Review: And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie

My Five Word TL:DR Review: Loved It, especially the reveal

And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie is a book that I’ve wanted to read for some time.  I bought, a few years ago, a copy of a paperback version and I think I also might have had a kindle version but when I saw this on Netgalley, well, firstly, I knew that it would give me the push I needed to pick it up and secondly, I was fascinated about this collector’s edition and the way the ending is revealed.

So, if you’re not familiar with And Then There Were None its a closed room mystery that takes place on an island where a number of guests have been invited for a mystery weekend.  One by one the guests begin to die and it soon becomes apparent that a murderer is amongst the party.

I had such a good time with this.

Having read Christie before I had an idea of what to expect with the style.  The writing is very easy to get along with.  The style is, I suppose, dated, I think the original was probably written in the 1940s and the characters, the dialogue and the set up is reflective of that but I loved it.

As mentioned, we have a number of characters that arrive at Soldier Island to be met by the housekeeper and butler.  Only ten people in total.  The island is completely cut off from the mainland and stormy weather makes it impossible for the inhabitants to leave once the murders begin.

In each room is an old nursery rhyme and on the dining room table are ten pottery soldier statues – which slowly but surely disappear in line with the murders.

None of the characters know each other (apart from the butler and housekeeper who are man and wife). 

Quite early in the story an ominous and intimidating record is played to the guests in which they are all accused of murder.  This of course causes immediate outrage and much stomping about followed by loud declarations of innocence.  Within fairly short order we have our first victim.  To begin with the guests think this may have been a suicide and although they all still feel uncomfortable and wish to leave the island they don’t at this point have any other fears – until the next body appears – two dead bodies in such a short period, even though they don’t immediately stand out as murder, it’s a bit of a coincidence.  And then the third body turns up and it becomes clear to all that their lives are in danger.

So, much searching of the island and the house ensues.  Some of the party have taken to solitary confinement and reflection, almost with a resigned feeling of the inevitable.  Of course, the island is small and practically barren with no hidey holes.  Likewise the house is a modern structure, clean lines and also very little room for evasion.

What I really liked about this.

The pacing is great.  There’s always something going on.

The mystery.  I’m pretty certain I’ve seen an adaptation of this but if I have I still didn’t guess the ending correctly.  To be fair my impatience got the better of me.  I started trying to work things out methodically and, not blowing my own trumpet, I thought I’d made quite a good job of coming up with the answer – but – well, firstly I was wrong, secondly there is a rather large clue which I’d completely overlooked and thirdly, there’s an element to the solution that I was totally closed off to.  Plus, as I mentioned, my impatience got the better of me and I was so excited to read the ending I just went for the first person that I thought sounded feasible.  Perhaps if I’d have taken long and reasoned things through – well, I don’t know.  

The characters, I don’t think any of them are particularly easy to like – which isn’t to say I strongly disliked any of them.  But, they’re all keeping secrets and some of them are definitely guilty and guilt ridden. I don’t think you’re supposed to love them to be honest which is just as well because the body count rises very quickly.

I have absolutely no hesitation in recommending this.  If you like a fast paced murder mystery, short, snappy and full of intrigue then you need to give it a shot.  The clues are all there, my only advice, don’t be like me and rush into your conclusion.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 4.5 of 5 very entertaining stars

 

 

 

Review: Cold Snap by Lindy Ryan

My Five Word TL:DR Review: Not Sure About This One

Having just read and thoroughly enjoyed Bless Your Heart by this author I couldn’t resist requesting a copy of Cold Snap.  Before I start on my thoughts this is a novella and I hadn’t realised that at the time, they rarely work for me as I prefer something I can really sink into.  That being said I don’t think this particular story would necessarily benefit by being longer.  It’s overwhelming bleak and there’s no let up from the despair so I think the shorter length and ability to complete in one sitting works in it’s favour.

The story starts with an introduction to Christine and her son Billy.  Two weeks ago Christine’s husband Derek fell from a ladder, whilst stringing Christmas lights, dying instantly.  As you may imagine the mood is terribly depressing and the holidays are fast approaching.  Before he died, Derek booked a holiday cabin for the vacation and his wife has decided to still go on this winter break in keeping with her husband’s original intent.

Immediately the atmosphere is very moody.  Billy barely speaks, Christine is riddled with guilt and constantly replays her husband’s fall in her head and the whole adventure seems ill set.  Things steadily go from bad to worse.  The cabin is freezing cold and a bit shabby.  The two have no appetite to make things any better and Christine, as well as suffering from some sort of blackouts starts to see a huge beast at the edge of the woods.

Okay, to be honest, my headspace is definitely not right for this book.  Having suffered loss myself last year I hadn’t realised just how dark and depressing this was going to be and it simply wasn’t for me.  I’m more about upbeat, cosy and light at the moment.   That being said, I still love a bit of horror and mystery but this one felt to raw.  So bear that in mind.

This is well written without doubt and having read the author previously I think I was prepared for her particular blend of bloodiness.  The atmosphere is tense.  The two main characters are constantly on edge and the whole affair feels desperately cold.  Ryan can certainly set a scene and create palpable tension.

The characters.  Well, it’s difficult to like them but that’s understandable.  They’re going through perhaps the most awful trauma they’ve ever experienced and instead of bringing them together it’s actually forcing them apart.  Christine is suffering guilt, she thinks her son blames her and would prefer that it had been her who fell and witnessing her husband’s fall from a position of seeing everything and yet being unable to help has affected her mentally.  She’s not coping well to be honest.  Neither is Billy although, and in spite of his almost non verbal communication, he’s probably coping better than his mom.

So, I think the writing is great, the atmosphere and tension you could cut with a knife and the dynamic between the two is taught enough to snap at any moment.  Then things go crazy.

My issues with this.  As I mentioned above, I’m not in the right reading mood for such sadness.  I want something that’s going to lift me and this isn’t that thing – I can see this might work for others – just not for me at this particular point.  I didn’t feel the sort of love or affection from Christine towards Billy that I would expect – but – and this is a big BUT – I’ve never experienced what she has and clearly it’s affecting her in so many ways.  She’s driven all the way up to a cabin in the woods without bringing any real supplies.  She doesn’t stop on the way even to let her son eat, she hasn’t considered the fact that stores will close early or there’s a storm as well as a holiday approaching.  But, yes, I get that she’s not functioning at the moment – but it just added another layer of sadness for me.

What is also missing from this for me is, apart from the sadness, there are no other emotions really evident. Christine actually witnesses something that, to me, should have hit her like a ton of bricks, but it didn’t.

Also, I’m just going to warn you that there is a pet involved in this story – and it doesn’t end well at all.  I mean in fairness, there’s another death which is also a bit nasty.

Finally, I simply didn’t understand the ending.  There I said it.  I feel like a raging dunce but I hold my hands up – what was going on??  This is probably just me.  Be warned.

I don’t really want to be overly negative and I certainly wouldn’t discourage others from picking up.  It just didn’t work for me.  I will certainly have no hesitation picking up anything by this author.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 2.5 of 5 stars rounded to 3

#SPFBO X Semi Finalist Announcement

SPFBOX

For those who don’t know about SPFBO (the Self Published Fantasy Blog Off) – this is a competition created and run by Mark Lawrence.  The competition is now in its tenth year and you can find more about all the other entrants and judges over on Mark Lawrence’s blog.

I have now completed my reading for Stage 1 of the competition.  I had five books that I read and reviewed and I chose two books to pass to my co-judges (The Critiquing Chemist.).  Likewise the Critiquing Chemist chose three books to pass to me to check out.  These five books are our chosen Semi Finalists and are posted below

Without further ado here are our five finalists.

*****

****

***

**

*

I will soon be reviewing the three books selected by the Critiquing Chemist but for now here are the titles linked to their Goodreads page.

Commiserations to the authors whose books have fallen. We had a lot of great books and some difficult decisions, with one final tough decision still yet to come.

By A Silver Thread by Rachel Aaron

Through Blood and Dragons by RM Schultz

The Enchanter’s Counsel by Thalib Razi

Smile and Be A Villain by Yves Donlon

Touched by Magic by Celine Jeanjean

 

Review: The Wilding by Ian McDonald

My Five Word TL:DR Review: A Little Slow to Start

I enjoyed The Wilding.  The writing is really good, very evocative and the author sets the scene very well.  Yes, it was a little slow to start as we get to know the characters.  To be honest, on the one hand, I’m not totally sure that all the character building was totally necessary as some of these characters are about to meet a grisly end, but, on the other hand, if the author just skimmed over these characters and gave them no depth it would be immediately obvious that their roles were going to be short lived, so, for me, it’s worth taking the time to get to know these people as it definitely makes their sudden demise much more shocking.

The premise of the story is a group of rangers and young adults, going into the wild to spend a night, at one with nature.  It’s an unlikely group of characters in some respects.  Lisa, the MC, is longing for a new start in life at University and in fact this little wilderness trek is probably going to be her last mission.  The other young adults don’t particularly come across as enthusiastic (at least not all of them) about this little jaunt into the wild and have an almost bored, are we really doing this, attitude, but they’re going to get a sudden jolt of nasty reality in fairly short order.

The author sets the scene early.  There have been unexplained attacks on farm animals and other unexplained incidences.  The setting feeds into the atmosphere perfectly.  This is a rewilding project based deep in rural island where the locals, the project itself and nature are struggling to come to a balance and, well, ultimately failing it would seem.  There’s a lovely build up of tension, I would say that at one point I was on the brink of wondering when the action would kick in but then suddenly I was in the middle of chaos.  When the proverbial hits the fan things go batpoop crazy.  The wilderness seems to take on a mind of its own causing confusion and driving the party deeper into the bog.  There’s bad weather, marshy boglands, bugs and that awful feeling of being watched coupled with the hysteria and panic created when people are desperately trying to survive. And there are some really unusual settings where our little group find shelter.

I don’t really want to say too much more for fear of spoiling the read for others.  I enjoyed this, it had a slightly slow start but I think that initial build up makes the story more dramatic.  There is definite horror and blood and guts.  I don’t know whether I’d call this a folk story.  It’s more like nature as a whole – showing us it’s power coupled with the journey of one character in particular – Lisa – who starts the story longing to move on before going on something of a self discovery jaunt herself, becoming very protective of the young people in her charge and throwing caution to the wind as she tries to keep them alive.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 3.5 of 5 stars rounded to 4 for the strange and dark appeal

Can’t Wait Wednesday : The House of Frost and Feather by Lauren Wiesebron

CWW

“Waiting On Wednesday” is a weekly meme that was originally created by Breaking the Spine.  Unfortunately Breaking the Spine are no longer hosting so I’m now linking my posts up to Wishful Endings Can’t Wait Wednesday. Don’t forget to stop over, link up and check out what books everyone else is waiting for.  If you want to take part, basically, every Wednesday, we highlight a book that we’re really looking forward to.  This week my book is: The House of Frost and Feather by Lauren Wiesebron.  Here’s the cover and description (basically I was hooked by that opening sentence!)

SPINNING SILVER meets HOWL’S MOVING CASTLE in this beautiful debut Slavic folklore fantasy.

Marisha’s life is not going as she expected. With the sleeping plague only a few months away, she’s as desperate for money as she is to escape her aunt’s torturous marriage prospects. Leaving all that she’s known behind, Marisha accepts a job working with the notorious koldunya, Baba Zima in her house that glides on chicken feet through the snow.

But Baba Zima is renowned for being both clever and cruel. And most difficult of all is her current apprentice, Olena, who wants nothing to do with Marisha. Despite her fears and Olena’s cold demeanour, Marisha finds herself drawn into the magical world of koldunry and delves further into Olena’s research – a cure for the sleeping plague.

Accompanying Olena on an increasingly dangerous, seemingly impossible search for a cure, she finds hidden connections between the sleeping plague, her own family’s history, and her bizarre, recurring dreams: dreams of a masked ball where the deep sleepers are trapped endlessly dancing – and a monstrous beaked man haunts her every step . . .

Expected publication : January 2025

« Previous PageNext Page »