Review: Paved With Good Intentions by Peter McLean (War for the Rose Throne #5)

My Five Word TL:DR Review: Brilliant, I absolutely loved it

I’m just going to be honest – I’m not usually a fan of spin off books or prequels – and yet, I loved this.  It was such a good read and I think, in all honesty, even if you haven’t read the other books in this series, you could read this as a standalone – and, in fact, it might be a perfect way to discover if you love this world or not.

The story focuses on Eline and basically how she becomes a Queen’s Man.

I’m actually not going to go into the plot.  I’m going to focus on what I really enjoyed.

First and foremost, the writing.  McLean has some writing chops.  This isn’t my first rodeo and I literally fell into this with ease.  I really enjoyed it.  This is my fantasy, grimdark if you will, kind of story.  It doesn’t pull the punches, it’s raw and gritty, maybe a little bit shocking, but it isn’t gruesome or gratuitous.

I loved Eline, her story is so fascinating.  Horrifying and yet hopeful.   She is one resilient woman. I can’t event begin to contemplate what she went through and yet she is a strong woman, and clever.

The rest of the cast are also really good.  Eline has this motherly quality, she has two children of her own and she extends those feelings to the people she finds herself amongst.

I can’t say too much more.  Other than, this book is so good.  I absolutely loved it.  The characters, the setting, the story – all perfect.  I would love to read more about Eline and what comes next, or maybe this is as much of her back story as we’re going to discover.  For me, this was such a good read, I can’t recommend it enough.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks, the agove is my own opinion.

My rating 4.5 of 5 stars

11 Responses to “Review: Paved With Good Intentions by Peter McLean (War for the Rose Throne #5)”

  1. Tammy's avatar Tammy

    I started this series, maybe read the first two books, and i didn’t even know about this book! So glad you loved it, it sounds amazing.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar @lynnsbooks

      It was really good, of course McLean is an excellent author so I expected to love it really.

      Lynn 😀

  2. pagesandtea's avatar pagesandtea

    This sounds so good that I’d be tempted to give it a chance even though I’ve not read the rest of the books, especially as you say this could be a good starting point before going for the rest of the series.

    Glad you enjoyed it so much 😀

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar @lynnsbooks

      Yes, you could read this to see if the writing and style work for you.

      Lynn 😀

  3. Booking Ahead/Weekly Wrap Up | Books and travelling with Lynn

    […] Paved with Good Intentions by Peter McLean […]

  4. Charlotte's avatar Charlotte

    I almost didn’t read this as I saw it was a later book in a series but then I spotted your prequel comment and the good starting point commented and figured it was safe to check out 😅 this sounds really interesting. The central character sounds delightful to discover and her backstory sounds like the sort that I have a tendency to find fascinating. I hadn’t heard of this series before but it does sound like another to add to my endless TBR.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar @lynnsbooks

      I think this would be a good point to dip your toe into the water – this series has a gritty grimdark feel and so I’m not sure if that is your ‘thing’ or not but the writing is very good and I loved the main character and her determination.

      Lynn 😀

      • Charlotte's avatar Charlotte

        Thanks for the advice, it turned out I actually already had book one on my TBR when I went to add it to the list 😂 it’s good to know this could work well as a starting point too though. And the main character sounds fantastic

  5. Bookish Highlights for 2025 | Books and travelling with Lynn

    […] Paved With Good Intentions by Peter McLean […]

  6. Top Ten Tuesday: Best Books I read in 2025 | Books and travelling with Lynn

    […] Paved With Good Intentions by Peter McLean […]

Leave a comment