The City of Stardust by Georgia Summers

My Five Word TL:DR Review : This book is a conundrum

cityof

This book is so difficult to write a review for.  On the one hand this is a really impressive debut with fantastic writing that I practically raced through, it has a fascinating story of otherworlds reached via magic keys that is captivating and then there’s a secret starlit city and a family curse.  Seriously, this book could be written just for me.  And yet. I did have a few issues.  Let’s not jump the gun.

In a nutshell, this is a story of the Everly family – cursed for years for reasons that are unknown, one member from each generation will be taken from the family.  A sacrifice – although, again, the nature of this is also cast in shadow.  Now, as the story begins we meet Violet and her brothers Ambrose and Gabriel. Violet has led a very sheltered life, her mother disappeared many years ago, her brother Ambrose is her main pillar, staying at the slowly crumbling family home to look after her whilst Gabriel seems to whisk in and out on fleeting visits, the nature of what he’s up to being incredibly vague.  Basically, Violet’s brothers have endeavoured to keep her existence a secret but apparently the truth will out and the very person they were hiding her from comes for a not so friendly visit. From this point onwards Violet’s life becomes something of a ticking bomb and in the absence of answers she eventually takes matters into her own hands in her own search for a cure to the curse.

My feelings for this book.

The writing is beautiful.  I loved reading this and will definitely be picking up more by this author. Her descriptions are quite magical and reminiscent of adventures through wardrobes and rabbit holes.  Really my cup of tea.

The idea of multiple worlds, accessed by magical keys, each one unique. A city of stars, set on a remote mountain topped by a tower with scholars bustling back and forth in search of answers.  What’s not to love.

And, we have two characters, you could call them star crossed, and a slow burning romance.

There are so many wonderful things about this book – but, at the same time, and this is why I mentioned this being a conundrum, I have slightly mixed feelings.

I had issues with the pacing.  Strangely enough I enjoyed the first half of the story much more than the second half – and this is unusual because the second half has plenty going on – in fact maybe too much going on and a kind of frantic feeling ending.  One part of me says, well, Violet was definitely on a timeline here so you would expect the tension to increase, however, she was flitting about all over, from place to place (or party to party) but it all felt a little bit pointless, like she wasn’t achieving anything, or she was always arriving just five minutes too late.  I simply didn’t understand what she was actually doing or how she came up with whatever trail she was following.  Similarly to what I mentioned about Gabriel above.  He’s constantly rushing about, disappearing into secret worlds, reappearing bloody and dishevelled – again, what is he actually doing.  I don’t know.

On top of this I’m not totally sure I bought into the relationship with Violet and Aleksander.  Other than that Violet has led such a sheltered life so the attention she received from Aleks perhaps overwhelmed her – I mean, I understand his motives, but I won’t mention them here.

The settings are primarily contemporary, with brief visits to other worlds and also the starlit city.

The other main character is Penelope, she’s the baddie of the piece.  What I would mention is I didn’t really understand why she skipped a generation, Violet’s mother was the sacrifice – she’s gone missing, so wouldn’t one of the two brothers now be chosen rather than Violet – who is the next generation.  Why did she give the family a stay of execution, why the extra ten years – why not just take what she believes she’s entitled to now.  It felt a bit like the baddie in a Bond movie, taking the time to tell 007 exactly how he plans world domination whilst at the same time giving him time to escape.  She had no reason to negotiate and given how she behaved for the rest of the story I think she would have just taken what she believed was her right.  But, then it would have been a much shorter book!

So, in a nutshell, I really enjoyed this book on so many levels.  I know it probably seems that I have a few criticisms but this was still very easy to read and entertaining.  I thoroughly enjoyed the writing and it’s certainly an impressive debut.  On the other hand, it without doubt has some plot holes, it feels like certain issues are whitewashed over so you just need to go with the flow and not question things too much.  For me, I do like answers so there is just a nagging feeling with this that something isn’t quite right. I feel like I’ve missed something – which is of course entirely possible.

I certainly wouldn’t discourage anyone from reading this – like I said, it’s a conundrum, I might have a feeling of not  really being able to fully explain things but at the same time I liked it – what more can I say.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 3.5 of 5 stars

Can’t Wait Wednesday : The Book That Broke the World (The Library Trilogy #2) by Mark Lawrence

CWW

“Waiting On Wednesday” is a weekly meme that was originally created by Breaking the Spine.  Unfortunately Breaking the Spine are no longer hosting so I’m now linking my posts up to Wishful Endings Can’t Wait Wednesday. Don’t forget to stop over, link up and check out what books everyone else is waiting for.  If you want to take part, basically, every Wednesday, we highlight a book that we’re really looking forward to.  This week my book is : The Book That Broke the World (The Library Trilogy #2) by Mark Lawrence.  I’ve been waiting to show this book and finally we have a cover so here it is, one of my  most anticipated reads for 2024:

TheBTBTW

The second volume in the bestselling, ground-breaking Library Trilogy, following THE BOOK THAT WOULDN’T BURN.

We fight for the people we love. We fight for the ideas we want to be true.

Evar and Livira stand side by side and yet far beyond each other’s reach. Evar is forced to flee the library, driven before an implacable foe. Livira, trapped in a ghost world, has to recover her book if she’s to return to her life. While Evar’s journey leads him outside into the vastness of a world he’s never seen, Livira’s destination lies deep inside her own writing, where she must wrestle with her stories in order to reclaim the volume in which they were written.

And all the while, the library quietly weaves thread to thread, bringing the scattered elements of Livira’s old life – friends and foe alike – back together beneath new skies.

Long ago, a lie was told, and with the passing years it has grown and spread, a small push leading to a chain of desperate consequences. Now, as one edifice topples into the next with ever-growing violence, it threatens to break the world. The secret war that defines the library has chosen its champions and set them on the board. The time has come when they must fight for what they believe, or lose everything.

The Library Trilogy is about many things: adventure, discovery, and romance, but it’s also a love letter to books and the places where they live. The focus is on one vast and timeless library, but the love expands to encompass smaller more personal collections, and bookshops of all shades too.

Expected publication : April 2024

Moon’s Artifice by Tom Lloyd

Posted On 8 August 2014

Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: , ,

Comments Dropped 13 responses

Just finished reading Moon’s Artifice by Tom Lloyd and will start by saying what a great start to a fantasy trilogy.  Thanks to Lisa at Tenacious Reader for this recommendation and I also agree completely that this book is greatly underrated.  Given the plot, the characters and the world building I really don’t understand why there hasn’t been more of a commotion about it.

Anyway, moving on.  To the story.  At the start of the book our main protagonist, Narin, is given a task to complete by Lord Shield.  Lord Shield is a God and therefore not somebody readily turned down.  In his quest for information Narin will uncover a plot that threatens the lives of many of the people that, as would-be Lawbringer, he is sworn to protect  He will join with three unlikely companions in a race to find the truth and during this search will encounter assassins, gods and demons alike.  As the story moves forward a dastardly plot will be uncovered and the four will face a massive task in order to save thousands of lives.

Lloyd has written a really interesting world here with magic, assassins, gods and demons.  The setting is the Imperial City which is divided into segments, each ruled by a particular noble house and then further sub divided into castes.   This is a city embroiled with court politics and a grim reflection of extremes with poverty stricken neighbourhoods rife with crime on one hand whilst huge palaces with exotic gardens nestle in the other.  The world building is very well done and easy to imagine.  The Houses all believe themselves superior and rivalry exists between them all although it seems to be universally acknowledged that House Dragon and their warriors are superior and not to be toyed with – in fact better to keep them out of things as much as possible if it can be managed as they will wade in and kick major ass.

At the start of the story we make the acquaintance of Narin – as he unwittingly becomes the focus of Lord Shield.  Narin is an investigator, currently operating under the wing and tutelage of Rye – the most respected Lawbringer in the city.  At the start of the story you could probably say that Narin is hopelessly naive to a certain extent but this is something that he will eventually lose as he develops sharper edges.  Narin is definitely a flawed character and you need only read the start of the story to find out why. He has secrets and frankly he isn’t perfect – you could almost be forgiven for wondering why his mentor Rye isn’t the main focus as he certainly seems more astute and far more capable in a tough spot.  But I kind of like that Narin isn’t perfect.  He isn’t totally ninja, he gets exhausted running up a large flight of stairs and his indiscretion has undoubtedly led him into a whole heap of trouble.

On top of this he is accompanied by his friend Enchei – an older man and supposedly a tattooist (responsible for tattooing people’s caste’s onto their shoulders) although he has many secrets of his own.  Initially he comes over as a grouchy guy who refuses to bend the knee to his so called superiors and balks at everyday convention.  Enchei is a great character and definitely one to pay attention to.  I would have welcomed a little bit more information about exactly why he has befriended Narin but it’s possible this may be more forthcoming in future instalments.  His other companions are Irato – one of the assassins’ order known as the Goshe who has mysteriously lost his memory following his clandestine rooftop adventure at the start of the story, and Kine, a fisherman’s daughter living in the poorer district and helping, alongside her sister, to keep her mother’s boarding house.

What I particularly liked about the story, including the magical elements and the slightly out of sync with the time inclusion of gunpowder weapons and other strange gadgets, was the way the Gods and Demons seem to interfere with everyday life.  They’re all playing their own little games in an almost parallel way to the regular mortals.  Each vying for supremacy.  I liked that they simply appear amongst people and everyone is completely unphased by this! In a similar way, the demons take control of certain animals who become their eyes around the city.  It is possible to call a demon and ask for help if you know the incantation.  Not something to be tried at home though!  The casual inclusion of deities and magic and the personalities of the four main characters are definitely the winning elements to this story.

In terms of criticisms.  I didn’t really have anything major.  I think the writing is very descriptive and that’s not to everyone’s taste as some prefer plot to prose but personally I enjoyed the detail.  And, I would say this definitely has a quest type feel and in that respect there is the element of you fall into trouble, you get out of trouble, then you fall into trouble and get out of trouble.  However, the pace is fast and the Lloyd definitely succeeds in building tension.

Overall I thought this was a very enjoyable read and I will certainly continue with the next book to see when Mr Lloyd takes us next.

 

 

In which I give you fantasy not to be missed!

256e2-toptentuesday

Top Ten Tuesday is a weekly meme hosted by the Broke and the Bookish.  This week’s topic:

Top Ten Books I’d Give To Readers Who Have Never Read X:

Well, if you’ve read this blog before you’ll probably realise I focus fairly strongly on fantasy with a sprinkling of sci-fi and a little horror, mystery and history.  So, for my ten choices this week I’m going for books from fantasy to give you an idea how you can read many different styles whilst getting your fantasy fix (let’s face it, I never miss a chance to bang on the fantasy drum).  This may seem like a bit of a cheat because I do have more than one example for each description but I do only have 10 descriptions!!

Fantasy:

  1. Children: Something to read to your children (not too young though – particularly if they don’t like spiders!!): The Hobbit by JRTolkien
  2. For the YA: I’m going to go with Harry Potter by JK Rowling, this is a series that a young person can get their teeth into and grow up with.  The series becomes progressively darker and the school setting means that a YA audience can easily relate.
  3. If you want stories with a fairytale feeling: The Graveyard Book, Stardust, Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman – BUT not all of Gaiman’s work is a light read so be careful what you pick up!!  Or, Sarah Pinborough who recently wrote three short books that were fairytale retellings – Poison, Charm and Beauty.  They depict a different side to Disney’s princesses and although fairytale style are definitely adult books.
  4. If you want alternative history: there are a few examples for this but, some are a bit deep if you’re new to fantasy and don’t want to move straight to epic – the major series that has turned people’s opinions on their head in terms of fantasy is the Game of Throne series by GRRMartin which is not so much alternative history but does have a mediaeval setting (that being said – this is fairly epic to say the least!). There is Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke. This is a very indepth venture set during Napoleonic times.  Alternatively, the series written by Jasper Kent  (The Danilov Quintet) which is an alternative Russian history with Vampires otherwise known as Vorodalak – starts in Napoleonic times and works up to early 1900s.  If you want an alternative Victorian history then a bit of Gail Carriger’s Parasol Protectorate might not go amiss – steampunk with a bit of spice.  Otherwise you could just opt for Bram Stoker’s Dracula which is a classic.
  5. Light and whimsical, only bordering slightly on fantasy: I would suggest two authors for this – Joanne Harris (Chocolat, Coastliners or Blackberry Wine) or Alice Hoffman (Practical Magic, The River King. or The Museum of Extraordinary Things).
  6. Grimdark – well, this is very popular in fantasy at the moment and maybe not for everyone.  However, I love Mark Lawrence’s Prince/King and Emperor of Thorns.  This series is dark and even more so because of the age of Jorg at the state of the story.  But, in spite of this Lawrence’s writing and plotting is second to none.  The vision he has for the whole series is nothing short of breathtaking.  If you want to try something a little lighter but set in the same world then ML has started a new trilogy starting with Prince of Fools – this is set in the same world as the Broken Empire (Thorn) books but has a different feel completely with two very enjoyable characters – I can’t deny that the ending gets a little bit more heavy BUT I think by then you’ll be totally invested in the main characters.
  7. Military based, I recently read Django Wexler’s Thousand Names – this is alternative military, apparently known as ‘flintlock’ (thanks to Mogsy for letting me in on that secret!) which apparently means based during the musket era.  I really enjoyed this book, it is fairly in depth to be honest but for people who want to go easy on the fantasy element it’s very lightly done.  If you fancy something a little bit different then All You Need is KIll is very short, quick and enjoyable – set in the future with battles against aliens but the central character, who dies at the start of the story (that isn’t a spoiler) then comes back to relive the day over and over – groundhog style.
  8. Something a bit more romantic: – The Outlander series by Diana Gabaldon.  Involving a bit of jumping back and forward in time this is a good series (although I haven’t read all of them).  If you want something a bit more, ahem, spicy, then Karen Chance or Christine Feehan maybe (so I’m told…..!).
  9. Detective based: Jim Butcher’s Dresden Files – this is one of those series that has a world living in parallel to the everyday mundane world.  It involves a wizard called Harry who also acts as a private investigator and assists the police with ‘supernatural, cases.  A very entertaining series so far.
  10. Classic:: I had to do it – I never miss an opportunity!  It would be rude not to mention Lord of the Rings by JRTolkien and this way I start and finish the piece with him.  However for other classic fantasy – A Midsummer Night’s Dream, A Christmas Carol, Frankenstein – the list could very easily go on and then on some more!

Now, if you were going to dip your toe in the fantasy pond do you think you might be tempted by one of the above?????

American Elsewhere by R J Bennett

Just finished reading American Elsewhere by Robert Jackson Bennett.  I’ve been longing, nay gagging, to read this book for quite some time, partly because I’ve really enjoyed all this author’s other books and also I read a stellar review over at Little Red Reviewer.  What can I say – other than it doesn’t disappoint.

In usual Bennett fashion the book seems to defy any particular genre.  Is it sci-fi?  Yes, in some respects.  Is it horror? Definitely in certain places.  Is it spooky and paranormal? The first half of the book definitely fits into that, well, actually, so does the second half!.  Is it quirky and are there tentacles aplenty…I couldn’t possibly say, or at least if I told you I’d have to kill you – so think on!

Where to begin with this review!   The book opens with a funeral and a will reading.  Mona’s father having passed away has bequeathed upon her his worldly goods.  No real sorrow here as there seems to have been little love lost between the two.  Mona seems to be there for one purpose only – to get her hands upon her late father’s red sports car – that is until she discovers that there’s a house also involved in the will.  A house that appears to have belonged to her mother and is situated in a place called Wink!  An opportunity to maybe finally discover more about the mother she lost at such an early age and in such strange circumstances that the details have been indelibly imprinted upon her mind.

And so Mona sets off to lay claim to her property.  Of course this isn’t as easy as it at first appears.  The town of Wink seems to be unheard of.  It doesn’t show on any maps, nobody can give you meaningful directions, you basically have more chance of happening upon Brigadoon.  Remember that horror movie, I think it was called Children of the Corn (but I could be making that up) where once you’ve driven into the village, no matter which road you take to exit it leads you straight back?  Well, this is the exact opposite.  Wink seems to exist in a bubble. That being said Mona somehow manages to find a way in – making a rather dramatic entrance in her flashy red car as she interrupts a rather sombre funeral that practically all the town seems to be attending.

Wink is a strange place.  Picture postcard perfect and yet goose bump forming with its quiet streets and creepy inhabitants.  You could be forgiven for thinking Mona has entered the land of Stepford and yet this isn’t all about perfect partners in flowery pinafores making preserves.  Things in Wink are not quite as they seem.  The facades are perfect but inside the walls a different story unfolds.  And, people don’t go out at night. There seems to be an unspoken agreement that its best to stay indoors!  In trying to uncover more background about her mother Mona begins to reveal the weirdness that is Wink.  Sometimes out of the corner of her eye things look different than they first seemed and after forming a tentative friendship with a couple of the more eccentric locals cracks begin to appear in the outer veneer.  Is it wise to dig too deeply and has Mona’s arrival in the small town of Wink become the catalyst for a string of events that everyone will come to regret.  Like I’m going to answer that!

The problem with reviewing this book is that it would be so easy to spoil the reveal and I really don’t want to do that so I’m basically not going to elaborate on the plot at all.  On to other points

This is a big book with plenty of detail and information and yet it doesn’t feel slow.  There’s this delicious creepiness that draws you in until you realise that you’ve read what effectively is the first half of the novel and what then turns into the fundamental turning point for the whole story.

In terms of characters.  Lets just say they’re an eclectic bunch – not only the inhabitants of the town (and the outer boundaries of the town) but the owner and employees of a rather sleazy bar called the Roadhouse (situated just out of the town boundaries) – rather a den of iniquity with drugs, fighting, prostitution and a sinister and bizarre partnership between the owner and an unknown man who supplies the drugs that make the place a magnet for certain types.  Of course he doesn’t supply these drugs out of the goodness of his little old heart and the services he requires in exchange are odd at best and nightmare inducing at worst (plus – there’s a particular scene which leads to the discovery of where these drugs actually originate and it’s pretty revolting to say the least – I think it would be enough to make anybody think twice!)

Plus, there are even odder characters that live in the forests on the outskirt of Wink – giant characters that seem to inhabit strange places and one particular character that dwells in a cave filled with tiny rabbit skulls – be very afraid of this particular person!

Then we have Mona – she’s really quite cool.  Got a whole bunch of attitude and I confess a bit of a potty mouth but it fits in with her persona and doesn’t feel gratuitous.  Mona never really settled down and a series of sad events in her past seem to have turned her into a bit of a hard case loner.  She certainly isn’t a shrinking violet and doesn’t need rescuing – she can damn well look after herself thank you very much.  I wouldn’t say I love Mona but she is a good character to read and the whole turning into a ‘green beret’ type kick ass in the forest was great readingl.

In terms of criticism I think the only point I would make is that I didn’t feel any particular attachment for any of the characters.  I didn’t dislike them and I was crazy intrigued to know what was going on but I didn’t have that strange reader/character bond that you sometimes seem to feel for these imaginary people.  That confessed it certainly didn’t stop me from feeling gripped and I wonder if it’s the author’s intention that you feel this way towards the characters – they’re all a little odd after all.

The setting is really very well portrayed and the town easy to envisage.  Shrouded in mystery – why is this town here, how come nobody ever leaves.  What strangeness exists in the woods and who is the guy with the long rabbit like ears (or could they be horns)!

On top of this – there’s this whole scene where one of the more unusual characters uses a scene from a Gene Kelly film – I loved that scene.  Sorry, I know it’s a bit of a teaser to write this in this way but there’s nothing else for it!

Plus – who’d have thought sibling rivalry could be so drastic.

Anyway, that’s all I’m going to not say about it!  Consider yourself teased and go check it out for yourselves.  If you want to read about a mysteriously creepy little town and the whys and wherefores of the strange inhabitants who live there then pick up American Elsewhere.

Other novels by RJ Bennett – all really good: The Troupe/Mr Shivers/The Company Man.

« Previous PageNext Page »