Spells for Forgetting by Adrienne Young
My Five Word TL:DR Review : Murder Mystery with ancestral magic
Well, yesterday I was reviewing a cosy horror story(Cackle) that was about finding oneself and discovering magic along the way. Today I’m reviewing a book that takes place on a small island where the inherited magic is so deeply rooted than no one questions the reality of it, in fact it’s as natural and everyday to the inhabitants as breathing, although some of them are trying to move forward and live without it (the magic,not the breathing). What Spells for Forgetting has is an abundance of atmosphere and a very easy to imagine setting.
As the story begins we meet August as he returns to Saiorse Island to bury the ashes of his late mother in accordance with her last wishes. This isn’t a happy return. August and his mother left the island 14, or perhaps more, years ago under something of a stormcloud. A young girl called Lily had died on the same night that the Island suffered a terrible fire. August was the main suspect for a time but lack of substantial evidence prevented any further action.
Emery was Lily’s best friend. She was also August’s girlfriend and the two shared an intense relationship, plotting to leave the island together as soon as they could.
So, there’s the mystery of Lily’s death and trying to uncover what actually took place on the ill fated night of the fire. You could be forgiven for imagining that on such a small island it’s impossible to keep a secret but on Saiorse there are plenty of skeletons tucked away in closets. Resentments, grudges, hidden jealousies, desires and so forth. Most of the islanders are angry that August has returned believing his presence will stir up bad feelings, in fact it does appear that the island itself is rebelling and although August has no intention of sticking around longer than necessary some people are afraid that his return will stir up things from the past that should remain hidden. August also needs to see Emery and make his peace with the way things were left.
Now, I do have slightly mixed feelings for this one. On the one hand I think the writing is superb. I love the way that we jump back and forth to explore events that took place on the run up to the fateful night of the fire. I think the author does an excellent job of writing the relationship between August and Emery. On top of that the island is such an unusual place. Years of history relating to witchcraft bring in flocks of tourists, as does the orchard and it’s need for fruit pickers and, well, a murder on the Island also proves to be a curiosity for some. The magic is interesting. Emery’s family still keep hold of the grimoire that has been passed down through the generations and still uses recipes from within to make candles and soap. There’s plenty of tension and so much history between the inhabitants of Saiorse that it’s easy to see, and believe, how deeply the resentments lie.
In terms of the areas that gave me mixed feelings. The story felt a little YA to me which could be because for part of the story we flit back to August and Emery’s teenage years. Although, in actual fact, I think their early relationship is really well portrayed even if it was perhaps a little overdone and drawn out in the middle section. That being said their teenage selves were easier to get along with than the more adult versions which were a little juvenile and ill at ease (I mean I do understand that they had unspoken issues but I kind of wished they’d just decided to get on with it and have that discussion.) Which does lead me to another issue, the lack of communication that seems to exist here simply to prolong the mystery. It felt too protracted to me. I also really would have liked to have seen more use of magic, even if it had been in a way that was vague and I felt my curiosity about the actual island itself and its history wasn’t really touched upon at all.
I hope that doesn’t come across as overly critical. I enjoyed reading this. I like the author’s style and the setting is really good. The atmosphere and tension are so intense you can positively taste them and the island is like an additional character in itself.
If you fancy cosying up to a dark murder mystery story based on a strange island where tensions run deep then give this a shot.
I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.
My rating 3.5 of 5 stars
Cackle by Rachel Harrison
My Five Word TL:DR Review: Is Cosy Horror Even Possible?
Well, when I picked this up I had few expectations. I didn’t really read the blurb and I hadn’t realised that the book was shelved in the Horror section. Given the title I was expecting a healthy dose of witchery and with Halloween looming I thought this would be the perfect read for an autumn evening. In that respect, if cosy horror is a ‘thing’ then you’ll love this. It’s not blood soaked and scary. Sure, there are a couple of scenes that feel menacing but I don’t think you’ll need to hide behind a cushion at any point. I had strange Witches of Eastwick meets Stepford Wives vibes – although I’m not saying this story resembles either of those per se. More I just got a feel in those directions occasionally. Basically, this is more a book about finding yourself and discovering what you’re capable of.
The main character, Annie, has recently split up from her boyfriend. This was a long term relationship that Annie seemed to think was the ‘real deal’. Unfortunately, her ex, Sam, had other ideas. In an attempt to start afresh Annie leaves Manhattan to live in a small village when she’s offered a teaching position. When she arrives she can’t believe how beautiful and picturesque the place is. Everyone is kind and thoughtful and one resident in particular catches her attention. Sophie is beautiful and sophisticated, graceful, generous and pretty soon an almost constant companion of Annie’s. Oddly enough the rest of the residents seem strangely wary of Sophie or desperate to stay on her good side. Soon Annie starts to suspect that people are afraid of her new friend although she can’t understand why.
Sophie lives in a beautiful mansion deep within the forest. She’s capable and pretty soon it becomes evident that there’s more to her than originally meets the eye. I won’t elaborate on that here.
So, the characters. Well, Annie is a strange character to really like at first, in some ways she comes across as a little lacking in backbone. Her main focus in life is Sam and she practically fantasises about getting back together with him. I do sympathise with her over the loss of a relationship that she thought was special but at the same time I wanted her to move on. And, I guess Sophie wanted the same thing. Sophie is a fascinating character and I confess that sometimes I was puzzled why she so quickly took Annie under her wing. But, I think, in a town where people are mostly suspicious of her, Sophie is also keen for friendship and at the same time sets herself up as a sort of mentor, trying to encourage Annie to stand up for herself. Eventually, the two form a firm friendship and with guidance Annie slowly starts to realise that she doesn’t need a man in her life to be complete – or is she just kidding herself, us and Sophie?
The small town of Rowan is where my Stepford vibes came into play. The village is positively idyllic. Everywhere is beautiful and to be honest Rowan seems to glow with prosperity and success and yet the locals all seem to know their place when it comes down to their own local ‘wise woman’. It feels like there’s an almost collective sense of fear or is it hysteria and people harking back to older times when a woman living alone was clearly a threat of some kind and surely meddling in the dark arts.
There is a creeping sort of menace. You’re never really sure what route this strange new relationship will take. Will it become obsessive or dangerous. Without doubt Sophie can sometimes come across a little unnerving, like you wouldn’t really want to upset her even if you’re not sure why that is. That being said Annie does begin to undergo a transformation of sorts, she eventually realises that she is capable of standing up for herself even where Sophie is concerned.
I mentioned above that this is cosy and I stand by that. There’s a lovely warm feel to the story overall. Even when some darker elements crop up. The writing is really good, and although I might have had the odd issue here and there they don’t really merit a mention and I found myself quite absorbed, bewitched even. A very easy to read story that I raced to complete mostly because I was never keen to put it down and always keen to pick it back up. A book about self realisation, coming to terms with who you are, self love and worth that includes magical elements and curses. A great book to curl up with at this time of the year.
I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.
My rating 4 of 5 stars
Booking Ahead/Weekly Wrap Up
16 October 2022
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Booking Ahead, Caffeinated Reviewer, Weekly wrap up
I’m trying to get back into the habit of doing a round-up of the week just completed and also take a look at my plans for the forthcoming week. I rather got out of the habit of doing this but I would like to reinstate this type of post as I feel it keeps me on track. So, I’m linking up to The Sunday Post over at Kimberly’s Caffeinated Reviewer. Without further ado:
Books read this week:
This week I’ve not been quite as productive in terms of reading. I’ve completed one of the Critiquing Chemist’s SPFBO Semi Finalists which means I have just one more book to read for Phase 1 of the competition. I’ve also made a good start on the latest CK McDonnell – Love Will Tear Us Apart and it’s quite possible that I’ll complete that later this evening. I’m absolutely loving this series and couldn’t wait to tuck in. I’ve made good progress on blog hopping and getting up to date with posting and even pulled together a book tag this weekend.
Next Week’s Reads:
I still have a few to choose from : One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig, The Ghost Woods by CJ Cooke, The Hollows by Daniel Church and I’m also going to be picking up my last SPFBO Semi Finalist. Although, of course, I’m not expecting to complete all these.
Reviews Posted since my last Sunday Post:
- Babel by RF Kuang
- A Dowry of Blood by ST Gibson
Outstanding Reviews
- A Gamble of Gods by Mitriel Faywood
- Cackle by Rachel Harrison
- Spells for Forgetting by Adrienne Young
- Unraveller by Frances Hardinge
- 1 x SPFBO SF
- Love Will Tear Us Apart by CK McDonnell
Paws for Thought > Book Tag
15 October 2022
Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: Book Tags, Books and dogs, Paws for Thought
Today I thought i’d have a go at something light and fun. A book tag that I came up with that combines my love of dogs and my love of books. If you fancy taking part please tag me so I can see what books you come up with. Let’s go:
<>
I’m going to start and conclude with the puppy and old faithful:
The puppy, illegally cute, will eventually grow into it’s paws and ears, will chew your shoes, possibly your clothes and the table legs and demand all your attention before curling up to sleep exhausted.
** The most recent book that you read and loved **
Well, I’ve been on something of a reading high just recently (long may this continue) but, the actual last book that I gave five stars to was A Dowry of Blood by ST Gibson. Dark romance, broodingly gothic and a tale of obsession and control:
<>
The Retriever, intelligent, hard working hunters with a love of life believed to have originated in Scotland.
** A book that was carefully planned, clearly well researched and was intelligent and thought provoking **
This is another very recent read that I’m really happy to be able to cast the light on here. Babel: Or the Necessity of Violence: An Arcane History of the Oxford Translators’ Revolution by RF Kuang. An ode to words:
<>
Poodle, the aristocrat of the canine world. A proud and elegant athlete.
** A book with a beautiful cover **
Ahh, so many possibilities… I had to cheat and choose more than one. (This was probably the most difficult prompt for me because I suffer from cover love so could have gone totally giddy and included MANY, MANY MANY, more covers, as it is I exercised remarkable constraint:
<>
The German Shepherd, an all purpose working dog, loyal and courageous.
** A book that gave you a strong case of the heebie jeebies. You needed all your courage to pick this one up **
Old Country by Matt Query and Harrison Query – there’s some very creepy scenes in this one so beware.
<>
Lakeland terrier, a ‘big dog in a small package’
** A book with great characters **
The Empire’s Ruin by Brian Staveley – I love this book and can’t wait to read the next in series. I love Gwenna so much.
<>
Rottweiler, descendent of the Roman mastiffs, playful and protective.
** A book based on ancient history **
I simply have to give a shout out to The Wolf Den and the House With the Golden Door by Elodie Harper because they’re just so good. This is a series that takes us to Pompeii and provides us with a glimpse into the lives of slaves and prostitutes. I am giddy with anticipation for what comes next.
<>
Greyhound, gentle and independent, a dog that embodies the saying ‘form follows function’. Bred for speed.
** A book that was fast paced and kept you racing to the end **
Black Tide by KC Jones. This was such a great book to read. The writing was snappy and the tension was cranked up and it had a healthy dose of totally ‘out there’ cosmic horror. This is a book that I would love to see adapted – it could be totally wicked, tense and scary:
<>
Dachshund, these dogs are not necessarily built for speed but they are relentlessly persistent. Quite often known as ‘the sausage dog’.
** A book that made you hungry – this is a book that you need to stock up on treats before you crack it open**
This is perhaps an unusual choice but I’m going to say Daisy Darker by Alice Feeney. It has some of the most unusual food served at a party that I’ve ever heard of. I’m not sure whether I’d love the food or not but I’m certainly intrigued. And, this is a great read. Feeney starts out with a captivating hook, she then lets us run on the line enjoying the freedom to explore the remote setting and the histrionics of the Darker family before reeling us in to a climatic and dramatic grand finale. An absolute must read imo.
<>
The Mixed breed or “Heinz 57” as its sometimes affectionately known, this is a dog of indeterminate breed. Generally speaking such dogs are believed to live longer and suffer less hereditary diseases and will you just look at that face. I have a serious case of ‘cute aggression’ coming on..
** This is a book with a bit of everything going on. Could be lots of different elements/POVs or a collection of stories **
This is a book that I recently read and will be reviewing soon. It’s one of those books that succeeds in blending elements such as science fiction, fantasy, romance and adventure. Watch this space for my thoughts very soon. A Gamble Of Gods (The Order Of The Dragon, #1) by Mitriel Faywood.
<>
The French Bulldog, enjoying great popularity at the moment. Playful and adorable and loved by City dwellers who have less space.
** A book that is irresistibly cute **
I’m using this tag as much as possible to highlight my most uptodate reads and also included in that is the books I’ve been reading for the Self Published Fantasy Blog Off Competition (for more info check out Mark Lawrence’s post here). One of my Semi Finalists this year is Miss Percy’s Pocket Guide to the Care and Feeding of British Dragons by Quenby Olson. This book is positively delicious – it also fits into the prompt above about needing treats on hand when you’re reading – because cake is mentioned an almost indecent number of times. This book is so good. When I was reading I felt transported back to an almost Austen-ish world with bonnets and etiquette. And just look at the cute dragon. Also the fantasy elements are included in such a clever way that even if you’re not usually a fantasy reader I think you’d be hard pressed not to be very pleasantly surprised.
<>
The Portuguese Podengo, alert and independent. A breed of hunting dog believed to have descended from dogs brought to Portugal by Phoenician merchants.
** A book that is a standalone **
Dyer Street Punk Witches (Ordshaw #7) by Phil Williams.So you’re probably scratching your head and wondering why I’ve included this book under my standalone prompt? Well, although this is set in the Ordshaw world I can confidently say that you can read this book as a standalone. I only mention this because I quite often feel daunted when I see that I’m already so far behind in a very established series and to be honest it puts me off picking it up – which sounds crazy but it simply feels like such a huge commitment to catch up. This was actually my favourite of the Ordshaw stories with new characters and an intriguing storyline. Plus a fantastic kickass central pov and a banging cover. Give it a shot, you might (more than definitely will) fancy returning to some of the earlier books as a result.
<>
The Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, the nobility of Dogdom with a silky coat, mild temper and graceful athleticism.
** A book with Kings and Queens or something historic **
So, back to my SPFBO endeavours. For this prompt I’m using my other Semi Finalist. The Blood of Crows by Alex C Pierce. I had such a lot of fun with this one and the story is intriguing and compelling. Firstly, I’m a sucker for heists, secondly I love characters that manage to insert a little humour even though they’re in the middle of dire circumstances, thirdly I loved the magic and the way it feeds into the plot so easily and fourthly, there is more yet to come and it promises something I didn’t expect. I’m thinking of the ending and obviously I can’t elaborate. You’ll simply have to read the book. I’m watching you AC Pierce!
<>
Finally. Old faithful. This is the dog that has been your steadfast companion over the years. Lies with it’s head on your foot so that it knows when you move, scents you out no matter where you are and waits patiently. Is the first to greet you in the morning and the last at night and is always happy to see you.
** A book that you’ve read many times, you could pick this book up and just let the pages fall open to where they may and dive right in **
I have a number of books that I’ve read a few times but I think the one I used to pick up most frequently was Rebecca by Daphne DuMaurier. Having said that I realise I haven’t picked this up in quite some time so perhaps a reread is in order. I love this author’s work and along with Rebecca have no hesitation in recommending My Cousin Rachel and Jamaica Inn. There are many more but those two always stood out for me.
If you enjoyed these prompts please feel free to take part. I’m not tagging anyone but hope you’ll join in and would love to see your books. Sorry if you don’t see your favourite pooch here – there are so many breeds and so I had to narrow it down somehow.
Also, for the cat lovers out there (of which I am also one), I have a lovely idea for a cat tag which I’m going to pull together very soon.
Friday Face Off : Witches/Warlocks
Here we are again with the Friday Face Off meme created by Books by Proxy . This is a great opportunity to feature some of your favourite book covers. The rules are fairly simple each week, following a predetermined theme (list below) choose a book (this doesn’t have to be a book that you’ve read), compare a couple of the different covers available for that particular book and choose your favourite. Future’s themes are listed below – if you have a cover in mind that you’re really wanting to share then feel free to leave a comment about a future suggested theme. I’ve also listed events that take place during the year, that I’m aware of, so you can link up your covers – if you’re aware of any events that you think I should include then give me a shout.
I’ve added themes in below. For information, I’m trying out some new ideas so along with coming up with particular items for book covers I thought we could also look for certain elements contained within the book or that play a large part in the story – this really broadens things out because I have plenty of more ideas with this – I’ve gone for a few of the Tough Travel Themes (so a book with that theme – just choose any book – the theme isn’t necessarily on the cover, then compare covers), also, I’ve thrown in some genres and some colours. Hopefully this will open things out a little and give us some more freedom to come up with new books.
This week’s theme:
Witches/Warlocks
Well, we are definitely in the right season for this weeks theme and I’m so happy to have a book this week that is a very recent read. So recent, in fact, that my review is not yet posted (although it will be soon, and, spoiler alert – it was really good). So, Cackle by Rachel Harrison. Here are the two covers:
My favourite:
Do you have a favourite. Have you read this book yet – what did you think?
If you’re taking part in this week’s theme feel free to leave your link in the comments below.
If you know of an event that’s coming up let me know and I’ll try and include covers that work for the event itself so that you can link up to the Friday Face Off and, as always, if you wish to submit an idea then leave me a comment – or if you’d like to host a week then simply let me know. Also, I would just mention that it’s very possible that some of these might be repeats from previous FFOs although I have tried to invent more ‘open ended’ prompt that can be interpreted differently and also prompts that relate to emotions. Finally, don’t struggle with any of these, this is meant to be a fun way of highlighting books. If you can’t come up with a book you think fits for a particular week use a freebie – perhaps a recent read for example:
Next Week’s Theme : Tough Travel Tropes – Good vs evil
2022
