Kushiel’s Chosen by Jacqueline Carey, readalong week No.4
23 August 2015
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Jacqueline Carey, Kushiel's Chosen, readalong week 4
Today is week No.4 of our readalong for Kushiel’s Chosen. This week our host is the lovely Lisa at Over the Effing Rainbow. As you would expect – spoilers lurk below – so beware. All welcome, if you want to join the readalong or jump in with comments then please do so (here is the SCHEDULE). This week’s questions and answers below:
1. Last week we talked a bit about who might succeed Cesare Stregazza as Doge. This week we learn that he might not be out of the game just yet, after all. What are your thoughts on his discussion and agreement with Phédre?
He’s a wily old bugger isn’t he! I actually didn’t see that coming at all. I actually liked his straight talking and appreciated it that somebody, in this highly political and backstabbing situation, could for once call a spade a spade. But then I felt annoyed with him at the end with his patron’s gift because it made Phedre feel uncomfortable and given how canny he is I think he should have been aware of that – in fact he probably was aware of it which makes me even more annoyed with him because he was using Phedre, so for all his straight talk he’s just as manipulative as the rest.
2. Melisande resurfaces – and right where I did NOT expect to find her! What about you? And what do you think of her latest ambitious designs? When she and Phédre speak again after her capture, Phédre calls her mad; Melisande hints at “playing a god’s game”. Is this ambition or is it in fact madness?
To be honest I was totally gobsmacked! She really is the archetypal evil baddie. I was flummoxed. How on earth does she manage to wrangle herself into these positions where she can manipulate everyone. Excuse me as well – but was there mention of a baby amongst that first scene?? Didn’t see that coming. You have to hand it to Carey – Melisande is a great character. I still don’t totally understand Phedre’s strange intoxication with her mind you – in fact the way her knees turn wobbly and she gets the butterflies, pulse racing, etc, well, what occurred to me when reading the last visit, was that Phedre doesn’t have those love sick feelings about anybody else except Melisande – and they really do read like love sick feelings don’t they? Or is that just me??
3. Things fall apart for Phédre and Joscelin after so much pent-up angst – but our Cassiline isn’t done with her yet, thank goodness! Phédre’s escape from La Dolorosa, and Joscelin’s attempted rescue, is some of the most nail-biting drama we’ve seen yet in this story. Do you think Joscelin will manage to find her, or will he play it smarter and go to Ysandre instead?
Well, I kind of hope he’ll go to Ysandre – not because I want him to abandon Phedre but just because I don’t see how he could possible trail her given her eventual escape! Plus, he has to kind of assume that Phedre will do all in her power to return to Ysandre in which case if he does the same then they’re bound to meet. Assuming of course that he doesn’t believe her to be dead and go off in a massive depression!! I’m guessing that he’s already totally berating himself for her capture anyway – not to mention the deaths of Remy and Fortun – that was so sad, I can’t believe it even now.
4. New character alert! What are your initial impressions of Kazan and Glaukos? How much trouble is Phédre in this time?
I like this new element. It’s going to be very interesting. Pirates. It was interesting the way the men on board were superstitious about Phedre – there always seems to be strange superstitions about women on board ships – sailors never seem to like it do they. I suppose picking a beautiful woman out of the ocean must be a little unnerving though. There certainly doesn’t seem to be any love lost between the Illyrians and Terre d’Ange – hardly surprising given that the Illyrians sought help and didn’t receive any in their hour of need. I guess you would feel bitter – and it does make you wonder. We’ve all noted that Phedre can be a little conceited sometimes haven’t we? Kazan’s comments when Phedre asked if he could speak Caerdicci were quite telling.
Part of me wonders if, now she’s out at sea, she might be able to manipulate a situation that takes her to Hyacinthe? I hope so. Even though she hasn’t really made any progress on coming up with a solution to free him yet I would like to see him being brought back into the story.
This week’s reading was very tense – I couldn’t help wondering about what Phedre thought of her captivity and whether she regretted putting herself back into the middle of the intrigue. She probably didn’t though – she seems to thrive in these situations.
The other participants are below – check out their answers too:
Allie at Tethyan Books
Lisa at Over the Effing Rainbow
Grace at Books Without Any Pictures
Nancy at FaeStruck’s Reviews & More
James at James T. Witherspoon
Emily at Emma Wolf
Susan at Dab of Darkness
#SPFBO Finalist: The Weight of a Crown by Tavish Kaeden
The Weight of a Crown by Tavish Kaeden was one of my SPFBO reads and in fact is the book I’ve put forward to the next round. I really enjoyed this, not without some reservations, but on the whole I thought it was well written and entertaining and a good start to a series that I will definitely continue to read.
I’m going to try and be brief with the plot – to be honest with you this story is set on an epic scale and so to really do it justice here would probably take too much time and eventually turn into a short story in itself.
The setting is Esmoria, which has known more than it’s fair share of conflict but is finally being ruled by one king (or at least they were until his death) – not, however, without a fair share of resentment on the parts of the other two races outlined in the story.The Bloodmarsh are the conquerors – the king-that-was had visions of a great empire living in peace, his death leaves a great void, felt even more by his people as the Prince is also missing (believed dead). In their place serves a regent known as Bokrham. The court is becoming a difficult place to rule though and trouble is brewing.
The other two races that we meet in this story are the Curahshar – a desert people with fierce warriors. They are ultimately ruled by a Grand Johalid who reigns in The Heart of Sands (a sacred city that lies deep within the desert). The Curahsar seem to be cursed by a strange plague which attacks their warriors leaving them vulnerable, weak and confused and which ultimately led to their defeat.
The Hinnjar live in the Silver Mountains. They were conquered after a protracted siege where starvation became their biggest enemy.
That’s the make up and lie of the land in a nutshell – albeit a tiny nutshell for the purpose of this review.
Now to the characters, of which there is no shortage. The four main pov characters are as follows:
We start off reading about Jeina. After being caught stealing Jeina has been sent to a mining camp (where silver is sought to help fund Prince Tobin’s exploits (Tobin is Hinnjar and has dreams of retaking his throne). Life in the camp is hard, cold and lonely. Jeina spends the majority of her day crawling through tiny tunnels looking for the telltale signs of silver – that is until she makes a scary discovery that results in the mine being closed indefinitely. Jeina is going to meet with an unexpected opportunity to escape – she will be followed however and by something quite unspeakably evil.
Next we meet Nicolas, an engraver’s apprentice whose livelihood is threatened by the strange seizures that he sometimes experiences and which now seem to be occurring with more frequency. His life is about to be changed irrevocably by a chance encounter with a mysterious stranger who wishes to buy out his bond.
Xasho is a Curahshar warrior. Accompanied by a small band of warriors and their captain Boskaheed, they’re about to try and reclaim one of their lost cities – an enterprise that frankly goes horribly wrong. Xasho manages to escape but becomes confused along the way and comes across a strange place where he finds a pair of short swords that possess strange magic and start to control the way in which Xasho fights. At this stage we have no idea whether this magic is good or evil but we share the visions that Xasho is now experiencing and that will eventually tell the story of these weapons and their previous owner.
Bokhram is the regent currently taking the reins over the Blood Marsh. Court politics and internal bickering are becoming more of a problem by the day whilst the nobles fight for position. Some of them directly claiming rights to the throne. Bokhram is barely keeping control and not knowing just how tentative his position really is is about to make something of a dubious deal himself.
Obviously there are more characters. We spend time with Tobin – a very unsavoury character who enlists the help of a blacksmith named Isic. Tobin and Isic both have their own ambitions and between them they’re about to release something dark and sinister from within the mines – not just to release either – but to try and control. We have the strange character that Nicolas’ fate has become entwined with and we have Jeina who manages to find help from a character called Fezi.
All of the four pov characters are about to set off on their own journey, a couple of them meet up during the course of this story and I suspect that they may all finally meet at some point. In the meantime we have a great combination of battles, championship jousts, court politics, intrigue, evil creatures who have the ability to control minds, escape, and, well, more.
This is a very readable story and it’s well written. I’m totally intrigued with where it will go next and will certainly continue the journey to see where book 2 takes me.
In terms of criticisms. Well, whilst I think the characters were well thought out I think I would have liked a bit more spark from them as at the moment I’m not sure how I really feel about them. For example Jeina. She’s a contradictory type of character who goes from an almost death situation to being helped by a kind stranger to then making demands – and this is something that she does tend to do quite often. I also felt that she lacked something somehow. She’s just kind of buffeted along and relies quite heavily on others. However, I also have the strange feeling that there’s more to her that we haven’t yet discovered and I wonder if, even unbeknownst to herself, she has some sort of magic that allows her to compel people to help her or bend them to her will – I guess we’ll see. I do think the characters are well done but I think maybe some sharper dialogue or banter would have brought them more to life somehow. That being said I do think the characters showed improvement in that respect as the story moved forward. There is also very much a set up feel to this story – it’s not something that I mind to be honest because there’s a lot going on here (plus no shortage of plot and action) and I’m glad that the author takes the time to properly line things up.
On the whole I really enjoyed this. I think the writing is very good. It’s a big book and yet I never had the inclination to put it down and leave it to one side in fact I think that there is nothing wasted in the writing at all – it kept me entertained throughout and compelled me to keep reading.

Tough Travelling – boldly going…..
These are the voyages of the starship Enterprise. Its five-year mission: to explore strange new worlds, to seek out new life and new civilizations, to boldly go….
![]()

This week over at the Fantasy Review Barn Nathan is taking us travelling through the tropes of fantasy. This week’s topic for discussion is MAJOR DISCOVERIES
While often the people of Fantasyland seem stuck in a time warp occasionally a major discovery can shock the land into changes. Be they new lands, new peoples or new technologies fantasyland thrives on having something to jump start the next age.
One book sprung immediately to mind when I read the topic:
The Magician by Raymond Feist – the Riftwar Series is a perfect example of new discoveries – in which a whole other world is stumbled upon with different religion, people, animals, – well, everything.
A Natural History of Dragons by Marie Brennan in which Lady Trent travels the world in search of information about dragons. She’s a quick witted, intelligent, forward thinking woman. A naturalist who is ahead of her time.
Daughter of Smoke and Bone by Laini Taylor – I like this as an example – the book starts with a series of strange hand marks appearing on doors all over the world. These doors usually lead to ‘other’ places. The major discovery for me with this book involves the teeth that Karou collects and what they are used for.
Bone Season by Samantha Shannon – in which people with the ability of clairvoyance are collected and removed from society. What we uncover here is a different race of people – hopefully that’s not a spoiler.




SPFBO – Finalist
19 August 2015
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Mark Lawrence, Self Published Fantasy Blog Off, SPFBO
For the past few months I’ve been taking part in the Self Published Fantasy Blog Off. This idea was hit upon by Mark Lawrence and brings together 10 bloggers, each undertaking to read 25-27 books submitted by self published authors with a view to putting forward one book from their pile. The 10 books that are then put forward will then be read by each blogger and scored and eventually an overall winner will be hit upon. The full details are here.
In today’s post I’m announcing my overall winner. I’m probably doing things a little back to front here because I haven’t reviewed the book yet (or a number of the other books that I actually completed). This is simply because I focused on completing the task in front of me and in particular on finding my ‘one’ book.
I can say that this has been a very difficult challenge for me for a number of reasons. I hate being critical – I really do! And yet I have a list of books and only one to take forward. This certainly acted as a motivation in making me focus. Also, I think writing a book and putting your labour of love forward for an event such as this must be really tough and I appreciate that and don’t want to discourage anybody.
What I can say about the books submitted on my list – I had some enjoyable reads here – in fact probably more than I expected (which was something of an eye opener and a revelation) Maybe I wasn’t as open minded about self published books as I thought and in that respect I think this challenge has been a learning curve.
In terms of the reading I didn’t complete all the books and this wasn’t necessarily because I didn’t enjoy them but more because I already knew that they would not be the book I put forward for one reason or another. In total I completed 10 books – I’ve already written a short review for a couple of those plus a full review for one of the others. The others I intend to write reviews for over the next few days starting with my finalist. I think I gave all the books submitted a very fair chance but at the end of the day the book I chose just stood out for me as up until that point I was undecided about which book I had enjoyed the most.
I would like to thank all the authors who submitted books for this challenge and hope that none of you are discouraged at all, at the end of the day I had to be fairly hard in terms of elimination. Put simply, some of the books were not my style, or maybe felt aimed at a younger target audience and some I had issues with the writing style that didn’t particularly work for me.
My finalist for this round:
The Weight of a Crown by Tavish Kaeden – review to follow.
The other books that I read fully but have not yet reviewed:
- Iduna by Maya Michaels
- The Duchess of the Shallows by Neil McGarry & Daniel Ravipinto
- Forging Divinity by Andrew Rowe
- In the Dark by Melody Taylor
- Thief of Hope by Cindy Young-Turner
- Blade of the Broken by Jake Scholl
The following three books I’ve already either reviewed or given a short write up of.
- Naming the Bane by Kal S Davian
- Klondaeg the Monster Hunter by Steve Thomas
- His Own Good Sword by Amanda McCrina review here





