Shadow of the Sun readalong, by Barbara Friend Ish, week 3

This week is the third week of the Shadow of the Sun readalong being hosted by Dab of Darkness.  Check out the details here – there’s all sorts going on including a giveaway and free download of the book for the duration of the readalong.

If you haven’t joined in yet but still want to do so it’s not too late but if you are considering reading then read no further for there will be spoilers.

Up to this section, we believed the Basghilae could not cross water, but we learn to the detriment of our heroes that this is not so. What further hidden abilities do you think might crop up from these walking dead?

Well, lets give the wish list of haves and have nots.  I’m hoping that they don’t have a stash of rocket launchers!  I’m hoping that they don’t know magic!!  I’m hoping that they haven’t learn’t to teleport and I’m hoping that they haven’t learnt to mimic Ellion, Letitia or any of the others!!!

Probably not very useful (to them) but I’m hoping that they can make a mean apple pie, I’m hoping that they can talk fluent French and I’m also hoping that they’re all fully fledged members of their local library!  I’m guessing I’m not going to get lucky with the wish lists.  And for the avoidance of doubt this means I don’t really know – perhaps they can fly – that would be very bad – although, no, we’d already know because they wouldn’t have saved that beauty.

As the party enters the human lands, they come up with a cover story and request that Letitia remove her torc. She refuses. Do you think her decision was the correct one?

No.  Between Ellion refusing to use magic for everyone’s benefit and Letitia not taking simple precautions they’re really driving me bonkers.  Who needs enemies with these two around – they’re basically their own worst enemy all rolled up into one!  However, it does reinforce our theories that there’s something more to the Torc than meets the eye.

At one point Ellion lingers over the warding process, specifically warding Letitia, and how a person must be completely nude for wards to be put in place. I’m going to leave this one wide open for comment ;). 

I think it’s a good job that he didn’t get to ward Letitia because his mind wouldn’t be on the job.  I don’t think she’d be very protected at all.

Ellion makes a tough decision to leave the Tanaan and while he watches them leave he has a huge epiphany about his inner motives. How do you think this will affect his actions and motivations the rest of the book? 

Maybe he’ll start thinking things through a bit better.  I know, I probably sound harsh on him there but some of his decisions just infuriate me.  He refuses to use magic even though it would be VERY helpful.  Then he blames himself every time someone dies – why, these are warriors, they know what they’re facing and it’s their decision.  I don’t like Ellion taking on responsibility for them in this way – I don’t know why it just feels like it someone belittles their own actions and decisions.  Honestly, I don’t dislike Ellion but it’s pointless feeling guilt, particularly when you’re not prepared to do your utmost to help protect in the first place.  Sorry, is that really harsh??

We saw the Tanaan and Ellion in some interesting situations of a more personal nature in these chapters, from the Night Butterflies to cutting in at a dance. What did you make of these instances, what further cultural differences along these lines do you foresee happening, and have you ever been a part of such a situation? 

I thought the differences in culture that came across were really interesting to read about.  All the little talks about Night Butterflies or how to cut in on a dance.  What on earth was Ellion thinking giving Letitia one of the Night Butterflies scarves.  Surely we just read that those scarves are worn by all such women and are almost a means of recognising them – and there he goes and gives one to her!  What is he trying to say exactly ;D  Whether I’m in a different cultural situation or not one thing you can usually guarantee from me is to put my foot in it sooner or later (especially after I’m in my cups!)(I love that phrase by the way).

Once again, we were treated to some fight scenes. What stood out for you about these scenes?

I liked the way that Ellion and Amien managed to overcome their differences when it was needed.  They fell right back into their old fighting routines working as a team.  ‘Kachow! ‘ ‘Pow’.

10 Responses to “Shadow of the Sun readalong, by Barbara Friend Ish, week 3”

  1. barbarafriendish's avatar barbarafriendish

    Now I’m hungry for apple pie…

    So. Much. Snark. I’m dying laughing!
    All of you crack me up. Thanks so much for taking the time!

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Hey, I thought you were AWOL. Shouldn’t you be far away some place enjoying yourself?? Or is it not a vacation? Anyway, you still need to chill and enjoy yourself.
      I’m looking forward to seeing how this all ends – very curious about a couple of things to be sure!
      Lynn 😀

  2. nrlymrtl's avatar nrlymrtl

    It sounds like you are trying to turn the Basghilae into dateable men – apple pie, book nerd, French accent.

    I think you are right about Ellion up to this point. He needs a smack upside the head to reset his logic circuits.

    Hehe. I’m sure Letitia was wondering the same things about the scarf. Did Ellion mean this as a hint – that I have a tradeable or sellable item (virginity)? Poor Elion. He certainly means well, but then when he or someone else takes time to give his actions or words a second thought….well, why don’t these folks have the face palm? Ellion needs an expression like that.

    Yeah for Ellion and Amien working as a team instead of having an ongoing pissing contest!

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Actually, you’re right – the Basghilae could become quite the ‘thing’ with their French accents, plus we’d be able to discuss books – okay, no!
      Yes, no more peeing competitions. Bit of synchronised Basghilae fighting!
      Lynn 😀

      • suecccp's avatar suecccp

        I’d be concerned about finding fallen body parts in the apple pie . . . 😦

      • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

        Ew, crunch, crunch. Quite put me off apple pie now!
        Lynn 😀

  3. suecccp's avatar suecccp

    2. I couldn’t agree more: they standout anyway, so why would the torc make it any worse?

    3. She might be rather tired though . . . 😀

    4. That’s an interesting point! As far as I can tell, the majority of the Tanaan don’t even know that he is a wizard, so they don’t expect him to be able to do anything more than he has. I am also feeling the need to slap Ellion about a little.

    5. Yep: I thought the gift of a scarf that screams “I’m a whore!” was a little strange . . .

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      She would definitely be tired!
      It seems to me that the Tanaan are very grateful for what Ellion has done for them and like you say they don’t know he is capable for magic so they’re certainly not blaming him for not helping in that respect.
      That scarf – what was he really thinking!
      Lynn 😀

  4. Amy's avatar Amy

    Letitia and Ellion are sort of their own worst enemies aren’t they? I keep shaking my head at Ellion but even for all his faults (numerous!) I still like the guy. He keeps trying to do the right thing, unfortunately he keeps messing things up too. That scarf idea…

    Apple pie! If only we could get them baking. 🙂 I love your first answer.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I know – the two of them are both gagging to get into some serious trouble!
      Imagine the conversation : Ellion ‘Letitia I got you this lovely scarf’ Letitia ‘it’s beautiful wherever did you find it?’ A: ‘ahem, a, mmm, butterfly??’ Q: ‘a social butterfly?’ – A: ‘mmm, something like that’.
      Lynn 😀

Leave a reply to lynnsbooks Cancel reply