Book vs Film
Okay, a very short article to quickly pick your brains – and, no, I’m not trying to say this is a short article because you have a small brain! I just mean my article is short (obviously your brain is appropriately sized). Anyway, on the back of this thought provoking article over at Little Red Reviewer which I really enjoyed (and is spot on because there are so many films out there which I enjoyed and hadn’t even realised there was a book!), and because I’m nosey and it piqued my interest I thought I’d try and think of the following:
- Films that I enjoyed better than the book (is that possible??? )
- Books that I liked better than the film
- Books that I can’t decide between because the film did a pretty damned good job of bringing the book to the screen.
So, I’m going to keep this to 5 for each category (more difficult in some categories than others) – let me know what your’s are:
No.1 – Films I enjoyed more than the book (this is a toughie)
- Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone (although this is my least favourite of all the films)
- Wuthering Heights (old B&W version)
- Jaws
- Warriors
- The Ring (although I didn’t dislike the book at all- just thought the film was more creepy – especially the original)
No.2 -Books I liked better than the film
- The Hobbit
- I am Legend
- Jane Eyre
- the Woman in Black
- Lovely Bones
No.3 – Books I can’t decide between: (or like equally or for different reasons)
- Lord of the Rings (both brilliant – and who am I kidding Aragorn *sigh*)
- Gone with the wind
- High Fidelity
- Rebecca – (thinking of the older version)
- The Princess Bride
Book vs film: your views please.
The Emperor’s Soul by Brandon Sanderson
28 March 2013
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Brandon Sanderson, Once Upon a Time, Stainless Steel Droppings, The Emperor's Soul
Last night I finished reading The Emperor’s Soul by Brandon Sanderson and I have to say before I write one more word that I loved it. This is only a short novella but wow, such a great story and the character building is excellent. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this book and I will without a doubt be reading it again.
Firstly, a brief outline of the story. At the start of the story, Shai is being held prisoner with the threat of imminent execution hanging over her head. She’s a forger- similar to how we understand the concept except using magic Shai carves seals which when stamped onto an object change it’s appearance. It’s based on the concept of everything, every day objects, having a memory and being able to manipulate this to change the appearance of the object. Shai’s captors however have other plans. They offer Shai the opportunity to stay alive. In return however she needs to forge something that seems impossible. The Emperor lies unmoving in his rooms following an attempted assassination and his advisors have an unusual proposition for Shai. They want her to forge a soul. Never attempted before Shai has no idea if this will work and so as to add a little more stress the task must be completed in three months.
Why did I love this story. To be frank I can’t really pin it down. It’s not like there’s an epic story taking place here after all. But I just really enjoyed it and do we always need an epic story? Apparently not. Shai is wonderful to read about. Seeing her take on this task, watching her inner turmoil about whether to attempt to escape or see the task through to eventually becoming overtaken with the overwhelming desire to succeed. The other characters are also easy to imagine, Gaotang particularly was easy to get along with and Zu was absolutely awful, just as he was supposed to be. What I liked about the way Sanderson wrote Zu was the way he stayed true to his character. At the start I had that ‘hello’ feeling – I was assuming that Zu would eventually turn his feelings around from hate to love but he didn’t and I love that Sanderson didn’t fall into that particular cliche.
I think for a short story, clocking in at under two hundred pages, this is so beautifully self contained. It doesn’t feel as though anything is missing. Sometimes when you read a novella like this you feel unsatisfied but that definitely isn’t the case here. Obviously I could have continued to read about Shai because I was enjoying her story so much but as it is this doesn’t feel incomplete, it also doesn’t feel as though it’s been pared down. It’s a perfectly sized package. It’s well written, the world building is simple but effective and the ending is awesome.
In case it’s not obvious already, I did really love this. I’ve probably not given a very articulate review of exactly why but I hope that if you read this, in spite of my incoherent babble, you’ll go ahead and pick it up too.
I’m adding this to my Once Upon a Time event being hosted by Carl at Stainless Steel Droppings under the auspices of fantasy. Go and check out the event details here and I hope you can join in with the fun. Happy reading.
A Hatful of Sky by Terry Pratchett, readalong week 3
27 March 2013
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: A Hatful of Sky, litt, Readalong week 3, Terry Pratchett
We are nearing the end of A Hatful of Sky which I admit is a little bit sad because it really is a fun book and spending time in Tiffany’s world is an enjoyable way to spend the evening!
If you haven’t read this book before then you might want to avoid the rest of the post in case of spoilers and if you haven’t read any of the Tiffany Aching series I really do recommend them.
This week’s questions are provided by Andrea at Little Red Reviewer so stop on over and take a look and also don’t forget to call in at Dab of Darkness to check out the discussion there.
I got a chuckle out of Tiffany’s visit to ZakZak’s shop, especially the bit about the different styles of witch hats. What kind of witchy goodies would YOU buy there?
It’s a funny shop for sure – I was imagining what it would be like if all your books had eyes set in the middle – you’d have a constant stack of books rolling their eyes at you in disgust because you’d not picked them up yet! Mmm, now what to buy, well I’m low on eye of newt, not to mention tongue of dog (*eyes up her two dogs sat innocently on the rug in front of the fire*). This is a tough one. I genuinely don’t know – perhaps a crystal ball – it would be useful to see into the future! Or a broomstick – flying around would be such a stress reliever!
Inside Tiffany’s head might be the strangest place the Feegle have ever been. What did you think of Pratchett’s imagery of her mind, and of her safe place?
Yet again I thought this was really well done by Pratchett. A really dark and quiet place – which given that most of Tiffany was absent I guess it would be. I liked that it was everything that she felt comfortable with, the shack, the green rolling hills, the horse, and the absolute hush made it all the more chilling because it sort of embodied everything about Tiffany but without her being present. I thought her safe place was a really good idea and hadn’t guessed what was going on at all. I loved it when she rose up out of the hill and squished the hiver!
Poor Miss Level. Do you think she’ll ever recover from what happened to her? How is this going to change her relationship with Tiffany?
Well, given her own natural kindly nature I think Miss Level won’t hold this against Tiffany. I also think she may come to think of it as a blessing in disguise. She still has the extra pair of hands but without the duplicate body – which was a bit odd – and hopefully she will get more respect from the villagers now as they’ll think she’s more ‘witchy’!
In the discussion Tiffany has with Mistress Weatherwax at the end of chapter 9, Weatherwax gives Tiffany some very important information about how to be a witch. Who would you rather study with to become a witch? Weatherwax or Level?
Miss Weatherwax is certainly a very interesting character and I can’t deny it. That being said Miss Level is obviously good to study with due to her natural compassion and care for others. Again, not sure about this one. Part of me thinks Weatherwax but then the sensible side says that Level is a really good starting point to teach a bit of humility – perhaps I could go to Weatherwax for a masterclass!
Any thoughts on how the story might end? Do you think the Hiver is gone for good?
I don’t think the Hiver has gone yet. It’s creeping about for sure. I have this weird feeling there’s going to be a showdown.





The Hum and the Shiver by Alex Bledsoe
Filed under Book Reviews, General Comments
Tags: Alex Bledsoe, The Hum and the Shiver, The Tufa
The Hum and the Shiver is an unusual story that’s difficult to pin down and I’m not even going to try because it will just give away spoilers which I don’t want to do. I went into this book not really knowing what to expect and so think you should do the same.
At the start of the story Bronwyn is returning home wounded from time in Iraq. She’s hailed a hero and everyone turns out to welcome her home and yet on actually reaching her home the welcome is somewhat different, even a little frosty. It seems not everyone thinks Bronwyn is a hero and not everyone is pleased to see her return.
Bronwyn is part of the Tufa people. The Tufa people have been around for longer than anyone can remember. They were up in the mountains of East Tennessee even before the Europeans set foot there. With their jet black hair and complexion they’re a distinctive group of people Very close knit, they share secrets and speak to each other using there own sign language. They don’t take easily to strangers and their music is not simply something played for entertainment value but has a much deeper rooted meaning that affects their whole livelihood and wellbeing.
When Bronwyn returns home she is both mentally and physically injured. Being back amongst her people will fairly soon take care of her physical condition but whether or not she can settle down into the life that is expected, that in fact drove her away in the first place, is another matter. Brownwyn has always been something of a rebel which is what drove her away from the restrictions the Tufa way of life placed on her in the first place. However, things are happening at home. Strange signs and warnings that the Tufa know only too well mean that death will be visiting soon. Bronwyn needs to come to terms with her place and she needs to do so sooner rather than later.
I liked Bronwyn, in spite of herself. She can certainly be a stroppy character and she’s not afraid to tell people how it is in quite a brutal fashion but if you look beneath the surly exterior there’s more to Bronwyn than at first meets the eye. She’s only twenty after all and doesn’t want to settle down to a life in the hills, all mapped out for her, this is why she ran away to start with – it’s strange though how she ran from one set of rules to another. It’s sometimes difficult to remember how young she is in this story as such a lot of weight seems to rest on her shoulders and she does come across as more mature but then she’ll go and get all paranoid about not having shaved her legs or something and it makes you look at her with new eyes and remember she’s only just left her teens and yet already dealt with such a lot. Bronwyn is no soft and cuddly girlie though, she’s not really concerned with appearance and has always been something of a rebel and not without good cause earned herself the title of ‘the Bronwynator’. I liked the fact that Bronwyn isn’t all girlie, she’s not a jump at the sight of a mouse type girl and isn’t afraid of most things – except maybe not being able to remember her music.
The characterisation in this novel is again excellent not to mention the world building. I quite literally could picture the place and the people easily. It just doesn’t feel like a made up place, it feels like you could drive there tomorrow and meet these people.
The other main characters in the novel are Pafford, the local sheriff who seems to spend his time trying to scare people out of their pants for doing absolutely nothing at all (and all I will say here is a big high five to Bronwyn on that score for getting the better of him), Hicks, the grumpy old guy who sits on his porch expecting respect from everyone and seems to have the running of the place to a certain degree, he’s even more sinister than his regular old grumpiness prepares you for, Craig the new priest who is trying desperately to be accepted in this environment, Dwayne, Bronwyn’s ex boyfriend and general no-good nasty piece of work and Don Swayback who is just starting to come to terms with his own Tufa connections. It’s a boiling pot of characters and everyone gets thrown into the mix.
I’m not going to say to much other than that. This novel moves slowly, simmering quietly until the lid finally blows. It will make you wonder if you’re really reading what you’re reading or whether you’ve just in fact misread it!!! Sorry if that sounds a bit mysterious but that’s genuinely how it feels at points. If you’re looking for all out action or adventure though this may not be to your liking it takes it’s time setting up the story and doesn’t just plough on in there just to satisfy the reader’s impatience.
In terms of criticisms, I don’t think I really had any (except maybe the fairly constant references to blow jobs! – come on give me a break, I get it, Bronwyn was sexually active). Otherwise, I think this is well written and quite compelling. I certainly didn’t see the twist towards the end and it almost had me in tears. It’s a tough story about coming to terms with your own place in your family and community and the fact that sometimes you can be a square peg in a round hole. And, there’s a little bit more to it than that – which interestingly may be based on certain myths or folklore – I would certainly be interested to find out more on that score and I think this is probably the set up for a series so I will hopefully have the opportunity to do so.