Review: The Wilding by Ian McDonald

My Five Word TL:DR Review: A Little Slow to Start

I enjoyed The Wilding.  The writing is really good, very evocative and the author sets the scene very well.  Yes, it was a little slow to start as we get to know the characters.  To be honest, on the one hand, I’m not totally sure that all the character building was totally necessary as some of these characters are about to meet a grisly end, but, on the other hand, if the author just skimmed over these characters and gave them no depth it would be immediately obvious that their roles were going to be short lived, so, for me, it’s worth taking the time to get to know these people as it definitely makes their sudden demise much more shocking.

The premise of the story is a group of rangers and young adults, going into the wild to spend a night, at one with nature.  It’s an unlikely group of characters in some respects.  Lisa, the MC, is longing for a new start in life at University and in fact this little wilderness trek is probably going to be her last mission.  The other young adults don’t particularly come across as enthusiastic (at least not all of them) about this little jaunt into the wild and have an almost bored, are we really doing this, attitude, but they’re going to get a sudden jolt of nasty reality in fairly short order.

The author sets the scene early.  There have been unexplained attacks on farm animals and other unexplained incidences.  The setting feeds into the atmosphere perfectly.  This is a rewilding project based deep in rural island where the locals, the project itself and nature are struggling to come to a balance and, well, ultimately failing it would seem.  There’s a lovely build up of tension, I would say that at one point I was on the brink of wondering when the action would kick in but then suddenly I was in the middle of chaos.  When the proverbial hits the fan things go batpoop crazy.  The wilderness seems to take on a mind of its own causing confusion and driving the party deeper into the bog.  There’s bad weather, marshy boglands, bugs and that awful feeling of being watched coupled with the hysteria and panic created when people are desperately trying to survive. And there are some really unusual settings where our little group find shelter.

I don’t really want to say too much more for fear of spoiling the read for others.  I enjoyed this, it had a slightly slow start but I think that initial build up makes the story more dramatic.  There is definite horror and blood and guts.  I don’t know whether I’d call this a folk story.  It’s more like nature as a whole – showing us it’s power coupled with the journey of one character in particular – Lisa – who starts the story longing to move on before going on something of a self discovery jaunt herself, becoming very protective of the young people in her charge and throwing caution to the wind as she tries to keep them alive.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 3.5 of 5 stars rounded to 4 for the strange and dark appeal

Monthly Wrap Up/What’s On My Plate September/October

I’m trying to post a wrap up for the end of each month, mainly to help me to keep track of my reading and at the same time look at what I’m intending to read during the month ahead (inspired by Books Bones and Buffy’s What’s on My Plate.

In this post I shall be looking at the reading I completed for September and what I’m hoping to read during October.  I hit a bit of a shady patch this month and didn’t quite finish all my planned books – and looking at October, well, I seem to have turned into a raging maniac requesting ALL the books and literally I don’t know what I was thinking.  Well, I do.  I just wanted them all, they all looked so lovely and they were calling to me.  Anyway.  This month I have two review books that I’ve not managed to complete but I’m still aiming to pick them up when I have a quieter month (November/December).  I have two reviews to catch up with at the moment and then onwards to my October books.

Here’s what I read during September:

  1. Fortitude’s Prize by Ceril N Domace (SPFBOX)
  2. The First Assignment by Billy Kramer (SPFBOX)
  3. River of Crows by NP Thompson (SPFBOX)
  4. This Girl’s a Killer by Emma C Wells
  5. So Thirsty by Rachel Harrison
  6. Lucy Undying by Kiersten White
  7. Touched by Magic by Celine Jeanjean (SPFBOX)
  8. Smile and Be A Villain by Yves Donlon (SPFBOX)
  9. Gorse by Sam K Horton
  10. The Ravening by Daniel Church
  11. The Glassmaker by Tracy Chevalier – review to follow
  12. The Wilding by Ian McDonald – review to follow

This month I had nine review books and five SPFBO books.  I have two review books to complete, I started both but put them down temporarily as I don’t think I was in the right headspace.  So, twelve books all together.

What I’m hoping to read during October(with links to Goodreads) (although I realise this is a tall order and probably unlikely – but I can roll some books over to November).

  1. The Bog Wife by Kay Chronister
  2. The Coven by Harper L. Woods
  3. The House at Watch Hill by Karen Marie Moning
  4. Candle & Crow by Kevin Hearne
  5. The Last One at the Wedding by Jason Rekulak
  6. The Book of Witching by C.J. Cooke
  7. Run by Blake Crouch
  8. Cold Snap by Lindy Ryan
  9. Hear Him Calling by Carly Reagon
  10. Strange Beasts by Susan J. Morris
  11. The Fury of the Gods by John Gwynne
  12. Here One Minute by Alex Lake
  13. The Scholar and the Last Faerie Door by H. G. Parry
  14. The Queen by Nick Cutter
  15. Magic by Sarah Pinborough

I also have a couple of books sent to me directly by the authors and three potential SPFBOX Semi Finalists.  So, realistically, there’s no way I’m going to complete them all. But, in my defence some of these were requests that came in late.  Oh, who am I kidding – there are some great books on here so I couldn’t resist.  And, just look how lovely they all look:

BTB

This month I read no Backlist Books -boo (I am still reading The Wisdom of Crowds by Joe Abercrombie – which is very good but I simply keep forgetting to listen to the audio version).

Bookforager‘s Picture Prompt book bingo

PPBBC

This month I’m ticking off the ‘clouds’ prompt from my Picture Prompt bingo card. 

I’m using Fortitude’s Prize by Ceril N Domace – a story that predominantly takes place in the sky so seems quite appropriate.

5 – 4 – 3 – 2 – 1 Book Tag

I just saw this tag over on Books Bones & Buffy’s blog.  I’m not sure where this originated so can’t credit the creator at this point.  All books are either linked to reviews or to their Goodread descriptions.  For the most part these are reads from 2024 except #3. 

5 Books I Love

  1. The Heiress by Rachel Hawkins
  2. The Tainted Cup by Robert Jackson Bennett
  3. The Silverblood Promise by James Logan
  4. Gorse by Sam K Horton
  5. We Used To Live Here by Marcus Kliewer

4 Books on My TBR

  1. The Devils by Joe Abercrombie
  2. Beautiful Ugly by Alice Feeney
  3. The Fury of the Gods by John Gwynne
  4. The Book of Witching by CJ Cooke

3 Books I Will Always Recommend

  1. Delicate Condition by Danielle Valentine
  2. Daisy Darker by Alice Feeney
  3. The Wolf Den by Elodie Harper

2 Recent 5 Star Reads

  1. A Sorceress Comes to Call by T Kingfisher
  2. A Little Trickerie by Rosanna Pike

 

1 Book I’m Currently Reading

The Wilding by Ian McDonald

 

 

 

Review: The Ravening by Daniel Church

My Five Word TL:DR Review: Didn’t Really Work For Me

I enjoyed The Hollows by this author so was really looking forward to this one but ultimately it just didn’t work it’s magic. But, first things first.

This gets off to a very intriguing start.  Jenna and her mother are travelling when their car breaks down.  Stranded in the forest things escalate quickly and Jenna’s mother disappears.  Fast forward and Jenna is 30 (ish), the mystery of her mother was never solved and has left her with severe trauma and trust issues  She struggles to hold down a relationship for more than a couple of months until recently meeting Holly.  The two, on the face of it, feel like opposites, but they click somehow.  They’ve just returned from a camping holiday, not something Jenna would usually undertake as she remains afraid of the forest since that terrible night when her mother went missing.

From here the story takes a completely different tack and not one that I was particularly expecting.  The horror wasn’t what I was hoping for, don’t get me wrong, the situation that Jenna finds herself in is definitely horrific, claustrophobic and anger inducing – and I don’t want to go into detail here as it’s probably best discovered during the read – but it simply wasn’t what I was hoping for.

So, what did and didn’t work for me.

I liked the ancient evil that is at play.  It’s a terrifying beast and there were some very creepy moments whenever it put in an appearance.

There are a couple of occasions where Jenna is, let’s say, making a break out – I found these gripping and tense.

In terms of criticisms.  I found it very difficult to like any of the characters and this is really a problem for me.  I wanted to like Jenna, she’s been through a lot and in fact continues to experience some terrible situations, but I didn’t find myself really caring.  The same with the relationship with Jenna and Holly, it just felt very flat, they didn’t really come across as though they even liked each other to be honest, it was all super prickly.  And, this is a small niggle, but the constant use of the word ‘babe’, it really irritated me, to the point I was actually becoming really grumpy and skipping over the dialogue in order to avoid it.  On top of that, I’m not really a lover of dream sequences in stories and they play quite an integral part here.  They rarely work for me.

I think some of my issues literally fall into the ‘its me not you’ category.  There were some exciting moments, some tense scenes and the final chapters rolled out more of the horror that I was expecting.  It just felt like a lot to get through in order to get to that point.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 2.5 of 5 stars (rounded to 3)

Review: Gorse by Sam K Horton

My Five Word TL:DR Review: Simple.  I loved this book.

I love stories of the fae but confess that I’m sometimes disappointed when they fail to shine, show their difference or stick their heads above the parapet.  I recently fell for Heather Fawcett’s Emily Wilde’s fae stories which I highly recommend and now I think I’ve found another story of the Others that delivers on so many levels.  This is definitely not a Disney version of the fae and I loved it.

Gorse is a period piece.  Set in Cornwall of 1786 this is a time of very mixed beliefs.  The church was trying to get a firm grip on people and shake the superstitions out of them and at the same time the Others and their Keepers were not totally ready to relinquish their hold.  That’s a very quick overview for a story that pretty much throws you straight into the mire.

What I loved about this.  The writing is gorgeous.  The entire story is steeped in atmosphere and intrigue.  The setting jumps off the page.  Bogs, moors, flowers, patches of beauty followed by the grim and ethereal.  There’s a feeling of cold grubbiness, of strife, of bitter recriminations and murder all shrouded in mist and shadow. And, slowly but surely, the body count is stacking up.

There’s a mystery here but not in the traditional sense.  And you really do have to bear with the storytelling because there is some set up here – but, I loved it all.;

The characters, Nancy and Pel, the dog Pat and the horse Selkie.  I fell for them all with their secrets and lies, their steadfast loyalty and courage.   Let’s also not forget the fae, those cheeky little critters that are full of mischief and danger, living in the rafters and dusty corners, tending the hearths and helping out generally when treated right and then the more dangerous Others that dwell below, The Hunt and their King.  There is much danger in these pages but it’s tempered by the beautiful writing and the love that grows for the characters.

These are savage and desperate times.  Crowds are easily driven to frenzy with mobs baying for blood and our characters have their work cut out to stay alive – in fact there is much death amongst these pages.

On top of this there’s the whole split world, Cornwall and beneath.  Startlingly similar and yet dramatically different.

I had such a good time with this. History meets folklore.  It’s not particularly fast paced in the first half but this isn’t a criticism.  I loved the set up, getting to know the world and the mystery that’s taking place in the pages.  It’s deliciously dark, full of intrigue and ends with a tantalising glimpse of what’s to come next.  I can’t wait.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 4.5 of 5 Pisky stars

« Previous PageNext Page »