The Cleaner of Chartres by Sally Vickers

Just finished reading the Cleaner of Chartres by Salley Vickers.  This is a gentle sort of read although it does contain elements of darkness when you least expect them.

The story is about a young woman called Agnes Morel.  Agnes is something of a mystery.  Nobody in Chartres really knows where she came from or very much about her past.  She turned up in Chartres some twenty years ago and has gradually made a life for herself, with a few friends, a small apartment and a quiet life.  However, Agnes is soon going to have to confront the memories from her past as old acquaintances show up and the life she has built on such shaky foundations begins to unravel.

The story is told in two alternating time frames showing us Agnes as a young girl (abandoned at birth and living with nuns at a convent in Evreux), and as the woman she is now.  I quite enjoyed this way of telling the story – I suppose the author could have chosen a more linear fashion of storytelling but I think in telling the story this way it has a more dramatic impact particularly in the way that it highlights how Agnes has changed during the two periods.  There were definitely moments where it was almost difficult to reconcile the two or to quite figure out how Agnes ever got to her current stage.

I wouldn’t say Agnes has had an easy life and you can’t help feeling sorry for her as you read on.  I think what makes it a little more sad is the way that Agnes just seems to quietly accept all that fate throws at her as though she has little expectation out of life.  That being said she has managed to find a measure of happiness and seems to have acquired more friends than she realises.

The writing style is quite lyrical and somehow manages to feel almost like a fairy story or more to the point has a feel of ‘otherness’ to it a little in the way that Joanne Harris brings that element to her story Chocolat.

It’s a very easy book to read with almost a holiday or beach feel however it had a slightly disappointing edge to it that I can’t quite pin down.  I think it could be a general ambivalence towards Agnes who, even though she seems to touch the lives of those around her, she never seems to have any real sense of happiness or well being.  There’s also the fact that some of the other characters are almost like cartoon cut out baddies.  Proper good old fashioned villains that are a little too stereotype.  Other than being a bit bitter I was never totally convinced by Madame Beck and the character assassination she undertakes on Agnes.  Also the whole plot with the baby Max was a little thin. And, I don’t think the ending was totally satisfying.  It felt a little as though the author wasn’t quite sure how to finish the story herself or just got to the point where she decided enough was enough.

But, criticisms aside I did enjoy this.  It is quite a lovely read and if nothing else I think it would convince anyone to want to visit the ancient Cathedral of Chartres.  The descriptions are amazing.

I suppone if I was going to say what this book was really about I would ultimately describe it as a book about forgiveness.  How your life isn’t necessarily set in stone due to events in your past and how you can make changes if you want to.

Eleven things of mild interest

Posted On 19 April 2013

Filed under Book Reviews

Comments Dropped 36 responses

Okay, the lovely Nadine from SFFbook review nominated me for a Liebster Award.  I know these aren’t everybody’s cup of tea but I must admit I enjoy all the silly trivia or questions!

1. Thank the Liebster Blog presenter who nominated you and link back to their blog.  Thank you Nadine!
2. Post 11 facts about yourself, answer the 11 questions you were asked and create 11 questions for your nominees.
3. Nominate 11 blogs who you feel deserve to be noticed and leave a comment on their blog letting them know they have been chosen.
4. Display the Liebster Award logo.
5.  No tag back thingies.

Them’s the rules. I didn’t make em so if you don’t like em then remember that rules are made for breaking.  So, moving swiftly on:

  1. When I was 15 I read Gone with the Wind and had a massive crush on Rhett Butler
  2. I can have a tendency to OCD and if I don’t (literally) tell myself I’ve done something, like set the alarm or lock the door, then I have to check it over and over again!
  3. The above being said, strangely enough I have managed to shut myself out of the house so many times it’s embarrassing.
  4. Up until late teens I had terrible car sickness, being the youngest I was always made to sit in the middle – a bit silly really when projectile vomit was imminent!  Not nice.
  5. My sister and I are born in the same year – although we are not twins
  6. I have a strange ability to remember lots of telephone numbers which makes me like the speaking directory in work!
  7. I enjoy drawing/sketching although I never do so anymore.
  8. I’m slightly (a bit)(okay quite a bit) superstitious, picking up pennies (which, yuk because you don’t know where they’ve been, but it’s almost like bad luck not to pick them up right?) or saluting single magpies – for which I get some very funny looks!
  9. I used to play Pokemon – don’t even say anything. Actually I was pretty damn good and collected the whole collection, plus my Dewgong (sign) – shut up!!
  10. I am not girly at all.  I hate shopping.  I have about two pairs of shoes, one bag (and that used to be a rucksack), virtually no make up and I don’t get upset about having my hair chopped off and stuck out in all directions.
  11. One thing that I really do is keep in touch with people from forever ago – I’m almost like a great pen pal – but not a pen pal an email pal!

The set questions:

  1. What was the book that got you into reading? Lord of the Rings (lots of books before that but this really sealed the deal)
  2. What is your favorite fantasy movie? Lord of the Rings (this could become boring – but Aragorn- book and film crush)
  3. Hugo or Nebula? Hugo – but don’t ask me why.
  4. How many books are you currently reading?  Three
  5. What was your last author crush (as in Oh my God, I need to buy everything this person has ever written)? Neil Gaiman
  6. What’s your favorite name?  Max
  7. What book would you give to your younger self and why?  Can I take books back in time? in which case Harry Potter.
  8. Where on the internet do you go for inspiration? Blogs, twitter, google, everywhere.
  9. Name a fictional character you’d like to trade bodies with for a while.  Hit Girl from Kick Ass.  Because she does kick ass!
  10. If your life had a theme song, what would it be?  I’m Walking on Sunshine by Katrina and the Waves
  11. Fantasy or Reality? Both.  Okay I have to pick – Fantasy

My questions are going to be very simple – except you HAVE to pick one – you are NOT ALLOWED to say both – otherwise the consequences will be heinous (you have been warned):

  1. Beer or Wine
  2. Dogs or Cats
  3. Fantasy or Sci Fi
  4. Book or Film
  5. Star Wars or Star Trek
  6. Batman or Superman
  7. Anime or Manga
  8. Gaiman or Tolkien
  9. Reading or Music
  10. Chocolate or Cheese
  11. Morning or night

Remember you can’t have both!!  No way can you have both – pick one already.

Now for the part I don’t like – choosing my nominees.  Not because I don’t want to choose people but because I’m not sure they’ll want to take part – if you don’t then don’t worry about it – I know this is time consuming.  Plus, it’s difficult with this 200 followers thing because you lot are all so shagging popular you make me sick – so you probably have more followers – in which case, either consider yourself disqualified from answering or not :

  1. http://eliseschipper.wordpress.com/
  2. http://booksireadandliked.wordpress.com/
  3. http://princeofink.wordpress.com/
  4. http://whathannahread.wordpress.com/
  5. http://spidermonkeycat.wordpress.com/
  6. http://thebookwormchronicles.wordpress.com/
  7. http://dabofdarkness.com/
  8. http://genkinahito.wordpress.com/
  9. http://bookypony.wordpress.com/
  10. http://darkcargo.com/
  11. http://barbarafriendish.wordpress.com/

Okay, a thousand apologies to all of the above it they (a) don’t want to take part (b) want to take part but don’t have the time (c) have thousands of followers but I just don’t know what I’m doing (which is most probably very true) (d) want to take part, don’t have the time but will persist anyway but then get trapped under a large object (not big enough to do serious damage though – just to alleviate any worries on the part of others).

That’s it for me.  Lynn has left the building.

Shadow of the Sun readalong, by Barbara Friend Ish, week 3

This week is the third week of the Shadow of the Sun readalong being hosted by Dab of Darkness.  Check out the details here – there’s all sorts going on including a giveaway and free download of the book for the duration of the readalong.

If you haven’t joined in yet but still want to do so it’s not too late but if you are considering reading then read no further for there will be spoilers.

Up to this section, we believed the Basghilae could not cross water, but we learn to the detriment of our heroes that this is not so. What further hidden abilities do you think might crop up from these walking dead?

Well, lets give the wish list of haves and have nots.  I’m hoping that they don’t have a stash of rocket launchers!  I’m hoping that they don’t know magic!!  I’m hoping that they haven’t learn’t to teleport and I’m hoping that they haven’t learnt to mimic Ellion, Letitia or any of the others!!!

Probably not very useful (to them) but I’m hoping that they can make a mean apple pie, I’m hoping that they can talk fluent French and I’m also hoping that they’re all fully fledged members of their local library!  I’m guessing I’m not going to get lucky with the wish lists.  And for the avoidance of doubt this means I don’t really know – perhaps they can fly – that would be very bad – although, no, we’d already know because they wouldn’t have saved that beauty.

As the party enters the human lands, they come up with a cover story and request that Letitia remove her torc. She refuses. Do you think her decision was the correct one?

No.  Between Ellion refusing to use magic for everyone’s benefit and Letitia not taking simple precautions they’re really driving me bonkers.  Who needs enemies with these two around – they’re basically their own worst enemy all rolled up into one!  However, it does reinforce our theories that there’s something more to the Torc than meets the eye.

At one point Ellion lingers over the warding process, specifically warding Letitia, and how a person must be completely nude for wards to be put in place. I’m going to leave this one wide open for comment ;). 

I think it’s a good job that he didn’t get to ward Letitia because his mind wouldn’t be on the job.  I don’t think she’d be very protected at all.

Ellion makes a tough decision to leave the Tanaan and while he watches them leave he has a huge epiphany about his inner motives. How do you think this will affect his actions and motivations the rest of the book? 

Maybe he’ll start thinking things through a bit better.  I know, I probably sound harsh on him there but some of his decisions just infuriate me.  He refuses to use magic even though it would be VERY helpful.  Then he blames himself every time someone dies – why, these are warriors, they know what they’re facing and it’s their decision.  I don’t like Ellion taking on responsibility for them in this way – I don’t know why it just feels like it someone belittles their own actions and decisions.  Honestly, I don’t dislike Ellion but it’s pointless feeling guilt, particularly when you’re not prepared to do your utmost to help protect in the first place.  Sorry, is that really harsh??

We saw the Tanaan and Ellion in some interesting situations of a more personal nature in these chapters, from the Night Butterflies to cutting in at a dance. What did you make of these instances, what further cultural differences along these lines do you foresee happening, and have you ever been a part of such a situation? 

I thought the differences in culture that came across were really interesting to read about.  All the little talks about Night Butterflies or how to cut in on a dance.  What on earth was Ellion thinking giving Letitia one of the Night Butterflies scarves.  Surely we just read that those scarves are worn by all such women and are almost a means of recognising them – and there he goes and gives one to her!  What is he trying to say exactly ;D  Whether I’m in a different cultural situation or not one thing you can usually guarantee from me is to put my foot in it sooner or later (especially after I’m in my cups!)(I love that phrase by the way).

Once again, we were treated to some fight scenes. What stood out for you about these scenes?

I liked the way that Ellion and Amien managed to overcome their differences when it was needed.  They fell right back into their old fighting routines working as a team.  ‘Kachow! ‘ ‘Pow’.

The Emoticon Generation Blog Tour!

Okay, today the tour for Guy Hasson’s book The Emoticon Generation, organised by Little Red Reviewer, stops by my blog.  The EG is a book of 7 short sci fi stories.

My first point. I would probably describe these as ‘soft sci-fi’ because whist they take you on a bit of a journey into a few possible futures they’re easily accessible or user friendly.  Or, if you want to be a bit of a stickler and call a spade a spade- I can be a bit of a dunce when it comes to all the science-maths-mumbo-jumbo-magical-bits and these stories didn’t make me feel like that.  In fact I didn’t get the feeling that I wanted to throw the book against a wall at all – which is just as well because I was reading this on my laptop!

My next point.  I don’t tend to read a lot of short stories because I feel disconnected to the characters.  I usually feel that I don’t spend enough time with them to get comfy.  However that isn’t the case here – the author has a way of writing that you can’t help connecting.

Anyway, I don’t want to go into overdrive so just a few thoughts for each – more so probably for my favourites.

Generation E – the father of a young girl goes snooping on his daughter’s phone and becomes concerned when he is unable to read most of what it contains because it seems to be all made up of symbols.  Now, this might not be a mind blowing story.  It’s gentle.  But it really resounded with me.  I think the author is really insightful in this story.  He talks about the father still thinking he has his finger on the pulse, which is probably the way a lot of parents feel and yet in reality your children really don’t see you this way.  Let’s face it, at the age of 17 most teenagers think 24 year olds are passed their prime!  So, he goes a snooping – tempting I know but naughty – and let’s face it ‘what you don’t know can’t hurt you’!  Basically your children love to have something that’s theirs and that you don’t understand.  For years they’ve been using words in a different context to that originally intended.  Then words became shortened – ‘c u l*tr’ then they progressed again into initials which is the stage we’re currently at and seems to give kids a way of swearing at their parents without getting caught – brb, cba, ffs, roflmao, etc, etc.  Anyway, this just takes it a step further – the really weird thing is you can see it happening!

Hatchling.  I loved this story and totally bought into the young girl.  Hasson just has a way of making you form attachments even over a few pages.  Nothing is squandered.  His writing is to the point and almost clinical in its lack of flowery description but it still pulls you in.  The young girl in the story basically has questions about her father.  Questions her mother avoids, ignores or just downright refuses to answer.  But this niggle isn’t going away, the niggle develops into an itch which is scratched into a sore until she picks and picks and ‘whoa’ opens up a can!  This is a clever young lady.  She has a computer and isn’t afraid to use it.  Apart from all the scary ‘big brother’ type events depicted here which are enough to have you looking over your shoulder, (really, you won’t be able to scratch your head without somebody picking up on it! ) is the fact that secrets will out.  However, the grass isn’t always greener (I’m having a challenge with myself to fit in lots of little sayings)  I read this story with a mounting sense of horror like a deer caught in the headlights.  It was compelling and had an unpredictable twist.  Scary ending.

The Assassination – okay, this was my least favourite.  I don’t know why but it just didn’t hold as much appeal for me.  It’s a sort of interview scenario with a former army guy who killed and has been grilled over the sequence of events ever since.  But, we appear to have discovered some new technology that allows us to replay conversations from years back – actually don’t women already do this??  I’m just saying.  Anyway, I’m not going to elaborate on this one other than to say there’s a general unspoken rule about trying to be careful about the written word because you never know when it will come back to haunt you – well, reading this, you better be careful about the spoken word as well.

Freedom is Only a Step Away.  I enjoyed this story, particularly the ending which was very satisfying.  We have a scientist who has discovered that imagination is good for you. (well score one for all us book readers because we already knew that anyway and let our imaginations run riot on a regular basis).  Imagination though shouldn’t be suppressed.  It’s harmful to children to do so and hinders them in later life.  By the time you reach adulthood your brain is trapped in a cage.  What I really enjoyed about this story was the way it unfolded, pretty much using a typical family watching news clips and then the resulting discussion.  We see scepticism, followed by interest, happiness, anarchy and a gradual revolution of the education system as we currently know it.  The funny thing is I couldn’t wait to see what would happen or how the author would resolve things.  I veered between ‘mmm, interesting’ to ‘no way’. I really don’t want to give away the ending so I’m going to use one of my father-in-laws funny phrases (he has a whole bunch) – ‘if things don’t alter they’ll stay the same’.

All of Me.  Now, this was okay but not as entertaining for me as a few of the others.  It brings to us a revolutionary development that can copy a person’s brain and in so doing come up with formulas for – which in doing so means you can add to the formulas to jump forwards. Basically this story has a young woman buy her boyfriend an unusual gift, one which she actually becomes quite addicted to.  In this instance the grass is greener on the other side!  It definitely is a thought provoking story though.  I’m intrigued about what exactly she was thinking – well, I suppose she was seeking the perfect partner and was able to manipulate things to achieve it.

Eternity Wasted builds on the previous story and expands it further.  Eternity Wasted is about a mathematical genius who has found a bit of a cheat.  He’s using the brain copying invention from All of Me and manipulating it to his own ends.  I was really horrified by his actions – the things he was actually doing to his ‘other’ self.  Is this the way you would behave providing you didn’t think it would affect you personally.  However, his ‘other’ self is going to get it’s revenge.

The last story Her Destiny also uses the brain copying invention but in a different way.  This ends up becoming something I hadn’t expected at all and goes from being down right hairs-on-the-back-of your-neck-standing-up-creepy to making you wonder.  Really is there such a thing as destiny.  It’s an unusual and fascinating concept.  Is your perfect person out there?  If you don’t end up with him will fate intervene to change circumstances.  Very enjoyable and one of my favourite stories of the collection.

Guy Hasson is also serialising his short stories on mythology/fairy tales ‘Tickling Butterflies” on his blog.  I will definitely be checking that out!

 

Guess which tower…

Posted On 13 April 2013

Filed under Book Reviews
Tags: ,

Comments Dropped 28 responses

Bit of foolishness for a Saturday afternoon.  Decided to build a tower of books as part of a little competition chucked out there by Mark Lawrence (check it out here).  I don’t think I’m really in the running as the objective is to actually build the tallest tower (and this clearly isn’t it) so I decided to go for a fully built tower with turrets.  I can’t do the tall tower because:

  1. I’m too short.  It would require steps and that’s not a good idea
  2. My co-ordination would become wobbly and I’d probably just keep knocking it over.  I can’t build a house of cards even.
  3. See the maniac critter at the front of the picture – that’s my dog – and he though he was missing out so he kept bounding in and out of the room – so any chance of building a real tower would have been in grave danger of toppling!

So, which tower do you think I was aiming for – it actually doesn’t really look like it but if you want a guess then go for it: (oh and Katie is stood inside – I did go away and leave her for a while!)  Now, I jus need to tidy all this away – Doh!!!!

My tower of books

« Previous Page — Next Page »