A Hatful of Sky by Terry Pratchett, week 2 readalong

Today marks the second week of the Hatful of Sky readalong being hosted by Little Red Reviewer and Dab of Darkness.  This week’s questions are from Dab of Darkness.  Beware of spoilers if you haven’t already read these stories (and if you haven’t, seriously, you should get onto them – they’re such good fun).

1) Awf’ly Wee Billy, the gonnagle, comes up with a plan, the PLN. First, do you like the basic idea? Second, what was your favorite part of the execution of the PLN?

The Plan was mental really – I’m trying to remember why they came up with the idea of dressing up as a man-come-scarecrow but it did make for some strange and funny reading – it just seemed to me that they travel so much faster just as themselves.  Obviously the part in the coach was very amusing – gradually all the other travellers removing themselves to sit atop – except for a few who couldn’t fit up there and those remaining few being privvy to a tantalising glimpse of the wee trouser occupant!  Thank goodness they had such a lot of gold coins!  I loved where the horse and cart is going faster than the carriage they’re trying to catch up to and actually takes over – there’s a lovely sort of irony.

2) Miss Level has a philosophy of ‘storing it in other people’. How do you like this philosophy and do you know any witchy people in life who might be secretly following it?  Miss Level has certainly got a lovely philosophy and a very caring attitude – not sure I’d be quite so generous spirited  – don’t get me wrong I’m not a meanie but she is just totally devoted to the people of the village and it’s really very time consuming.  It’s a whole new way of looking at how a witch gets on – here I was thinking they’d spend all their time cackling and cooking eye of newt and in actual fact she feels more like a cross between a district nurse with a hint of Lady Bountiful thrown in for good measure.  I don’t know if I know any witchy people but I certainly do know a couple of very thoughtful and kind people.

3) We finally get to meet some other witchlings, such as Petulia and Annagramma. What do you make of Tiffany’s first meeting with them?  I really have to hand it to Pratchett writing that whole scene of the original meeting, he does a terrific job of creating the type of bitchy high school mean girls.  Annagramma and her Earwig witch are both basically a big pair of bullies!  I must admit though that I was surprised when Tiffany met these girls – at first anyway.  She seemed so subdued and just immediately fit in with the group and acted in the same way as the rest of the girls.  At first I thought she was going to stand her ground and stick up for herself but then I figured she’s never been in a group like this before and she doesn’t really know how to act so she’s trying to act in line with the others.

4) The Hiver has finally found Tiffany and Miss Level has finally met the Feegle. How do you think Tiffany will fair against the Hiver and how much damage do you think will be done (either by the Hiver or the Feegle)?

I think Tiffany will fair okay with the Hiver but to be honest that’s only because I’m being a smarty pants and I figure she must get out of this situation in order to be present in book No.3 – yes, I realise that’s called cheating and not using my own brain/imagination but…. needs must when the devil vomits into your kettle!  I think the Hiver and the Feegles are equally capable of inflicting damage although the Feegle’s is not done maliciously.

I really enjoyed this week’s reading and must admit that this book feels a much stronger addition than the first – which I also really enjoyed but just think this one is definitely superior.

 

14 Responses to “A Hatful of Sky by Terry Pratchett, week 2 readalong”

  1. Redhead's avatar Redhead

    Sure, the Feegle could have traveled not in disguise, they could have just snuck onto a carriage, but come on, where is the fun in that?? 😀

    i do love all the things Miss Level does, but you hit it right on the head, it’s not that you or i are mean, it’s that were just not that devoted to the needs of other people. If a family member wants/needs me to pick up groceries, help them around the house, of course I’m going to do it! but some neighbor I barely know? probably not. I’m just not that good of a person.

    why couldn’t have the Hiver gotten Annagramma? she could have been improved by being taken over by a horrible and unkillable monster.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Yep, I’d definitely help somebody if they needed me to but I’m not the sort of person who it might naturally occur to – I think that’s probably because I already have a very busy life and there feels very little room to let anything else in! So usually things don’t just pop into my brain – I would probably need to be asked – it would be nice to be one of those genuinely thoughtful people but it seems its something I need to work a little bit at!
      Annagramma is a bit of a so and so really – unfortunately I don’t think she’s as powerful as Tiffany which seems to be what attracts the Hiver. This whole Hiver thing is one nasty creation! You do have to hand it to Pratchett!
      Lynn 😀

    • suecccp's avatar suecccp

      You are so right: what would be the fun in the Feegles NOT making a huge performance out of something as simple as catching a sneaky lift on a cart or stage coach. That would be too boring and wouldn’t leave the same trail of psychologically scared people in its wake! 😀

      I guess that the Hiver ignored Anna’ because she is such a pathetic witch with minimal power . . . boo! 😦

  2. TBM's avatar TBM

    I was in the library yesterday and saw shelves of Prachett’s books, which surprised me since my library doesn’t have a wide selection. I wonder if the head librarian is a huge fan.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      Ha ha, it sounds possible! Although there are such a lot of them – apparently though the Discworld series is not something that you need to read the entire series or indeed in order for that matter. I quite like that you can dip in and out.
      Lynn 😀

      • suecccp's avatar suecccp

        According to Wikipedia, the next Discworld book is number 40, so even half of them would look like a full shelf! I imagine that they are very popular and that is helped precisely because you can dip in and out of the series without getting too hung up on the reading order.

  3. suecccp's avatar suecccp

    1. It would have been so much easier if they had just let Henry carry on past the stage coach . . . and he could have shown off some more for the lady horses! 😀

    2. It is almost like she is the glue holding the community together, acting as doctor, social worker, vet, care-giver and many other people rolled into one. It makes me wonder if she is typical of all witches, and how a village without a witch can cope.

    3. Mr Pratchett did really nail the whole bullying concept. I also thought that Tiffany would knock some sense into the other girls and overthrow the terrible Anna’. I was surprised and disappointed that she was so overwhelmed that she caved to peer pressure just like the other girls. However, I thought that it was a good choice for the author to make as it made Tiffany a much more rounded character, exposing her vulnerability when she is in new situations. We are seeing her totally removed from her comfort zone and she has still not adjusted to it.

    4. I agree: intellectually I know that Tiffany has to escape in order to continue in the series . . . but this doesn’t reduce the anxiety that I feel for her or help me to guess at how she will win the day.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      You’ve got to love Pratchett – he’s as crazy as can be – he just throws stuff in there for the pure mania of it. Like Henry actually going faster than the carriage! Or the wee men dressing up as a scarecrow so they could board the carriage! Imaging seeing that sight walking down the street – would you run in the opposite direction or what?
      The bullying chapter was really well done I thought, and, a bit like you, at first I was thinking ‘that’s not like Tiffany’ on reflection I think it made her more realistic.
      Even though I sort of know Tiffany will be okay I do still wonder exactly what is going to come next.
      Lynn 😀

  4. Allie's avatar Allie

    “it just seemed to me that they travel so much faster just as themselves” You know, I think you’re right. Didn’t we learn before that they move so quickly the human eye can’t follow them? Maybe they’re only sprinters, and can’t handle the long distances?

    I felt really sad for how Tiffany buckled to Annagramma… but I agree, she’d never experienced this kind of behavior before, so it makes sense she doesn’t know how to deal with it.

    I am really looking forward to seeing what happens in the second half of this book! So much has happened already.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I know – it does seem to be much faster for them to travel by their own steam – but I think it’s all part of Pratchett’s not fitting in with expectations and just chucking in such oddities that you’d never guess. I certainly never saw that whole scarecrow thing coming! But it was pretty funny and just added a whole ridiculous but amusing feel to the whole adventure.
      Re Tiffany: I felt really surprised at first but then I just figured she’s finally around a bunch of her peers and she just doesn’t know what to expect.
      I’ve already read some of the next chapters – I might be tempted to just finish the whole thing!
      Lynn 😀

  5. nrlymrtl's avatar nrlymrtl

    While I love this book and the Feegle PLN, I too always wondered why they didn’t travel through dreams or simply sprint to the mountains. Perhaps their magic doesn’t work so good off the Chalk, or can only be used for short periods?

    ‘needs must when the devil vomits into your kettle’ ?!? *falls over in a fit of giggles*

    Yep, the books get better as the series goes forward. Not that I dislike any of them or feel that any one is inferior – but I can see how Pratchett really settled into these characters and they became stronger and more entertaining as we go forward.

    • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

      I think Pratchett just comes across as very random the way he thinks of just bizarre things to include – yes, the Feegle’s could have probably ran faster than the carriage but it would have been a lot less fun that way – also it sort of keeps you guessing because he’s definitely not predictable. I love his whole sense of humour which to me feels along a similar vein to Monty Python – which is also totally zany and madcap.
      I hope you’re feeling better? Did the strawberries have a positive effect?
      Lynn 😀

      • nrlymrtl's avatar nrlymrtl

        Strawberries always have a positive effect :). Yes, I am feeling a little better. Still resting this weekend. Which means more reading – yeah!

      • @lynnsbooks's avatar lynnsbooks

        Yay!

Leave a comment