ebooks vs paper books??

It’s an inevitable question isn’t it.  A while ago I had a kindle bought for me.  I was a little underwhelmed at the time because to be honest I prefer books.  However, that being said it’s amazing quite how easily the kindle becomes a part of your reading life, it inveigles itself and creeps up on you unexpectedly.  Let’s face it the books you buy for your kindle are more reasonably priced.  There are frequently good deals on some of your favourite books.  There are daily deals and many books are completely free, especially the classics.  If I was to list my pros and cons they would probably be:

Pros:

  1. Cheaper books
  2. No matter how many books you have on the go at any time your place is always saved – no need for bookmarks
  3. No stacks of books all over the house
  4. Easy to highlight relevant parts which is great when doing a readalong
  5. Quick to purchase – ‘one click’
  6. No postage costs or delivery time
  7. You can take a thousand books away on holiday with you and still fit clothes into your suitcase
  8. Really good for reading big chunksters

Cons:

  1. They’re not books!  Books are like trophies in a way, I love having them gathered all over the house. I don’t know why but they’re just a part of my personality and I feel like they say something about me that a kindle just doesn’t.
  2. No stacks of books all over the house!
  3. The books are cheaper but if I read a book I love I still want to own the paper version which in reality means I buy the book twice!
  4. It runs out of battery at the most inopportune times – my fault but nonetheless infuriating when it happens
  5. They’re pretty useless in terms of glossaries or maps that are usually at the front or back of the book – if you’re reading a book it’s so much easier to flip from front to back.  Which means I tend to ignore these things completely!
  6. I lose the association with the look of the book and the title and author.  Sometimes I will struggle to remember a book’s author after I’ve finished reading on the kindle – I know that sounds odd but when you’re reading a book you see the cover and name/author all the time.  It just reinforces it somehow.
  7. I can’t be nosey and look at what other people are reading when they’re using a kindle.  I know, I know.  I’m a nosey so and so, but, I just can’t help wanting to know what everyone else is reading – well, it could be the next ‘big thing’.
  8. It really is too easy to buy books this way which means you purchase on the slightest whim – there are no physical inhibitors, no scowling partners – no books taunting you from the windowsill, coffee table, bedside cabinet.

So, it appears evens doesn’t it – and yet, I still prefer the book.  I worry about all the talk surrounding the disappearance of paper books, how they’ll soon just become a thing of the past.  Let’s face it some books are never printed at all now.  What happens to all the gorgeous cover art??  Will it still be needed?

It definitely makes me a bit sad to think electronic books may be the end of paper ones.  After all, as much as I’ve grown accustomed to my kindle it’s never going to fulfill my dream of having a library is it!!

And, I wonder what authors make of ebooks.  I can’t help thinking it must be really satisfying when you receive that first copy of a book with your name on it – and yet at the same time so many books are self published now which gives some authors a chance that they wouldn’t previously have had)  Of course, there’s a whole other argument around that and the flooding of the book market with so many books that probably would never have made the cut through a publishing house.

Your thoughts??

 

 

34 Responses to “ebooks vs paper books??”

  1. jessicabookworm's avatar jessicabookworm

    I love my kindle for how practical it is. As you said I can carry hundreds of books around, especially useful on holiday, and it fits easily in my handbag meaning I’m never without something to read. However I agree I won’t stop having books as well as its a completely different experience to break open the pages of a book especially of a well loved and read favourite.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I do have a bit of a love affair going on with paper books but it doesn’t mean that I can’t also appreciate my kindle. I would hate to think that paper books become a thing of the past though.
      Lynn 😀

  2. jenclair's avatar jenclair

    I remember being reluctant to get an e-reader, but over time, I’ve become quite addicted. I still love physical books, and the cover art is one reason. It is also easier to (for me) to locate a passage in a real book, and if I want to re-read, I’m more likely to do so with a physical book.

    I love my Kindle for many of the reasons you mention, and I don’t have to worry about the stacks of books that will never be read again needing a place on the shelf. In the end, I want any book I’ll read again in physical form, but most books are just a one read experience, and the e-reader is great for that.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I definitely think you need a paper book for rereads. Plus, like you – I love the cover art.
      It will be interesting to see if paper books can hold their own – I certainly hope so.
      Lynn 😀

  3. Lynn E. O'Connacht's avatar Lynn E. O'Connacht

    For me the biggest pro that ebooks have over paper books is that ebooks are a lot more comfortable to hold. Hardcover (and trade paperbacks) are often too large for me to hold comfortably, while mass market paperbacks are too thick. But my ereader? Fits my hands snugly and perfectly.

    But I do love both and I will continue to read both. I will continue to buy books I loved twice because I really want that paper copy too. You’ve got a great set of lists there that echoes mine pretty neatly. But mostly for me the ebooks win out because they’re actually comfortable to hold for longer periods of time. ^_^

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      The ebooks are definitely easier to read for the sort of books that I frequently pick up. For example The Wise Men’s Fear by Patrick Rothfuss – I had to prop that open on a cushion on my knee. It’s such a huge book that it’s really hard work to keep hold of.
      I don’t think I’ll ever give up paper books but I wonder if the next generation of readers will feel the same connection.
      Lynn 😀

  4. Catherine's avatar Catherine

    Yes e-readers versus real books is a big debate. I love books, the real ones and I have a Kindle. For me it is more 2/3 things:the price : sometimes cheaper in paper (charity shops) sometimes on Kindle (daily deals or other), the room/size of the book. I enjoy reading on the Kindle for its practicality but the feeling and the relation is different than with a book that you manipulate, turn over to have a look at this cover that you love. In the end for me it is a compromise. I alternate my readings on Kindle and real book because I need this balance and because I need both to downsize my pile to read on my shelves AND on my Kindle.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      You definitely feel a different connection with a paper book. Are at least I do, but perhaps it’s in my mind!
      I agree about the downsizing.
      But I’ll never own my own library room with just a Kindle.
      Lynn 😀

  5. lipsyy's avatar lipsyy

    I have thus far resisted getting a kindle etc…I hate the idea of them even though I know it will make my life so much easier, especially where book blogging is concerned. But they’re just not books are they?

    I’m pretty sure I’ll have to give in eventually but I really don’t want to. And, to add to the cons list – you can’t borrow/lend books between friends…that’s a deal breaker for me!

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      It probably would make your life easier as a blogger but like you say – you can’t share and they just don’t feel the same as a physical book. I think the best pro for me is when I go on holiday – I used to have to make all the family carry a couple of books for me as I hated running out!
      I would hate to see paper books disappear and part of me feels like a traitor for having the kindle!
      Lynn 😀

    • mshannahw's avatar mshannahw

      I hadn’t even thought of the whole borrowing/lending between friends things, despite my main reason for not wanting one being the greater cost of e-books compared to library ones *duh*.

      • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

        Yeah, that’s another downside. I did used to pass on some of my books – for example to my dad but I can’t do them when on the Kindle!
        Lynn 😀

  6. Kavir's avatar Rabindranauth

    I love paperbacks, I used to read strictly those. But because of how much it costs to ship certain new releases to Guyana that I don’t find right here, I caved and started using the Kindle app on my tablet. So now it’s a mix, I guess. Maybe 30% ebook and 70% paperback 🙂

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Yeah, I think my split is probably similar. Like you say, the imports are expensive. Plus, because I read a lot of blogs and then want to read the books they recommend it is definitely easier and quicker to purchase on kindle.
      I do love paperbacks though.
      Lynn 😀

  7. Michael H's avatar Michael

    As you said, there are positive and negatives to each one. I can easily add to my TBR pile using both and I can easily “forget” which book I “need” to read next. 🙂

    My e-reader will learn my reading speed and tell me how long it will take me to read the next chapter. This can be a good way to talk myself into or out of reading just one more chapter when I’m reading to wind down for the day.

    The big advantage for my e-reader books is no matter how long the book, holding my e-reader is a consistent weight. This is helpful for larger tomes like the latest George R.R. Martin fantasy book or the latest from Brandon Sanderson or even a large Stephen King novel. Sometimes (especially early or late in the book), my hands can get tired from the weight of the book and that may make me read less. With an e-book reader, it’s always the same weight, thus I might read longer or not “hurry” to get to a point where the weight is equal for both hands.

    I do wish there was a way that if I bought a physical copy of a novel, that I could pay a little extra to get the e-reader copy. In the case of Martin’s books, I want to have a physical copy of the novel to sit along-side the full set of Song of Fire and Ice novels, but it’d be nice to have an e-book copy to read because of the size. Similar to buying a movie on DVD and getting a digital copy. I’d pay a dollar or two more to have both the physical copy to put on the shelf and the e-book copy to read on the e-reader.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Oh, I like that – that your ereader learns your speed – how clever! I definitely agree with the consistent weight thing – plus another one which I forgot is that sometimes the really chunky books are almost impossible to open and they certainly don’t always lie flat.
      I think that’s a really good idea about if you’ve purchased the hard back then also having the ebook – there must be a way to do that and monitor it and like you say it would be worth paying a little extra for.
      Lynn 😀

  8. Steph's avatar stephswint

    I love both and I love audible books. I am sad I’ve found I will reach for my e reader before a paperback now, and it also means I don’t spend as much time in libraries and bookstores – my favorite haunts. Plus side I don’t have to wait to buy the sequel. My ereader doesn’t weigh a ton. *This is my thought.* You should buy both because of the ever so anticipated Zombie Apocalypse:) You have the physical copy if there is no electricity, and if you have rechargeable batteries if you have to bug out – the ereader is super light, and can have all kinds of survival data stored on it. I know, I know, I’m joking…but am I:)

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      You won’t believe this but I was also thinking you should have both – perhaps not because of the zombie apocalypse (although given that I read quite a lot of these types of books – you never do know) but in the event of some sort of problem a book is a book and it doesn’t need recharging. I quite often carry both in my bag. Even if my current read is on the kindle – I like to have backup!
      Lynn 😀

  9. Nathan's avatar Nathan

    I have switched almost completely to ebook. Just so convenient. Though I still get a bit of joy when a physical book shows up in the mail, unless it is 500+ pages then I long for my ereader again.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Wow, switched almost completely – so have you kept all your books or are you aiming to become book free and save space? I can definitely see the appeal when reading big books although watching the percentage bar virtually not move, even after you’ve been reading for ages – is probably not quite as satisfying as reading a book and seeing the number of pages that you’ve read.
      Lynn 😀

  10. PaulineMRoss's avatar paulinemross

    I’m a Kindle convert. I’ve hardly read a physical book at all in the three and a half years since I bought my first Kindle (yes, I’m onto my second, a Paperwhite), and then only when I have to, for my book group or for a non-fiction book that isn’t available in ebook form.

    Having moved several times in my life, and having a loft full of boxes of books not yet unpacked (nowhere to put them), the Kindle is a lifesaver. It means I can buy more books! And nobody knows just how many books I own. 🙂 I’m gradually sending all but my special books off to the charity shop.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I like the idea of buying books without anybody knowing – although that really only feeds my strange obsession and ‘one click’ is far too easy!
      I’m on the old original Kindle. I like it for some reasons – I wish it was backlit though. I could buy a newer one I suppose but there’s nothing wrong with this one so it sort of bugs me.
      Lynn 😀

  11. cleopatralovesbooks's avatar cleopatralovesbooks

    Out of all your cons it is number 7 that resonates most.. If I see someone else reading a book I like to see what it’s about for myself….

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I know – sometimes I nearly injure myself trying to peer at other people’s books!
      Lynn 😀

      • cleopatralovesbooks's avatar cleopatralovesbooks

        That moment when you realise that everyone can see you staring and think that you are a little bit weird!

      • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

        Yes, that moment!!
        Lynn 😀

  12. Priya's avatar Priya

    I’m increasingly switching to ebooks for all the pros you mentioned (except bookmarks, I love bookmarks!) So I feel especially excited now whenever I get a paperback, it just feels so special. That being said, there are so many books I wouldn’t have been able to get here had it not been for the Amazon Kindle versions. So, I tell myself it’s the story that matters in the end, right?

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I’m dreadful with bookmarks – if somebody buys me one now as a gift I pointedly don’t use it – otherwise I’ll lose it – I put it somewhere safe (which I suppose defeats the object). Definitely a bonus for imports and like you say its the story that really matters.
      Lynn 😀

  13. mshannahw's avatar mshannahw

    I’ve not got an e-reader of any sort & don’t plan on getting one. For me, the main issue is price, as I get 90% of my books from the library – I’m not fussed about owning books (we don’t have much space & I have a bit of a hippy mentality of not wanting to be tied down by stuff, what you own ends up owning you & all that…) & I only buy them if I can’t get them from the library & then I buy them as cheap as possible & give them away afterwards (& we are on a limited income so I wouldn’t be able to afford to read nearly as much if I had to buy all my books!) – & of course I wouldn’t be able to do that with an e-reader. Yes, there are free e-books, but they’re not necessarily the same books that I actually want to read. & then there’s the cost of the e-reader in the first place, which is way more spare cash than I ever have hanging around!

    (This comment was sponsored by the & sign…)

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I admit that reading so much can become expensive. Sometimes I’m lucky and pick up books from the charity, occasionally I request ARCS, I always ask for book vouchers for birthdays, etc and, like you, I use the library. However, I’m far too impatient for the books that I SIMPLY MUST HAVE NOW! I actually checked out my reading habits last year and I think I had about 25% of my books from the library. Plus, space is an issue – but I do love to own the books that I really enjoyed.
      Lynn 😀

      • mshannahw's avatar mshannahw

        I’m so lucky with my library in that they do free reservations which you can “book” online. So I basically just order books up almost as though I was internet shopping & then go in & pick them up :D. I do sometimes have to wait a few weeks for books but unless they’re very new and very popular I usually get them within two weeks & often less 🙂

      • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

        I do that also – book online (it’s free at my library as well). The main problem is that sometimes I book a few books at the same time – because they’re already out etc, and then they all came in at once!!!
        Lynn 😀

  14. cherylmahoney's avatar cherylmahoney

    I can’t get over “they’re just not books” which is why I still have paper books!

    I also agree about how annoying it is that you can’t see what other people are reading. I hear the publishing industry worries about that–how do you build buzz when people can’t see each other’s choices?

    I don’t think covers will go away though (I don’t actually think paper books will go away!)…even online, books need pretty covers to entice readers in!

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I hope covers don’t go away – it’s a whole industry right there!
      I’m not surprised the publishing industry worry about the issue of people not being able to check out what others are reading – it’s sort of annoying if you’re a very curious (okay, nosey) person like I am!
      Lynn 😀

Leave a reply to jenclair Cancel reply