Beauty by Robin McKinley

I’ve been wanting to read this book for a long time.  A retelling of the story of Beauty and the Beast by Robin McKinley  Firstly, I think this is one of my favourite fairy tales.  It’s also probably my favourite Disney Film.  So I went in with fairly high expectations.

I actually know what it is about this tale that appeals to me. It’s the fact that somebody can see beneath the exterior to what lies within and love a person whether or not they’re attractive.  Plus, and I know this probably sounds unreasonable, but it always kind of reminds me of Jane Eyre.  Now, I know that’s probably a long stretch but I can’t help making the leap.

I’m fairly certain that everyone will know the story of Beauty and the Beast but for the avoidance of doubt it’s a fairy tale told at bedtime of a family whose fortunes take a downward turn.  The father and his three daughters (the mother having, I think, died in childbirth) have been brought up in comfort and style.  The father is a merchant with ships that he owns to trade his goods.  He becomes a victim of rough tides and loses his wealth.  The family then move to the country and live a much simpler life.  The father, on returning from a trip to the city, becomes lost and comes upon a dark and foreboding castle and yet he is looked after and fed (although he sees no sight of any person).  In the morning, upon leaving he takes a rose from the garden to give to his daughter (nicknamed Beauty – for obvious reasons).  Upon taking the rose there is an almighty roar and a huge beast appears and threatens to kill the man for abusing his trust and stealing the rose.  The beast demands that the man return in 30 days time – to die – or one of his daughters to take his place (not to die of course but to become a prisoner within the castle)!

That’s basically the gist of the story. In the retelling imagined by Robin McKinley there are a few differences.  Beauty has earned the nickname in spite of her looks as she is rather plain and unlike in the traditional tale her sisters are both pretty and fair tempered.  The family love each other dearly.  In accordance with the original tale their fortunes are lost but they actually then move to the country with a suitor of one of the sisters where they seem to live in relative happiness despite all their extra chores (which they are very unfamiliar with).  There is, of course, a foreboding forest – believed to be enchanted – to the rear of their cottage which nobody ever enters.  That is until the father does return to the City following the return of one of his ships.  On his return journey he does become lost and encounters the enchanted castle belonging to the beast.  From there onwards the story is fairly much as above with a few differences like a rather fascinating and enchanted library!

I really enjoyed this story.  McKinley has a quite enchanting voice.  I liked the fact that Beauty wasn’t actually as her name described.  She was actually much plainer than both her sisters although lets be clear here – she’s not ugly, hideous or a beast).  I liked this about the story – both of them had inhibitions to overcome.  I also liked the enchanted castle and the magical breezes that kept Beauty company.

Reading this again made me realise that in fact both Beauty and the Beast were lonely and in need of each other.  I’d never really picked that fact up before. Beauty, even in the more traditional stories, and certainly in this – was always different than the rest of her family.  Certainly not an outcast but definitely not the same.  The two characters seemed almost compelled to like each other just because of their differences.  When you consider the Disney film of the story – Beauty is lovely – and yet the entire village think she is ‘odd’ – simply because she reads!  They don’t truly accept her although they want to because she is so pretty (in fact in that tale her prettiness is almost a curse because it draws the wrong attention).  The beast on the other hand will never be accepted.  He’s far too scary and hideous.  It’s the two extremes and although one may seem more desirable than the other in actual fact neither of them truly fit.

I’ve rambled on a bit there and been led off course.  This is a lovely retelling of one of my favourite stories from a very good author.  If I had any criticism at all it would simply be for a little more of a dark gothicy feel.

Otherwise, I really enjoyed this and would have no hesitation in recommending.

I’m submitting this for my Once Upon a Time reading event being hosted by Carl at Stainless Steel Droppings under the category of fairy tale.


13 Responses to “Beauty by Robin McKinley”

  1. jenclair

    I really want to read this one. Your comment about the beast and Mr. Rochester has merit–I wouldn’t have thought of it, but can see the similarity.

    • lynnsbooks

      Aw thanks! There was one part of the story that just really put me in mind of the scene from Jane Eyre where Mr Rochester asks if Jane thinks he’s ugly! I couldn’t stop thinking of the comparison somehow.
      I hope you like it. I think it’s a really good retelling. It’s not as dark or gothic as I might have liked but it was a wonderful cross of the Disney film and Jane Eyre so it can’t be that bad!
      Lynn 😀

  2. Priya

    Sounds like a great book. Honestly, though, you had me at “enchanted library”! I do have it and I mean to read it sometime next month, and now I can’t wait. 🙂

    • lynnsbooks

      Yes – a library that has books from the future – imagine that!! Talk about your proper sci fi!!
      Hope you enjoy.
      Lynn 😀

  3. parichitasingh

    You have me now. I still haven’t decided which book I want to read for the fairtale genre, so I’m going to read this. It sounds quite intriguing.

    • lynnsbooks

      I liked it. I thought it was a good retelling but then I do like McKinley. I could have used a little bit more ‘dark’ but that’s not a big enough criticism to stop me enjoying this.
      I hope you enjoy it.
      Lynn 😀

  4. Keri B.

    Do a Top 10 Tuesday today! I want to see your list of unique books!

    • lynnsbooks

      Haha, Just done one now. Will have to come and check yours out now….

  5. cherylmahoney

    Jane Eyre is Beauty and the Beast!!! I can completely see that, and I never thought of it before…

    • lynnsbooks

      Or is it the other way round and Jane Eyre is Beauty and the Beast??
      Lynn 😀

  6. Risa

    Oh! I read this book only last week! I really enjoyed Mckinley’s writing style and the depth she gives to all her characters…including the supporting roles. I also noticed how, even extremely minor characters, were given so much personality with a mere line or two.

    *spoiler ahead!*

    Also, at the end when she finally looks at herself in a mirror I recalled that Beauty hadn’t seen her image in a mirror for nearly four years before then. Ever since they came to the country the only mirror in the cottage was in her sisters’ room, and she refused to look into it. When she returns to her family for that one week the only major difference they see in her is her height. Yet at the end of the story the readers, along with Beauty, realise that she is indeed a beauty herself! Her family, though, saw it all along….saw her becoming beautiful, that is. 🙂

    The end, I felt was a bit rushed. I wished she’d given so much more detail as in the rest of her story.

    • lynnsbooks

      I do like McKinley so party I wondered if I was just predisposed to like this so it’s good to hear that others like it so much as well. She has a lovely writing style and you’re right about the other characters being given depth.
      I guess that Beauty is truly in the eye of the beholder because she always thought she was plain and yet everyone else saw something different. Her aversion to mirrors was really funny! Yes, the ending could have been a bit longer but I suppose that really is a reflection of storytales – they always end rather abruptly!
      Lynn 😀

  7. Once upon a time…. they all lived happily ever after. The end. |

    […] Beauty by Robin McKinley – I lovely retelling of the Beauty and the Beast tale. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s