Immortal Beloved by Cate Tiernan
13 November 2011
Filed under Book Reviews, Challenges for 2011
Tags: Cate Tiernan, Immortal Beloved
Just finished reading Immortal Beloved by Cate Tiernan and am surprised to say that I ended up liking this book much more than I expected to. I don’t really know why but I was reluctant to read this – I thought maybe it would be much of a muchness but it is actually quite a captivating story that unfolds gently.
This is the story of Nastasya, one of the immortals, she is over 450 years old, she’s lived through wars and plagues, raids and famines but her life has become one long party. Nastasya has lost her focus, she doesn’t really care about anything or anyone, she spends her time living the jet set lifestyle flitting from one cosmopolitan city to the next and partying to excess with a small selected band of immortal friends. They’re not particularly ‘nice’. They don’t mind whose feelings they stamp all over or who they use in order to find a little entertainment but all this wild behaviour is about to come to an abrupt halt for Nat after one evening ends with a particularly nasty incident that leaves too bitter a taste and leaves her feeling vulnerable and scared. So, Nat, runs aways and with the help of one of her many assumed identifies disappears to a small retreat out in Massachusettes – run by another immortal – River. River met Nat almost a century earlier and extended an invitation to her and finally Nat has taken up the offer.
River’s place is a bit like a half way house or rehab almost for immortals. The inhabitants spend their time undertaking regular mundane everyday duties and work that helps them to become more grounded and they also spend time honing their magical skills using circles, scrying and crystals. All the immortals have certain magical abilities but they can choose to draw energies from living things – and in the process cause damage or by trying to harness their magic in a more natural way without harming other living beings. So basically dark and light magic. And, this makes up one of the main premises for the story – whether they choose to take the dark side or not – a choice that is constantly open to them and which they have to fight against.
The two main characters are Nat and Reyn, and they share something in their past that they’ve put from their memories and built walls around. At first it would be easy to say that neither of these characters is particularly easy to get on with but as they spend more time in each other’s company, and also as Nat spends more time at the retreat and starts to deconstruct her defences, they start to grow on you and each other. I really warmed to Nat – she starts to really care for the first time in many years about other people and the lives they lead and she actually wants to help them and make a difference. Also, through flashbacks and visions you start to pick up the threads of the life that she has led. And, it hasn’t been easy, being immortal is no defence against all sorts of atrocities – it simply means that you;re around long enough to live through most of them and therefore most of the immortals have pain and suffering as part of their histories. They’ve also had a long time in which to make mistakes and live to regret them!
In terms of criticisms – nothing really major – I found it a bit of a stretch to believe some of Nat’s behaviour, which at times comes across as incredibly juvenile, because, whilst she may look like a teenager she has been around for a good few hundred years and it’s difficult to believe that she wouldn’t be more mature in her actions. Also, the whole ‘immortals’ issue is not really touched upon – so there is no discovery of why or how, etc, to satisfy the curiosity on that front.
Also, if you come to this novel expecting it to be bursting at the seams with action then you may be disappointed. The story builds very slowly, the characters are quite well drawn and we begin to piece together Nat’s history bit by bit until she finally puts together all the pieces of her own puzzle. It’s a bit like a coming of age almost – except with a much longer history to work through.
And, on top of this we have the romance building between Nat and Reyn – and the fact that in spite of the terrible history they share – they are utterly drawn to each other.
On the whole I really enjoyed it and I’m looking forward to the next in the series (which hopefully won’t be too long a wait now). This first in the series has set up perfectly the next one for a bit of a showdown and hopefully for some more magic and romance.
Rating –
A
Lord of the Rings read along – Return of the King
12 November 2011
Filed under Book Reviews, Challenges for 2011
Tags: J RR Tolkien, Lord of the Rings, Return of the King
And so we move on to Book No.3, The Return of the King, where we read through to the end of The Battle of the Pelennor Fields. We’re almost at the end of the journey now. Questions this week were provided by Clint at Geeky Dad as follows:
- With the company that went with Aragorn through the Paths of Death. Would you have volunteered knowing it may be curse and ghosts haunting the paths? I think if I had the opportunity I would have preferred to go with Aragorn. He always seems to feel so ‘right’ with his choices that he inspires confidence plus he seems to have been growing in confidence himself, at the beginning he almost shied away from his own legacy but as the books progresses he seems to be taking ownership. Also to be honest, it’s not really like there’s any really easy choices – death by orc (or other beast/person/thing) or death by ghost – think I’ll take death by ghost – it doesn’t feel as ‘real’ somehow. I’m not saying that I wouldn’t be frightened by ghosts but it seems less tangible somehow so I’ll take my chances. (Anyway, who am I trying to kid – obviously I would go with Aragorn – it’s Aragorn! Doh
- What were your thoughts of Merry and Pippin in the preparation to the Battle of Gondor. It seemed that each ruler just thought that each hobbit could not be a contribution to the battle. I felt sorry for both Merry and Pippin to be honest. They both seemed to suffer the loss of each other when they were split up – and frankly the split almost seemed on a bit of a whim now when you reread the book . It felt very much like both had become an encumberance – they were treated a bit like a child who you humour with your patience when you have the time but then want to shoo them away to one side when things become more serious. But, at the end of the day, and though they might be small in stature, they are both adults – and they both wanted to contribute. I really liked that they eventually both proved their worth in more ways than one. Without Pippin looking in the palantir the battle would probably not have been as accelerated as it was – which was a good thing in a way because it meant the battle wasn’t as well planned as it would otherwise have been and without Merry’s intervention on the battlefield things could have gone horribly wrong. I like the way that Tolkien manages to give them, and the Lady Eowyn, a valuable contribution.
- Did you think that the preparations to the Battle sparked your interest and all or did you find that the flow was bogged down a bit? I suppose I did find the preparations a little more ‘sluggish’ than the rest of the book – which is to be expected in this type of novel, you have these chapters that totally raise you up and throw you into battle and then you have the lulls in between. But, I am a stickler for detail and if it wasn’t in the book I would probably find it very irritating. I did find it really interesting to read about the Wild Men who assisted the Rohirrim in finding a forgotten road to get more quickly to Gondor – Ghan-buri-Ghan was a funny character – didn’t like the orcs, and probably had no real love for men either but chose the lesser of the two evils in his eyes and struck a bargain so that his people could retreat to the quiet of the forest again.
- I thought that it was great that both Eowyn and Merry made it to the Battlefield. Yet against orders of the King and made a huge contributions. What did you think both of them doing this and would you have done this if it was you? I loved Eowyn and Merry’s contribution – and in fact it proved pivotal – things could have been so very different (and bad) without their rebelliousness! Not sure if I would have been so brave – in fact I know I wouldn’t. Although I suppose you’re carried away on the moment really and probably not thinking you’re brave at all.
- What do you think of Denethor’s rash decision to send Faramir to hold Western Osgiliath against the hosts of the Enemy that outnumbered their own greatly? Denethor is one of the few people that I have very little sympathy with in the book. I really don’t like him and it makes me feel bad, even though he is a work of fiction, to say that, but I think he is so mean! Imagine saying to one of your children that you would prefer their death to their brother’s – OMG! I know he was grieving for Boromir but frankly he always had a preference by the sound of it. I thought he was wrong to send out Faramir to hold Western Osgiliath because frankly it was an impossible task and a tremendous loss of life.
Other discussion posts:
Blue Fairy’s Bookshelf
Geeky Daddy
Storm Front by Jim Butcher
9 November 2011
Filed under Book Reviews, Challenges for 2011
Tags: Jim Butcher, Storm Front, The Dresden Files
Just finished reading Storm Front by Jim Butcher. Storm Front is the first one in the Dresden Files series of books and brings to us a new type of PI. Harry Dresden is a private investigator with a difference – he’s a wizard! This is a paranormal detective book with wizards, demons, black magic, fey, vampires and talking skulls – and I loved it!
Okay, I admit this probably isn’t a work of art, it isn’t deep and meaningful and it’s cliched but it’s fast paced, full of tension, had a fairly good story running through and frankly pretty much grabbed me from the first page and kept me wanting to read – which is a definite plus.
In this first book we learn a little bit about Harry but I suspect that this will be built upon in future novels. I really liked Harry – he’s one of the good guys after all. He’s poor and not exactly flooded with work but he treats people decently, he doesn’t try to con them, he feels bad when he has to act tough and he’s not ashamed to admit to his weaknesses – creepy crawlies give him the shivers, he feels sick at the sight of a crime scene – and, my favourite, he has a love of books and an overloaded book shelf in need of some attention! But, he does have a shadow looming over him – something in his past that has put him out of favour with the all powerful ‘White Council’ – the wizarding police if you will.
In this episode Harry’s dry period comes to an abrupt end when he is asked to look into a ‘missing persons’ mystery and then he’s called in by the police to look at a particularly nasty double murder where black magic is suspected. Things quickly spiral out of control and Harry seems to go from one life threatening event to the next, he’s definitely caught the wrong sort of attention and he’s in a race against time to find the killer and save his own life in the process.
I enjoyed the Chicago setting with the dark and stormy settings and I thought there was enough detail to set the scene without it being overly done – which I don’t think would have sat well with this story and would have slowed it down in an unhelpful way. I also enjoyed the introduction to a number of the supporting characters – Murphy, hard nosed cop (but her bark is worse than her bite), Bianca, the vampire, who will definitely be reappearing in future novels and is bearing a grudge – her bit of the story was quite riveting! And, of course, we have the obligatory reporter – Susan. There are of course plenty of others who will doubtless be in future novels – the bar McAnallys, and the obvious favourites – the pizza eating faerie – Toot Toot, and Harry’s helpful assistant Bob – who lives in a skull!
On the whole, a very enjoyable and entertaining read and I will definitely continue with the series.
Rating -A
The Lady of the Rivers by Philippa Gregory
6 November 2011
Filed under Book Reviews, Challenges for 2011
Tags: Philippa Gregory, The Lady of the Rivers, War of the Roses
Just finished reading Lady of the Rivers by Philippa Gregory and will say that I found this a very enjoyable and informative read. I haven’t read the first two in the ‘Cousins’ War’ series but I may pick them up and apparently reading this book first may not be a bad idea as the focus of the novel is Jacquetta Rivers, daughter to the White Queen (first book of the series). I do like PG’s series – I read all of her Tudor Court novels and found them to be an intriguing set of novels, a well balanced blend of fact and fiction with elements of romance, intrigue, mystery and magic.
This Lady of the Rivers tells the story of Jacquetta and commences at the Castle of Beaurevoir where Joan of Arc is being held captive prior to her trial and execution. Following this, having caught the eye of the Duke of Bedford, Jacquetta is betrothed and wed and finds herself embroiled in the strange world of alchemy, scrying and foretelling for the Duke and ever watched by his squire Richard Woodville. After only a couple of year’s of marriage the Duke dies leaving Jacquetta a very wealthy and powerful woman. Fate intervenes and Jacquetta, who has fallen in love with the young squire, marries in secret and without the consent of King Henry VI – at first it seems that the two will live a quiet life in the countryside until both are drawn into the life at Court when Jacquetta is asked to accompany the King’s new bride Margaret of Anjou to England. I won’t elaborate too much more on the story – although I don’t think I’ll be giving away any spoilers here as this is all based on historical fact after all.
In this story PG takes a little known figure and manages to weave around her an intriguing story of love and magic. Jacquetta’s family is linked since way back when with the Water Goddess Melusina and this is where all the water elements of the story come into play. As such Jacquetta, as many other women in her family before and after, are gifted with the ‘sight’, being able to foretell the future. Her aunt, Lady Jehanne, introduces Jacquetta from an early age to divination using charms and tarot cards and her first husband, The Duke of Bedford, also having an interest, continues her education encouraging her in the arts of herbs and furthering her access to reading material that will broaden her knowledge of alchemy. Of course, in later years, all such knowledge is forbidden and anybody practising such arts will be accused of witchcraft so Jacquetta hides her knowledge.
In terms of the characters in the novel – I really liked Jacquetta and her husband Richard. They are both portrayed as honourable, courageous and well liked. They had an amazing relationship which resulted in so many children that I think that ‘the old woman who lived in a shoe’ rhyme may have been based on her – I think 14 in total! They lived in turbulent times to say the least. War was never far away and usually only ceased for particularly bad spells of weather and so many of the characters you are briefly introduced to are quickly, quite literally, history. The other main character, of course, is Margaret, the new queen, who soon becomes a force to be reckoned with. To be honest I didn’t really like either Margaret or her husband Henry. Margaret quickly changes from being a spoilt young princess to a ruthless woman who it appears will stop at nothing to secure the throne for her son Edward. She is vindictive to say the least and has no regard for the life of the people surrounding her – she quickly becomes greatly disliked by the people of England who name her ‘a she wolf’. Her husband Henry is weak and ineffective. He suffers from ill health and seems to lose possession of his mind and is incapable of ruling – where Margaret is spiteful and mean Henry is almost like a child who wants everyone to simply get along – something that history has shown is never easy to do, particularly when a throne is at stake.
As usual, PG, has managed to introduce us to two very strong female leads – at a time in history when women had very little power. I really loved all the mystical elements, the family lore and the references to sightseeing and scrying etc. The reason why I enjoyed this is because I think it played a part in that period of history – I don’t think that the women involved were doing anything ‘witchy’ in particularly, they just suffered from a good pinch of superstition, had a bit of knowledge about the benefits of herbs and relied upon their own intuition. Nothing really supernatural there after all – plenty of people read horoscopes, won’t walk under ladders, salute magpies and take natural remedies in this day and age!
In terms of criticisms – there is a lot of fighting in this book – really, I’m not exaggerating. We reach a point where Jacquetta is tired of it all – and frankly I couldn’t have agreed more with her (but, again, this is history). I really don’t envy people living in that era, particularly the poor people who’s homes were constantly raided by either one invading army or another. And, the only other criticism, and I suppose this is a bad reflection on me, is coming to terms with all the Richard/Henry/Edmund/Edward’s etc.
Criticisms aside, I really enjoyed reading this book. I was intrigued with the War of the Roses and the part that Jacquetta and Richard played in it all and I think that PG has managed to provide us with another great historical read from a period that is less written about.
Rating -A
The Act of Roger Murgatroyd by Gilbert Adair
3 November 2011
Filed under Book Reviews, Challenges for 2011
Tags: Crime spoof, Evadne Mount, Gilbert Adair, The Act of Roger Murgatroyd
Just finished reading The Act of Roger Murgatroyd – I know! What a book name!! Anyway, this is not the type of book that I would usually pick up – in fact it was picked by my book club. That being said I found it a lighthearted, amusing little romp of a detective novel that takes a bit of a dig at your average crime novel – or maybe not a dig, it’s a sort of spoof but not quite as much as a spoof – oh, the joys of being articulate!
So the book starts on Boxing Day, the body of Raymond Gentry has been discovered dead in the attic, shot through the heart – apparently in a locked room, with the murder weapon nowhere to be found. The Manor house that sets the scene rests on the edge of Dartmoor and belongs to the Ffolkes. A winter story, one of the worst on record for year, rages, the telephone lines are down, the roads are closed and we have a number of suspects – the guests, the Vicar and his wife, the Doctor and his wife, Evadne Mount – famous crime writer, Cora Rutherfod- ageing actress and the Ffolkes daughter and her two friends (not to mention a cast of charactes such as maids, butler, gardener, cook, etc). Really this cast is just so cliched it’s amusing just in itself. We are then joined by a retired Scotland Yard Chief Super who lives in close proximity to the Manor and is called on to try and assist in the absence of any official authorities. The story then develops with all the guests becoming potential suspects with their own reasons for wanting Gentry dead. All of them have their own secrets and all of these will be revealed. And, added to that of course is the fact that one of them is a murderer – and apparently a murdered who is not yet content!
This book just reminds me of so many things. I couldn’t help reading all the Evadne bits in the voice of Angela Lansbury from Murder She Wrote (I strongly deny ever watching this programme however, well maybe a couple!). Then on top of this there were echoes of upstairs/downstairs, The Pink Panther and bits and bobs from many crime writers – all mixed in with a Cluedo like setting.
Okay, what I will say, if you’re looking for a classic novel – then this isn’t for you. Also, if you’re expecting a serious crime novel – this also isn’t for you. If you want some light entertainment and a quick read and you don’t mind taking a lighthearted look at crime novels in general then you may enjoy this. The story is certainly good enough, there are plenty of red herrings scattered about and I really couldn’t help wondering how the ‘locked room’ crime had been committed. Plus, the finale, where Evade Mount sits everyone in the library to reveal how the murder happened and who the murderer is was just so cheesy, but good!
In terms of criticisms – I found the relaying of the original stories a little drawn out – and as this was a crime book – would have liked a bit more serious interrogation. It felt very much like Insp Trubshawe spent all his time checking out the guests’ former histories and establishing their motives for commiting a crime but he didn’t do much ‘detecting’. I think we could have used a bit of good old fashioned ‘Sherlock Holmes’ style detective work! Also, I wasn’t convinced by the actual murderer – in fact I was a bit disappointed with that bit – and, I sort of guessed who it was fairly early on – probably just a lucky guess but I had my mind made up – just could have done without the long winded motive. Alos, I can think of at least two things which I think are inconsistencies – but obviously I can’t point them out because they would contain spoilers.
Now, criticisms aside, this was funny and entertaining, lightheared and easy to read.
Rating C+
Spoiler below:
The Butler was the murderer. It was a very long and convoluted reason which I won’t go into because it will take forever.








