The Toymakers by Robert Dinsdale

toysThe Toymakers is a book that I felt certain I would love, there was something about it that simply called out to me.  Perhaps it was a childish whim, perhaps it just appeals to the romantic side of my nature that is called forth by nostalgia, but, if you remember a time where a cardboard box was a castle, the underneath of a kitchen table a fortress and a sheet thrown between two washing lines a tent in the wilds then I dare say this will appeal to you too.  This is a book that simply shouts out to the child in everyone. It’s packed with imagination.

It starts at a time where the country has seen much war and perhaps in such times dreams become hope and toy shops become little miracles of possibility.

The year is 1917,  We meet with Cathy Wray who has brought shame to her family by becoming pregnant out of wedlock.  There are two solutions, Cathy can be taken to an institution that will deliver her baby and take it for adoption, or she can take herself out of that possible situation by running away.  Cathy chooses to run away from her home and finds herself in London where she becomes fortunate enough to find a job, room and board at Papa Jack’s Toy Emporium.

I’m not going to go into the plot any further because not only do I think that this book is best explored by the reader without any fore knowledge but also this book is so much more than the plot itself.

The writing here is beautiful.  The Imagination is captivating.  And, I think my biggest disappointment is that I just wanted to spend all my time in the Emporium itself – it’s magical, wonderful and breathtaking.  I felt like a child in a sweetie shop reading this.  It simply took me back.  I defy anyone to read this book and not feel the childish wonder that is evoked.  The emporium is incredible of itself, wonders that seem to defy expectation, Wendy Houses that are like a tardis once stepped inside, paper trees that seem to grow from tiny little boxes, toy boxes with more space within than physics can explain. Isn’t this just what your imagination was like as a child when anything and everything was possible?  The moon was a balloon that you could capture, your bedsheets became a rabbits’ warren and shadows could menace you with hidden faces.

The characters are also something out of a fairytale.  We have Papa Jack.  He’s like a big old grizzly bear.  Everyone is afraid of him whilst at the same time knowing that he’s softer than a wet tissue.  He has a history full of sorrow but at the same time he seems to be full of impossible magic.  He has two sons, Kaspar and Emil, they love their father, they love the shop and they love each other but at the same time they are inextricably set in a battle, not just of the toy soldiers that they pitch against each other year after year, but for the admiration of the father that they both adore.

Herein lies the crux of the matter.  Both boys are in a competition of sorts and one that eventually blinds them to the love they have for each other.  They compete over who makes the best toys, who will run the store, who wins their ongoing battle of the soldiers, who gets the girl, and who has the most magic.  And, unfortunately, things eventually turn very real and a little bit ugly.

The characters are a mixed bunch.   Cathy, although very much at the forefront of things almost feels secondary.  The competition between the two boys is very much the underlying force of the story and does in fact lead to something of a love triangle. The thing is, you have sympathy for one of the boys but at the same time it’s always clear who is the favourite of the piece.  Not just of Cathy or Papa Jack but of the reader and it’s a little bit sad because you really don’t want to choose between the two but at the same time it feels simply inevitable and also a little bit obvious.

In terms of criticisms.  Well, this is a book that, whilst I should have seen the way it was going, I really didn’t.  It’s a book that moves with the times and with it comes almost the death of a dream.  But, my niggle here comes in the actions of one of the characters.  For me it doesn’t ring true and the ending also takes something that is a beautiful dream and tries too much to turn it into something more.  For me, the ending chapters simply didn’t work and whilst it didn’t spoil the book for me it changed the feeling somewhat.  Otherwise, a stunning book.

Overall I loved this, it’s beautifully told and is perhaps one of the most evocative stories I’ve ever read.  I was a little bit underwhelmed with the ending but at the same time, on reflection, I can appreciate how difficult it was to maintain this fantasy and I can see why the author went down this route – I suppose I just wanted the dream to continue.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks.  The above is my own opinion.

12 Responses to “The Toymakers by Robert Dinsdale”

  1. beereaderbooks

    Great balanced review, I think the ending is divisive, I loved it and found it expanded a theory about life, creativity and magic but I can see why it might be too out there for others

    • @lynnsbooks

      Yeah. I think it was so unexpected and it seemed that one of the brothers acted out of character for me. But even with that I thought it was a great read. I loved the emporium. So sad really and also a bit of a sign of the times.

  2. Tammy

    I’m so glad you reviewed this, I didn’t know much about it. I love stories that evoke childhood memories😊

    • @lynnsbooks

      It’s beautiful and magical – I found the ending a tiny bit out there, otherwise this would have been a perfect 5 star read.
      Lynn 😀

  3. sjhigbee

    This one sounds absolutely delightful, Lynn. Thank you so much for a wonderful review:)

    • @lynnsbooks

      It was such a good read – I wasn’t enamoured with the ending but it didn’t spoil the read at all.
      Lynn 😀

  4. Zezee

    I’m glad you liked it. It’s one I want to read too and was waiting to see what you’d say of it. I can’t wait to try it.

  5. maddalena@spaceandsorcery

    I’ve often heard the old maxim about never losing contact with your inner child, and this book seems to appeal to that inner child and to try and coax it out of hiding: despite your misgivings about the ending, I think I would love to see for myself how much of that child I used to be is still there… 🙂
    Thanks for sharing!

    • @lynnsbooks

      The writing is beautiful and it just made me want to cry at points. Really magical and so nostalgic. And, also a little bit I suppose a commentary on the way things have changed because I don’t suppose you really get emporiums like that any more – in fact, ironically Toys R Us has just closed up shop in this country – not really the same thing I realise but still a reflection on the way things have changed.
      Lynn 😀

  6. Friday Face Off :  ‘who will buy this wonderful morning’ | Books and travelling with Lynn

    […] not!  I think my eventual choice would probably have been the same anyway.  This week my books is The Toymakers by Robert […]

  7. A Perfect Marriage : Magic and Realism | Books and travelling with Lynn

    […] The Toymakers by Robert Dinsdale – ‘while all toy shops are places of wonder, only one is truly magical…’ […]

Leave a Reply to Friday Face Off :  ‘who will buy this wonderful morning’ | Books and travelling with Lynn Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s