Review: Death at the Sign of the Rook by Kate Atkinson

My Five Word TL:DR Review: Fantastic Characters meet Murder Mystery

Kate Atkinson is an author that I really like, I haven’t actually read all her Brodie books but did read the first few pre blogging and enjoyed them and so couldn’t resist the description for this one.

This story brings to us a range of quirky and eccentric characters, a murder that takes place in a manor house whilst the lord of the manor is actually holding a murder mystery party.

There is some set up for this before we get to the murdering and sleuthing that takes place in and around the grounds of Burton Makepeace.  The story brings to us Jackson Brodie, an ex-cop turned private detective.  He’s taken a case about a stolen painting.  At the same time another case comes to his attention which seems to share very similar traits.  Could this be the same person.  Basically, Brodie enlists the help of a former colleague – who you could call his sidekick as he is usually one step ahead and the two start searching for clues.

Now, firstly, picking this up I thought we would fairly soon be ensconced at the cumbling manor house with a storm keeping the residents and guests hostage.  However, this isn’t quite the case, there is some detective work that takes place before hand and also an introduction to a number of the more standout characters  This is in no way a criticism as Atkinson is an absolute wonder at drawing her characters and giving you some fantastic favourites to plump for.  And, any patience you exercise beforehand will be well rewarded as the scenes at Burton Makepeace are so good.  There’s an almost comedic element to certain scenes and that coupled with the ever so quintessential British eccentricity of some of the characters makes this a really engaging read.

To be honest I don’t really want to say too much because of spoilers and the desire not to ruin the read for others.

What I will say is the writing is wonderful.  The pacing takes a little time to pick up but I think it’s worth the wait and the characters are really good.

I have to give a little shout out to the Dowager who absolutely stole the show for me.  Brodie and DC Reggie Chase make a fantastic team and you know that you’re enjoying a book when you seriously start to worry about any harm coming to the main characters.  Fortunately this is quite a cosy read although it wouldn’t be a murder mystery without any bodies now would it?

I had such a good time with this.  A murder mystery.  A positively Christie style guest list, the vicar, the Dowager, the Army Major, a pack of invited guests expecting a thrilling evening of murder mystery shenanigans, little expecting that a real murder has actually taken place, and a detective and his sidekick arriving to the party just in the nick of time.  Did I mention that there’s an escaped criminal on the loose and an intense storm that gives the proceedings a locked room feel?  Well, there you go then.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 4.5 of 5 stars

Review: Long Live Evil (Time of Iron #1)by Sarah Rees Brennan

My Five Word TL:DR Review: Slow Start But Have Patience

I will admit that I had a brief moment when I first started reading Long Live Evil where I considered setting it to one side to pick up at a later time (and lets just face it I’m not kidding anyone when I say that because everyone knows that book will then be doomed).  Fortunately I pressed on and I’m so glad that I did because I ended up really enjoying this and loving the characters.  And, quite unexpectedly, because I seemed to have convinced myself that this was a standalone novel, it seems that there is more to come.  Which is a relief because otherwise that ending would be very puzzling indeed.

So, basically, as the story begins we meet Rae, in hospital with cancer.  Her sister spends a lot of time at her bedside reading stories and in particular the one fantasy series that they both love for very different reasons.  Not to beat about the bush Rae is seriously ill, she is visited one day by a mysterious woman who, in a nutshell, lays things on the line.  She’s not going to survive and her family will be destitute after paying for all the treatment.  Said mystery woman offers Rae a chance at survival.  She can enter the world contained in her favourite fantasy series, as one of the characters and use her time there to retrieve a magic flower, if she retrieves the Flower of Life she will return to her own world and recover.  If not, well, she won’t be returning.  Of course Rae takes the deal, when you have one choice at survival what you going to do, but, on waking in the country of Eyam, and discovering she is in the body of Lady Rahela, she soon deduces she may have been duped.  Lady Rahela is about to be executed the very next day for treason and, being all too familiar with the storyline Rae knows exactly the torturous death she’s about to face.  She needs to come up with a plan.

I won’t give away any spoilers but instead discuss general thoughts and feelings.

I feel I should mention that it did take me some time to get into this one.  I’d say a good 30%.  Possibly because there’s quite a lot to take on board in the early stages and also because it took me a little while to really get a handle on what was going on and where the story was actually going.  Rae’s knowledge of the world, particularly from the first book in the series is sketchy and so I felt like I was stumbling around a little at first in much the same way that she was – although she had a much better handle on the key characters and all their ridiculous nicknames. In the early stages I wondered if this was going to be similar to the Princess Bride but I was soon disabused of that notion as this isn’t about somebody telling a tale to a sick person but instead it’s the sick person actually taking part in the tale themselves.  That being said, much like the Princess Bride, it does poke fun, and has a good time doing so, at the tropes of fantasy which is something I really enjoyed.

The characters.  I really did like so many of the characters.  I’m not sure you’re supposed to like a murdering, sociopathic bodyguard but I did.  I couldn’t help it.  He was a two faced duplicitious so and so for the most part who wouldn’t hesitate to slit your throat and steal the dress off your back – his name is Key.  We also have Emer, Lady Rahela’s maid.  She’s not best pleased with her lady, as we soon find out, and with good reason, but she plays such a good role and soon finds out she’s a dab hand at wielding an axe.  The Golden Cobra is probably my favourite character, a charmed man, he runs the local brothel and has a laid back attitude and a way with words, he’s blackmailing one of the heroes of the piece in order to gain access to the castle and the nobility.  Okay, I’m not going to list all the characters, they all seem to have fallen straight out of a Diane Wynne Jones Tough Guide to Fantasy.  They all have a role to play and their characters are almost carved from stone.  Rahela for example, she’s the evil woman who connived to win the crown and the King by seeing her step sister put to death.  She’s also branded a seductress and the funny thing is, whether she’s angry or sad, happy or indifferent her curves are always resplendent, she walks with a sultry sway and her voice is set at a level to seduce – she’s the evil seductress, this is her character, but of course, she’s also Rae.

Now, what Rae soon discovers, much like a time traveller who has jumped back to tinker with events thereby changing the future, the plot of this story has similarly become an unknown beast.  In escaping her own execution Rahela has turned the course of the story and she’s now set on a desperate mission to put it back on track.  At first she doesn’t feel any remorse, these are not real people after all, they’re characters in a book, but Rae is also now living in these pages and her actions have very real repercussions.

I really enjoyed the writing style.  Rae, being a 21st century girl, quite often acts or says things that are way too modern to belong in a mediaeval setting but I really liked these moments, because she is, after all not from that period and it leads to a few comedic repercussions.  I wouldn’t necessarily say this is a laugh out loud sort of story, it made me frequently smile or raise my eyebrows at the shenanigans taking place and I did enjoy a lot of the dialogue, particularly when it involved, Rae, Key or the Cobra.

In conclusion, I was surprised to find that this wasn’t a standalone (I don’t know why I thought it was to be honest), and happily surprised because I’m more than intrigued and keen to see where this story goes next.  I’m not at this point sure this is the story I thought I was going to get but I enjoyed it perhaps even more for the unusual route it took me down.  And, in spite of the snarky brevity and sometimes light feel to the story it raises some heavy topics.  Rae, after all, is very sick, she’s also lonely and angry and so the opportunity to be the ‘bad girl’ really appealed to her but even with the freedom that falling from grace can bring she is actually still a good person who really wants to get home (and not kill everyone else in the process of doing so).  Perhaps there’ll be some ruby slippers in book 2.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publishers, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opiniion.

My rating 4 of 5 dastardly villainous stars

Review: Tales of a Monstrous Heart by Jennifer Delaney

My Five Word TL:DR Review : Mixed Feelings With This One

Tales of a Monstrous Heart has so many things that I was looking forward to and usually love in a novel.  A gothic tale with hints of Jane Eyre and a brooding love interest.  A world divided where the fae are treated as second class citizens and a return of darkness that brings with it a mystery to be solved before more fae are kidnapped and killed.

Katherine Woodrow is a fey student at the Institute of Magic.  Unfortunately she’s usually in trouble with the mortal council who will pounce upon any excuse to try and expel her before she can complete her studies.  As the story begins Katherine is once again in trouble and is only saved expulsion by a Mage Partnership offer by the elusive  Lord Blackthorn (Emrys).  Accepting this offer Katherine and her companion (and shape shifter) Alma take up residence at Blackthorn Manor.  Soon enough these two central characters become embroiled in a mystery that both need to solve quickly before the encroaching darkness threatens their way of life.

What I really enjoyed about this.  The writing is really good, it kept me hooked.  This isn’t a short and snappy style but given the type of story I really liked the attention to detail and I loved all the details about the house.

I really liked the side characters.  The house is practically a character itself.   And I also have to give a shout out to Thean who is a deliciously wicked character.  I liked Alma, Katherine’s constant companion since childhood although I felt she was a little under used and often seemed to appear simply at opportune moments to stage a rescue.

I think the author does a really good job of creating chemistry and tension between Katherine and Emrys, sly glances, hands brushing against each other all clearly leading to forbidden desires.

I found myself a little bit puzzled with the plot and the direction it took and this is an element to the book that I struggled with a little.  In one respect I feel like I missed something and perhaps I did and need to go back and have a reread.  In the earlier stages there’s quite a bit of history between mortals and fey to take on board and some of this felt a little clunky at times.  On top of that I wasn’t always clear about the motivations of all the characters, other than the thirst for power – at any cost.  The plot sometimes had  a feeling of being simply too much.  I would also say that Katherine is quite often placed in very difficult and upsetting circumstances and I didn’t really get a feel that Emrys helped very much – part of me thinks good for Katherine, she’s very capable and doesn’t need rescuing but at the same time I think it would be nice to feel that Emrys would at least speak up for her, which you would expect given he’s her mentor.  Perhaps that’s a little wrong of me, clearly the two were playing roles in order to covertly investigate – but even so, it irritated me slightly.

Also, I would just mention that this ends on a cliffhanger which is not something I’m very fond of to be honest.

Overall, I enjoyed this because it’s well written and the characters were quite easy to like but I didn’t feel totally enamoured with it which is what I’d expected and I think the plot in some ways feels a bit convoluted.  So, I have mixed feelings.  I really like certain elements but others didn’t quite wow me.  I can see why this would be popular though so don’t take my little niggles too seriously.

I received a copy though Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 3 of 5 stars

Booking Ahead/Weekly Wrap Up

Sunday Post

Today I’m posting my Weekly Wrap Up and II’m linking up to The Sunday Post over at Kimberly’s  Caffeinated Reviewer.  Without further ado:

Books read this week:

Slowly but surely I’m catching up with my blogging and reviewing.  This past week I posted five reviews and I might have another intense week going forward which should then put me back on track.  In terms of reading I finished The Seventh Veil of Salome by Silvia Moreno Garcia.  It’s not my favourite book by the author but that’s more an issue of personal taste because the writing is really good (I wasn’t absolutely in love with the storyline but I think others will be).   I read Death at the Sign of the Rook by Kate  Atkinson, this is really good for lovers of cosy mystery, I had a good time with it, it perhaps wasn’t quite what I was expecting in some respects but it has good characters and a great sense of humour.  I also started Long Live Evil by Sarah Rees Brennan – which I’m enjoying, about 40% into the story so far.  Unfortunately I’ve had to set aside one of my review books as it wasn’t quite working for me.  The Girl With No Reflection by Keshe Chow.  This gets off to a really good start, with good world building and some very creepy early scenes but then we run into an instalove situation that just didnt work for me but to be fair that’s one of my pet gripes and really I’m not the target audience so don’t be put off by my grumps.  In SPFBO news I’ve completed my final batch of five books (reading the first 25%).  I shall be posting soon about the books that will be cut and those that I’m going to read fully with a view to choosing SFs.

Next Week’s Reads:

  1. The Drowning House by Cherie Priest
  2. A Marriage of Undead Inconvenience by Stephanie Burgis
  3. The Wilds by Sarah Pearse
  4. A Poisoner’s Tale by Cathryn Kemp
  5. The Seventh Veil of Salome by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Outstanding Reviews

Review: The Seventh Veil of Salome by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

My Five Word TL:DR Review : Definitely a Thought Provoking Book

I absolutely love Silvia Moreno-Garcia’s books and so was in no doubt about wanting to pick up The Seventh Veil.  This is another story where the author jumps genres this time tackling not just the golden age of Hollywood when it’s obsession with Swords and Sandals movies was at its height but also taking a look at an infamous character from biblical times.

On one hand I wouldn’t say that I loved this one, or at least it’s not my favourite by this author, it took me a little while to get into the story and in fact I set it aside at one point, Salome’s chapters felt very dry and the ending felt a bit anti-climatic after such a build up, then on the other hand the writing is absolutely lush, the storytelling voices are so well done, the author captures the Hollywood period as well as any Director could and the interwoven tales of these three women is so thought provoking.  A story within a story with three females all playing the lead in their own productions.

Our three characters.  Vera, the young woman who has landed the much coveted role of Salome.  Vera has no experience in the film industry and in a way it’s like throwing a tiny minnow to the sharks, a tasty snack at most.  Nancy has been trying to make it big for about four years now.  She is beautiful for sure but in a place where beauty is around every corner and the opportunity to become famous relies almost on the whim of chance she has become desperate, conniving and bitter.  Finally Salome.  Another female manipulated by those around her.  On top of this we have snippets of interviews and press articles that pretty soon make it apparent that something bad is going to happen

All three women have things in common.  Their beauty, which brings with it wanted and unwanted attention, the way they are manipulated by those around them and have little choice.  Her whole life Vera has played second fiddle to her sister – the one who was supposed to make it to Hollywood, prettier and more talented (according to their mother).  Vera never expected fame in fact she was more comfortable off camera composing music.  Thrown into a role she didn’t expect she is treated as little more than an object by those around her.  She’s just so lucky – or at least she’s constantly told she is.  Nancy, on the other hand, wants fame and fortune so badly that she’s become obsessed with it, she is the one doing the manipulating here but at the same time as massively disliking her and her self entitled expectations I did feel a little sorry for her.  In its way, Hollywood has also chewed up Nancy and spat her out.  She didn’t make the cut.  Salome.desired by men seems to hold some sort of irresistible pull – in fact I did do a little read up about Salome having finished this and her infamous dance of the seven veils, and there is speculation that Salome was only a child at the time, influenced by her mother and not in fact this siren who held sway over any man – perhaps her own story has been manipulated over time to become the one we know today.  Another male production with the woman at the centre holding sway and portrayed as a conniving she devil.

In terms of the writing.  Well, as I’ve come to expect this is nothing short of beautiful. The depiction of Hollywood is simply brilliant.  The way the studios ran the lives of their stars to the nth degree, telling them who to be seen with, what to wear and even where to go in order to be snapped favourably.  The place comes alive.

Criticisms.  I can’t really criticise the book to be honest.  What I would say is that I didn’t enjoy this particular story as much as some of the author’s other work but that’s a personal taste thing more than there being anything to criticise here.  I do think the start felt a little laboured and some of Salome’s chapters were a bit dry but it is a very thought provoking and well told tale.  If you love this Hollywood period I think you’ll get a real kick out of all the little details with this story.

In conclusion, not my favourite but still a very well told story that gave me plenty of food for thought and I confess I don’t think I’ve probably managed to articulate my real thoughts on these three stories as well as I’d like.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

My rating 3.5 of 5 stars rounded to 4

« Previous PageNext Page »