A Hatful of Sky by Terry Pratchett, readalong final instalment

And so we reach the end of our readalong of Terry Pratchett’s A Hatful of Sky.  This has been a great book for a readalong as it’s such good fun.  If you didn’t join in with the readalong then I would still recommend you read this series.  The Little Red Reviewer and Dab of Darkness have acted as hosts for this.  Questions and answer to follow but read no further if you don’t wish to encounter spoilers and if you do – don’t say I didn’t tell you so!:

1) Mistress Weatherwax has a philosophy of her job is to make sure everyone today can get to tomorrow – such as letting people believe in water sprites and goblins if it lets them lead a better life. Do you see yourself somewhere in this philosophy?

I suppose this is similar to ‘live and let live’ which I would say I do believe in also.  Absolutely let people believe in water sprites if they want – anyway, they’re real aren’t they????

2) Do you think Mr. Weavall will be successful with the Widow Tussy? Do you think Tiffany got off light concerning Mr. Weavall’s stash?

I think Mr Weavall and the Widow will be very happy and probably rack up another 100 years between them with this new lease of life!  I’m not sure about Tiffany getting off lightly really – at the end of the day the Hiver was controlling her – but, she does also realise that the Hiver is just fulfilling your own wishes – so really she did covet the money??  Anyway, she did feel really bad about her actions during the possession and I loved the fact that the Feegles helped her out with this – after all they weren’t using the money, other than for serving plates and they obviously didn’t want her to feel bad for stealing from Mr Weavall.

3) What was your favorite part of Mistress Weatherwax’s and Tiffany’s bonding time in the mountains with the little picnic and the owls and such?

I loved the way that Mistress Weatherwax was always being grumpy but then kind of looking askance at Tiffany to see how she was really reacting.  She tries to act like a real meanie but actually she’s not really.  I enjoyed the part where she was trying to sleep and attract the owl and Tiffany woke her up and scared away the owl.

4) Petulia Gristle heard Tiffany was going to face something nasty and went out to see if she could use some help. Have you ever had an awkward situation like that?

I thought that was really good of Petulia.  I knew she was a good character and I thought it was great when she finally plucked up enough courage to tell Annagramma off!  I don’t know if I’ve had an awkward situation like that – don’t get me wrong I end up in plenty of situations, usually embarrassing and probably more than my full share, but not really like this one.

5) Tiffany has her first and last conversation with the Hiver/Arthur. Did you see Tiffany’s answer to the Hiver dilemma coming or were you taken by surprise?

I was taken by surprise.  I never figured out the conclusion at all and I couldn’t piece together what all her talk about wishes was about.  I thought the conclusion was more satisfactory than with the Fairy Queen.  And, I liked that she helped Arthur instead of simply trying to destroy him.

6) The Witch Trials are almost like a county fair, a happy outing for the entire family, or so Granny Weatherwax was grumbling about. What about the affair caught your attention?

You wouldn’t think a bunch of witches at a trial would be a family occasion would you – you could be turned into a toad just for a bit of sport!  I suppose the Mexican standoff with Tiffany and GW was the most stand out part of the trials for me.  You could sort of cut the tension surrounding them as they shared that moment – I really liked that part and thought it was very wise of Tiffany to act as she did.

7) In the final chapter, we learn the meaning of the title of the book. Did you feel this was a good wrap up to the novel?

It was a very satisfying ending.  I liked the fact that she returned to the chalk  to help with the lambing and then created her own hat.  I thought it was interesting to see her changed feelings for Roland and also that he seems to be growing up and basically as with the last book I felt it was quite touching – the way everything returns to Granny Aching and the fact that Tiffany now seems to be taking her place in everyone’s eyes.

Thank you ladies for hosting both these readalongs and taking the time out to come up with all the questions.  It’s been very enjoyable and I’m looking forward to spending time with Tiffany again later in the year. 😀

14 Responses to “A Hatful of Sky by Terry Pratchett, readalong final instalment”

  1. Lisa (@EffingRainbow)'s avatar Lisa (@EffingRainbow)

    Water sprites are totally real! 😀

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I knew it! Now, what about these feegles – are they real or not?????
      Lynn 😀

  2. nrlymrtl's avatar nrlymrtl

    I agree. Water sprites are real – and they live in my ditch and the pond, occasionally stealing duck eggs.

    Yes, I totally love that Tiffany tried to help the Hiver instead of destroy it – something no one else has done for it/Arthur before.

    Yep, Granny Weatherwax was totally testing Tiffany with her grumbles. I think this is a good way to test folks and I am going to try to do more of it. I don’t expect I will have as much success as Weatherwax, but at least I will know that those left standing are tolerant folks.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Maybe you have your own Feegles and that’s where your eggs are going to! Either that, or have you been trying to make a shambles??
      Just imagine – if only they’d thought to help the Hiver sooner, a lot of those people could have been saved.
      Lynn 😀

  3. tethyanbooks's avatar tethyanbooks

    Interesting answers!

    1) I think I interpreted this differently! I agree that people are free to believe in water sprites and goblins if they like, but if they ask me why they need to move the privy away from the well, I’d explain bacteria every time. So, I’d agree with live and let live… but also live and give correct explanations for things.

    2) Tiffany did want awesome witchy clothes (after meeting Petulia & Co.), and she didn’t really have any money, so I could see her coveting Mr. Weavall’s money. I don’t think its anything Tiffany would have ever acted on, though. That was totally sweet of the Feegles, though (what a weird sentence, but they are sweet sometimes!)

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Well, sometimes you need straight talkers for sure. I think in terms of Mrs W and the way she tells people little porkies – I suppose she doesn’t always do that, maybe she just knows that sometimes it’s what will be needed – she certainly did a good bit of straight talking with Tiffany after all.
      Yes, she did covet the money but like you say I don’t think she would ever have acted upon it because she’s so proper. In the end it all worked out well with the Feegle’s intervention.
      Lynn 😀

  4. TBM's avatar TBM

    Just curious, how many groupreads can you do at one time? I love your dedication!

    • suecccp's avatar suecccp

      This week nrlymrtl and I had 4 . . . Mon, Weds, Fri and Sun . . . This is probably too many! 😀

      • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

        I agree – I’ve taken on a few too many – or more to the point not planned it properly so they’ve all occurred simultaneously! Better forward thinking next time.
        Lynn 😀

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Actually I confess I think I bit off more than I could chew this last few weeks. I only have one readalong now and a book tour and once they’re complete I’m having a bit of a break!
      Lynn 😀

  5. suecccp's avatar suecccp

    2. I found it interesting that the Feegles were just trying to help her out of trouble, but actually ended up making a lonely, old man very happy and giving him a new lease on life.

    3. I get the feeling that Granny Weatherwax always sees the teaching opportunity in everything and seizes it. It reminds me of something I read once about how to encourage your child to be intelligent: if it wants something from somewhere it can’t reach make it try to work out how to get it rather than simply handing it over. She refuses to make things easy for people and so she has a reputation for being mean, but it is just because she is trying to poke people into doing things for themselves.

    5. I agree that this ending was more satisfying than the defeat of the Fairy Queen because it actually did a kindness to the Hiver.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I think Tiffany is growing up a bit in this novel. It was interesting to see how she reacted to being in a different place and out of her comfort zone and particularly how she responded to meeting her peers where she was a bit like a fish out of water. I thought it also brought home to us that she wasn’t that comfortable around people and wasn’t used to being part of a larger society. I thought this book showed how she was drawn out of herself a little and all the teaching of being kind to others obviously worked – maybe she wouldn’t have thought to help the Hiver otherwise.
      Definitely a more satisfying ending – it’s funny because I really enjoyed the first book but this one was superior.
      Lynn 😀

  6. Redhead's avatar Redhead

    I also found the end of this book, especially the conclusion of the Hiver issue, to be more satisfying than the end of the first book. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoyed Wee Free Men, but I liked A Hat Full of Sky better.

    I really appreciate the relationship that forms between Tiffany and Granny Weatherwax. Tiffany realizes why GW is seen as aloof and a little mean: she’s not mean, she just has a LOT to protect and doesn’t want to let her guard down. When Granny Weatherwax meets her equals, she’s a very nice woman. She just doesn’t suffer fools lightly, or rather, at all.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      That’s what I like about GW – she doesn’t want people to creep to her. She wants genuine people and Tiffany stands up to her and says her piece and isn’t just bowled over with awe because of who it is. I think Tiffany also understands that about GW – that whole para where she’s almost saying that GW realises she’s at the top of the chain really and there is no challenge for her – it’s like she realises Tiffany is going to be good and wants to help her so that she’ll have somebody on a par. I also thought it was great that they didn’t go in for a load of cheap tricks at the trials just to please the other witches.
      A really enjoyable second book.
      Lynn 😀

Leave a reply to nrlymrtl Cancel reply