Review: The Trouble With Mrs Montgomery Hurst by Katie Lumsden

My Five Word TL:DR Review: A Love Letter to Austen

I really enjoyed this story. It manages to combine some more modern themes and sensibilities with a perfectly executed comedy of manners amidst a profusion of gossip and a splendour of bonnets and bickering. 

The story is set in the fictional county of Wickenshire and revolves mostly around the exploits of a young woman called Amelia Ashpoint. As you would expect from a novel set in this period (late Regency/early Victorian) the more prominent families spend their time worrying about money, future prospects for their sons/daughters and keeping up appearances. 

As the story begins we immediately discover that one of the more desirable bachelors of the neighbourhood is about to marry – and not to one of the local young ladies. Imagine the consternation when it’s discovered that this new lady has not only been previously married (shock, horror, *gasp*) but also has three children. The indignation is real!

Anyway, I’m not going to delve deeper into the plot. Suffice to say that there are enough twists and turns to this one to delight and perplex readers aplenty. 

What I loved about this. Virtually everything to be honest. It’s really entertaining, the writing and pace are excellent, it feels like a period novel without being too fusty and it made me smile and sometimes cringe a little. 

The characters are really well drawn. Amelia gave me Emma vibes with her constant interfering and usually ill conceived plots and statements. I don’t think she came across as nearly as witty as she and everyone else believed but even so I liked and was rooting for her.  There are a collection of characters from Earls to brewery managers, all with their own motivations and the story really brought to life the strict etiquette of the period that was so very restraining whilst at the same time demonstrating how some of these norms were perhaps starting to relax a little. 

I loved the country and Manor House setting, the insertion of many small dramas that kept the place alive with gossip and the constant behind doors attempts at match making. And this is all delivered alongside some much more weighty themes that are inserted with a wonderfully light touch. 

I thoroughly enjoyed this tale of manners. It’s a step away from the fantasy, horror and mystery that I often enjoy and was a lovely change of pace. Highly recommended for Austen lovers. 

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion. 

My rating 4.5 beribboned stars

7 Responses to “Review: The Trouble With Mrs Montgomery Hurst by Katie Lumsden”

  1. Tammy's avatar Tammy

    It’s always good to step outside the familiar now and then. I think I would love this too.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar @lynnsbooks

      This was such a lovely read, I thoroughly enjoyed it.

      Lynn 😀

  2. mallikabooks's avatar mallikabooks15

    Sounds well balanced and fun.

  3. Charlotte's avatar Charlotte

    This sounds like a lot of fun 😁 especially as it’s the kind of setting that’s always intriguing to explore. The Etiquette that you mentioned is always interesting to learn about. Although I have to admit that I still need to read Austen 🙈

  4. Countdown to 2025: Day 11: Mistletoe | Books and travelling with Lynn

    […] The Trouble with Mrs Montgomery Hurst by Katie Lumsden – this was a really delightful read. […]

  5. WordsAndPeace's avatar WordsAndPeace

    Probably well done, but not for me. Yes, your vey first paragraph made me right away think of Austen, and I have a real hard time with this author

Leave a reply to Charlotte Cancel reply