by Clayton Snyder

SPFBO71024_1

What is SPFBO 9?  This is  a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted.  Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants.  Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.  Also, check out this page to see all the lovely finalists and the scoreboard for Phase 2 of the competition.

Today I’m posting my review for Cold West by Clayton W Snyder.

coldwest

Cold West is a story of loss and revenge set in the wild wild west where life is cheap.

As the story begins we meet Will Cutter.  Will and his two sons are burying their wife/mother after she passed away following illness.  Life is tough on the farm and not being naturally inclined to the lifestyle, and money sorely lacking, Will finds himself tempted back into his former life as a bounty hunter.  A life of violence and bloodshed.  Leaving his two boys, for what should only be a a few days, maybe a couple of weeks Will sets out with an old friend/colleague to try and claim the rather generous bounty on offer.  Of course, if something seems too good to be true, then it usually is and Will is about to reach a whole new low.

Now I will start out by saying that this is a very dour read set in a harsh and violent world.  There is plenty of violence and more heartbreak for Will along the route he has now chosen and that might not be for everyone.

In terms of the characters.  Well, I felt sad for Will but at the same time frustrated by the way he chose so quickly to return to his former life. Then again, he is grieving and isn’t really thinking straight.  His wife was his salvation.  Her love helped him to choose a new life and without her he has basically come undone.  On the other hand – he did leave his two sons behind which I have to be honest annoyed me – not like he could take them with him of course, but I think there should have been more weight behind his decision.

There is no shortage of action and the pacing is very good.  Considering this is a fairly short book the author manages to pack a lot into the story and I think this really speaks to his ability as a wordsmith, In fact, that was the winning element of the story for me.  The author’s writing is spot on. He sets the scene, he delivers characters that are easy to imagine and spins a tale of sorrow and revenge. I would mention that the story dips back and forth a little.  It’s something of a mixing pot of strange dreams, flashbacks and the action that is taking part in the current timeline, I didn’t find this a problem.

Overall, I can see why this book was chosen as a finalist.  The writing is impressive and for lovers of grimdark this book is a quick and impactful one that can’t fail to impress.

I received a copy courtesy of the author for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 7.5 of 10

#SPFBO 9: Finalist Review: The Last Fang of God by Ryan Kirk

SPFBO71024_1

What is SPFBO 9?  This is  a competition where authors of self-published fantasy can enter their work. The objective to find a winner out of the 300 entries submitted.  Ten judges (or judging teams) each receive 30 entrants.  Each judge/team will eventually submit one finalist to the second round where a winner will eventually be decided upon. Check out Mark Lawrence’s post here to look at this year’s entrants, judges and allocations list.  Also, check out this page to see all the lovely finalists and the scoreboard for Phase 2 of the competition.

TLFOG

Today I’m posting my sixth review of the nine SPFBO finalists that I’ve read.  Only three more reviews left to fall – next one probably later this week.

This is a review for The Last Fang of God by Ryan Kirk.  This is a fairly short(ish) story with a strong  father/daughter focus and the journey they need to make together when the Gods start to meddle in their lives.

Kalen left his warrior life behind.  Once a master of the Runes and with a fearsome reputation he gave it all up for a quiet life in a small village.  He kept his past buried (along with his sword Fang), trying to give his daughter, Sasha, the sort of upbringing that he never had.  Unfortunately, Kalen’s God has other plans and so when Sasha begins to experience night walking episodes Kalen knows only too well what the outcome will be.  He consults one of the local women who reads the signs and confirms Kalen’s suspicions.  Sasha must return to Kalen’s old home, she is being called by his God and to ignore the call is basically a death sentence.  Of course, Sasha is not happy about leaving her life and everything she knows behind, she’s particularly unhappy to discover that her father has been keeping secrets her entire life but at the end of the day tough choices must be made if she wants to stay alive.  The two must now face a difficult journey, made perilous by the number of foes along the way and the ever ticking deadline nipping at their heels.

I enjoyed The Last Fang of God.  It manages to pack quite a story into a relatively small package.  The character work is really good and I enjoyed learning of Kalen’s backstory and meeting the people he knows along the way.

This very much has the feeling of a ‘going from A to B’ type story – fortunately this works for me and the author manages to inject enough new material along the way to keep the story compelling.

As I mentioned, Kalen has an intriguing past.  A feared warrior and master of the runes he was the champion of his God until he left quite suddenly.  His backstory is gradually revealed as the two travel together.  He meets old friends and also enemies (some that used to be friends) and his story falls into place.  I liked Kalen.  He is quiet and confident.  He fears for his daughter and is unsure how to make amends for having kept her in the dark.  To be fair I couldn’t blame Kalen for burying his past, he wanted a shot at normality and although he may not be naturally suited, or indeed love, the farming life, he also wanted his daughter to experience this way of life rather than the brutal and battle soaked one that was his own.

Sasha has the ability to become really quite annoying during parts of the story – but – at the same time I also felt her moodiness and general teenage eye-rolling-reluctant-to-listen-you’ve-ruined-my-life-attitude to be quite realistic in a lot of respects.  She doesn’t trust her dad.  She doesn’t want this new life or the responsibility being thrust upon her.  She constantly rails against it until Kalen begins to share some of his past and more than that come to the realisation that she needs to learn at least some basic skills if she’s going to survive.  And so begins a grudging, tentative at first, sort of respect/truce between the two where Kalen acknowledges that Sasha is a young adult and Sasha realises that her father has a lot of knowledge and experience that he is willing to share.

I really enjoyed this aspect of the story and thought it was really well done.  Yes, Sasha can be infuriating, yes Kalen should open up and help her learn, but these things just don’t happen overnight and I liked that the change between the two was a gradual process.

Now, on top of this we have a lot of rival tribes along the way which helps to maintain the tension.  Kalen is helped out by some unusual conspirators who help the two escape some tricky situations when the outlook looks dire and I loved the different tribes and the Gods they followed.

The writing is good and the pace is also consistently upbeat with plenty of new experiences to keep the story fresh.  I will say that I was surprised that this is a standalone and in fact my only real criticism is that I think this could have easily included more pages – although it is quite refreshing to be asking for more rather than feeling that the story is carrying too much bulk.

Overall this was a quick and punchy read set in a Viking style world with tricky and oftentimes cruel Gods, pretty cool magic and a winning father/daughter relationship.  I would like to read more from this author based on the strength of this novel.  It’s just a shame that he isn’t returning to this world as it has such a good foundation here.

I received a copy courtesy of the author, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 7.5 of 10 (rounded to 4 of 5 for Goodreads)

Next Page »